HABITAT SELECTION AND COMPETITION AMONG SIBLING SPECIES OF SATYRID BUTTERFLIES
Arthur M. Shapiro,R. Cardé
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1558-5646.1970.tb01739.x
1970-03-01
Evolution; international journal of organic evolution
Abstract:standing on morphological as well as ecological grounds (Carde, Shapiro, and Clench, in prep.). Museum series reveal that the two species are sympatric throughout the northeastern United States, south to the southern boundary of the range of eurydice at about 40° north latitude. Only appalachia has been found in the southeastern United States (Figs. 1, 2). Woodland reports anywhere in the range probably refer to appalachia. We have examined a specimen of this species collected at the locality where Saunders found "eurydice" in a New York woodland in 1928 (Saunders, 1932) . The differences between the species are slight but consistent, and include the ground color and details of the ventral lines (Fig. 3). Field observations of contiguous sympatric populations were made in New York State at the Oak Orchard Swamp, Genesee County; Sapsucker Woods and the McLean Bogs Reserve, Tompkins County; and Texas Hollow, Schuyler County. Populations at McLean and Texas Hollow were large enough for quantitative studies of distribution by habitat to be made. We have notes from collectors extending our observations to western Pennsylvania, northern New Jersey, and central Michigan. We have also observed the same phenomena in southeastern Pennsylvania and southern New Jersey. A third species belonging to a different group in the genus also occurs in New York. Lethe portlandia anthedon Clark is a well-known woodland butterfly (Scudder, 1889; Edwards, 1897; Klots, 1951) which occurs in all four of our New York study areas, frequently but not invariably associated with L. appalachia. Groups of sibling species are frequently detected first by field workers observing ecological differences among them. Mayr (1963) observed that "even in the exceedingly well-knownbutterfly fauna of eastern North America, sibling species are still being discovered." In 1968 we found striking behavioral disassociation in satyrid butterflies of the genus Lethe in central and western New York that led to the recognition of a new sibling species (Carde, Shapiro, and Clench, in prep.). Partitioning of the environment among three related species is correlated with larval food plant preferences, and appears to prevent interspecific competition. Lethe eurydice Johansson is a common butterfly of the northeastern United States, where its habitat is usually described as sedge marsh or wet meadow (Harris, 1862; Klots, 1951). There are, however, occasional reports of the insect from wooded sites (Edwards, 1897; Saunders, 1932). The first population discovered on the southeastern coastal plain was described by Smyth (1890), who found the insects deep in a cypress swamp. Similar habitats for southern populations were subsequently described by other authors (Clark and Clark, 1951; Harris, 1951). Chermock (1947) described Lethe eurydice appalachia as a geographic subspecies and cited localities from the southern Appalachian mountains, the coastal plain, and the Piedmont plateau near Washington, D.C. Masters (1967) reported L. e. appalachia from an "upland wooded environment" in Anoka County, Minnesota. We found appalachia sympatric with nominate eurydice in Pennsylvania and New York and have determined its specific