Processing, thermal, and mechanical issues in shape deposition manufacturing
F. Prinz,L. Weiss,C. Amon,J. Beuth
DOI: https://doi.org/10.15781/T20G3HH4W
Abstract:An overview of Shape Deposition Manufacturing (SDM) is presented, detailing manufacturing, thermal and mechanical issues of concern in making it a commercially viable method for creating arbitrarily shaped three-dimensional metal parts. SDM is a layered manufacturing process which combines the benefits of solid freeform fabrication and other processing operations, such as multi-axis CNC machining. This manufacturing process mates possible the fabrication of multi-material layers, structures of arbitrary geometric complexity, artifacts with controlled microstructures, and the embedding of electronic components and sensors in conformal shape structures. To minimize cost, SDM is implemented using primarily commercially available hardware and CAD modeling and planning software. Important issues toward the production of high quality objects are the creation of inter-layer metallurgical bonding through substrate remelting, the control of cooling rates of both the substrate and the deposition material, and the minimization of residual thermal stress effects. Brief descriptions of thermal and mechanical modeling aspects of the process are also given. Because SDM involves molten metal deposition, an understanding of thermal aspects of the process is crucial. Current thermal modeling of the process is centered on the issue of localized remelting of previously deposited material by newly deposited molten droplets. Residual stress build-up is inherent to any manufacturing process based on successive deposition of molten material. Current mechanics modeling is centered on the issue of residual stress build-up and its potential effects, including part warping and debonding between deposited layers. Shot peening is an operation currently used to control residual stress effects and preliminary work studying its effects is also presented.* 1. Shape Deposition Manufacturing Process Description Shape Deposition Manufacturing (SDM) (refer to Fig. 1) is a layered manufacturing process which systematically combines the benefits of Solid Freeform Fabrication (SFF) (Le., quickly planned, independent of geometry, multi-material deposition, and component embedding), with other intermediate processing operations such as CNC machining (i.e., for accuracy and precision with good surface quality), thermal deposition (i.e., to produce fully dense structures), and shot peening (Le., for stress control) (Merz et al, 1994). Like conventional SFF processes, SDM builds shapes using a layered material deposition approach. After each layer (or layer segment) is deposited, however, the part may be transferred to other processing stations where additional operations are performed on that layer. The basic strategy is to first slice the CAD model of the shape to be fabricated into layers while maintaining the corresponding outer surface geometry information. Layer thickness varies depending on the part geometry. Each layer consists of primary material(s) (i.e., the material(s) forming the part being created) and complementary shaped * This wok has been supported by the Engineering Design Research Center, a NSF Engineering Research Center. sacrificial support structure material which is removed when the entire part is completed. Each material in each layer is then deposited as a near-net shape using thermal deposition as described below. The sequence for depositing the primary and support materials is dependent upon the local geometry and the material combinations and is also described below in more detail. After deposition, the layer is then precisely shaped to net shape with a 5-axis CNC milling machine or EDM, for example, before proceeding with the next intermediate processing operation or layer. The 5-axis machining eliminates the stair-step surface appearance common to conventional SFF technologies. Microcast 5-Axis CNC Mill ShotPeen Integrate Sensors Deposit • Shape • Control Stress • Embed Figure 1. Shape Deposition Manufacturing Internal residual stresses build up as each new layer is deposited due to differential contraction and thermal gradients between the freshly deposited molten material and the previously solidified layer. Internal stresses can lead to warping and to delamination. To control stress-induced warping, each layer is also shot-peened. Small round metal spheres (called 'shot') are projected at a high velocity against the surface in a blasting cabinet The complex state of stress in deposited layers makes difficult the evaluation of the effect of peening on the state of residual stress. It is clear, however, that peening imparts a compressive load which counters warping due to the net tensile load in die newly deposited top layer. Building shapes with deposition also permits pre-formed, discrete components or assemblies to be fully embedded within the growing structure. For example, sensors can be placed throughout the structure to provide feedback for subsequent deposition process control, and when the part is operational these sensors can provide feedback on part integrity and operational parameter status. 1.1 Adaptive Shape Decomposition In SDM there are several feasible sequences for depositing and shaping each layer. The basic sequence which we use for building a single-material part is described below and shown in Fig. 2. Variations of this sequence, which will be discussed later, may be required to improve overall process performance and part quality. Both Undercuts No under-cuts