Alcoholics' perceptions of group therapy and Alcoholics Anonymous.

F. W. Obitz,J. D. Wood,N. Cantergiani
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1360-0443.1977.TB00698.X
1977-04-01
British Journal of Addiction
Abstract:Summary Sixty-four alcoholics were asked to rate their perceptions of group therapy and Alcoholics Anonymous on thirty variables. Data from half of the subjects were collected by a recovering alcoholic; data from the other half of the subjects were collected by a non-alcoholic. When the recovering alcoholic served as experimenter, A.A. was rated as more socially desirable than group therapy and group therapy was rated significantly higher on negative attributes than A. A. When the non-alcoholic served as experimenter, group therapy and A.A. were rated about equally. Subjects significantly reported to the recovering alcoholic that they preferred A. A. as the treatment of choice; conversely they reported to the non-alcoholic that they preferred group therapy as the treatment of choice. The differences in alcoholics' perceptions of group therapy and A.A. were highlighted and discussed in terms of demand characteristics. How alcoholics perceived treatment was intimately tied to who did the asking.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?