Changes in Beliefs About Post-Transplant Immunosuppressants Over Time and Its Relation to Medication Adherence and Kidney Graft Dysfunction: A Follow-Up Study
Barbora Kostalova,Katerina Mala-Ladova,Ales Antonin Kubena,Rob Horne,Sylvie Dusilova Sulkova,Josef Maly,Ales Antonín Kubena
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S344878
2022-01-01
Patient Preference and Adherence
Abstract:Barbora Kostalova, 1 Katerina Mala-Ladova, 1 Ales Antonin Kubena, 1 Rob Horne, 2 Sylvie Dusilova Sulkova, 3 Josef Maly 1 1 Department of Social and Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy in Hradec Kralove, Charles University, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic; 2 Centre for Behavioural Medicine, UCL School of Pharmacy, University College London, London, UK; 3 Hemodialysis Centre, University Hospital Hradec Kralove, Hradec Kralove, Czech Republic Correspondence: Katerina Mala-Ladova Department of Social and Clinical Pharmacy, Faculty of Pharmacy in Hradec Kralove, Charles University, Ak. Heyrovskeho 1203/8, Hradec Kralove, 500 05, Czech Republic Tel +420 495 067 486 Email Purpose: The main aim was to evaluate the changes in beliefs about immunosuppressants over a 3-year period in patients after kidney transplantation. The second aim was to investigate the relationship between beliefs, medication adherence, and selected clinical outcomes such as graft functioning. Patients and Methods: This observational follow-up study was conducted in the outpatient post-transplant clinic at the University Hospital Hradec Kralove in the Czech Republic. Adult patients, at least 4 weeks after kidney transplantation, were invited for the structured interview, which was followed by a self-administered questionnaire survey during their regularly scheduled visits at the clinic. Appropriate paired tests were used to compare two measurements of beliefs about immunosuppressants by BMQ-CZ© in 2016 (baseline) and in 2019 (follow-up). Self-reported adherence was measured by two validated tools (MARS-CZ© and BAASIS©) capturing implementation and discontinuation phases. A generalized linear model was used to investigate the relation between beliefs and the consecutive estimated glomerular filtration rate. Results: The study involved 134 patients. Over time, their perceived treatment necessity beliefs of immunosuppressants decreased, while their treatment-related concerns increased. Overall self-reported non-adherence (ie, taking, dosing and discontinuation of immunosuppressants) was reported by 12% of the patients in both observation periods. In the follow-up period, timing non-adherence was reported by 52 (38.8%) patients. Higher baseline treatment concerns were associated with poor adherence whereas higher baseline treatment necessity beliefs corresponded with better kidney functioning, even after adjusting for age. Conclusion: Higher treatment necessity beliefs corresponded with better kidney functioning, whereas higher treatment concerns were related to non-adherence to immunosuppressants at the beginning of the observed period. Still, most patients accepted their medicines that do not come without risk. Nevertheless, decreasing treatment necessity beliefs on one hand, and increasing treatment concerns on the other, should be considered in clinical practice. Keywords: kidney transplantation, immunosuppressants, treatment necessity beliefs, treatment concerns, medication adherence Kidney transplant (KTx) is the most cost-effective treatment option for patients with end-stage renal failure. KTx significantly improves life expectancy, quality of life and reduces financial burdens on the health care system, leading to an increasing number of procedures worldwide. 1–4 However, it is essential that patients manage a complex life-long therapeutic plan and attend medical follow-ups after KTx with emphasis on strict medication adherence. Medication adherence is defined as "the process by which patients take their medications as prescribed, composed of initiation, implementation and discontinuation". 5 Focusing on implementation patterns regarded as vital for immunosuppressive regimens, non-adherence may reach up to 17.4% and increases over time post-transplant. 6–9 It is well known that many factors may influence implementation non-adherence. Factors at higher levels (ie, structural characteristics and practice patterns), however, do not differ within the same KTx follow-up care. Considering all the patient-related factors in general, beliefs about the medicines seem to play a decisive role. 10–12 Usually, regardless of the level of adherence, patients themselves develop their own beliefs and attitudes towards the medication over time. This is supported by a recent meta-analysis involving 94 studies across 18 countries, showing that adherence to long-term medications was often related to patients' beliefs about treatment where low adherence is linked to doubts about the personal feeling of need for the medication (treatment necessity beliefs) and the concerns about the potential adverse consequences (tr -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal