Abstract:Behavioral Economics has in recent years played a key role in informing the design of non-price interventions aimed at promoting energy conservation behaviors in residential housing. Some of the most influential contributions of the discipline in an applied setting have centered around the development of norm-based interventions. The success that these interventions have had in specific contexts presents an opportunity to exploit them as tools for tackling a prevalent type of poverty at the EU level: energy poverty. Recent contributions to the literature highlight the role of inefficient energy behavior as a significant driver of this particular type of poverty, which is characterized by an inability to afford the basic energy services necessary to guarantee a decent standard of living. Therefore, the effectiveness of norm-based interventions in vulnerable populations merits further investigation to determine whether this approach can suitably address the behavioral components of energy poverty by promoting efficient energy consumption and conservation efforts. This study reports on a pilot conducted in an exemplary social housing context (located in Bolzano, Italy) with the aim to assess the effectiveness of social comparison interventions in energy vulnerable groups. Our investigated cohort covers an initial small sample of apartments with a large representatives of elderly individuals and other energy-vulnerable groups. Using a design that combines appeals to injunctive and descriptive norms embedded within In-Home Devices (IHD) in recently retrofitted homes, our objective is to set a basis for the assessment of effectiveness of these types of interventions in social housing populations. Our study seeks to provide useful methodological insights to policy makers on how to effectively design behaviorally informed interventions aimed at tackling energy poverty. Despite the current data limitations, our results do seem to suggest that uniformly applied norm-based interventions may have potentially backfiring effects in small-scale implementations. Therefore, they suggest that attention needs to be paid to household composition and pre-existing levels of consumption, when designing behavior-change interventions in these groups. JEL Classification : C93; D03; D04; D12; D19; D91; Q40.

For cash, the planet, or for both: Evaluating an informational intervention for energy consumption reduction

CEP Discussion Paper No 1602 February 2019 Making Smart Meters Smarter the Smart Way

Ecological-behavioral economics: Impact of information on energy-renovation decision through third-party investing

The Effect of Information Nudges on Energy Saving: Observations from a Randomized Field Experiment in Finland

Reducing hot water consumption through real-time feedback and social comparison using persuasive technologies: evidence from a Swiss energy-efficient district

Effectiveness of an Energy-Counseling Intervention in Reducing Energy Poverty: Evidence from a Quasi-Experimental Study in a Southern European City

Carbon literacy – Can simple interventions help? Effect of information provision on emissions knowledge of private households

Beyond short-term savings: A ten-year analysis of energy efficiency program outcomes in swiss households

Residents' Participation in Energy Performance Certification for Collective Action on Climate Change: the Case of EnerGuide.

Tackling Energy Poverty Through Behavioral Change: A Pilot Study on Social Comparison Interventions in Social Housing Districts

Norms, prices, and commitment: A comprehensive overview of field experiments in the energy domain and treatment effect moderators

Increasing retrofit device adoption in social housing: evidence from two field experiments in Belgium

Distinguishing between Low- and High-Cost Pro-Environmental Behavior: Empirical Evidence from Two Complementary Studies

Norm proximity and optimal social comparisons for energy conservation behavior

Effects of Monetary Versus Environmental Information Framing: Implications for Long-Term Pro-Environmental Behavior and Intrinsic Motivation

Analysis of social–Psychological factors and financial incentives in demand response and residential energy behavior

Understanding the factors that affect households’ investment decisions required by the energy transition

The Influence of Information Intervention Cognition on College Students’ Energy-Saving Behavior Intentions

Determinants of Willingness to Participate in Urban Incentive-Based Energy Demand-Side Response: An Empirical Micro-Data Analysis

Awareness and Utilization of Incentive Programs for Household Energy-Saving Renovations: Empirical Findings from Greece

Social norms, pro-environmental identity, and finances: what motivates households to participate in energy efficiency programs?