Abstract:Differential migratory strategies may impose varying selective pressures. While tracking technologies provide valuable information, they typically involve a limited number of individuals and may yield biased conclusions when data are only accessible upon individual recapture. We incorporated tracking information into a long‐term individual database and used Hidden Markov Models to examine wintering philopatry and to test whether individual preferences contribute to adult survival heterogeneity. Our study reveals that winter oceanographic conditions play a critical role in driving survival heterogeneity. Additionally, over the last two decades, some individuals have wintered in less suitable areas, with significant consequences for adult survival—a parameter to which the population growth rate is most sensitive in long‐lived species. Seasonal migration has evolved as an adaptation for exploiting peaks of resource abundance and avoiding unfavourable climatic conditions. Differential migratory strategies and choices of wintering areas by long‐distance migratory species may impose varying selective pressures and mortality risks with fitness consequences. Recently developed tracking technologies allow wintering movements of migratory species to be studied. However, these technologies typically involve a limited number of tracked individuals, which gives low statistical power for any robust estimate of survival probabilities. Additionally, when utilising geolocators, data become accessible only upon individual recapture, presenting a potential source of bias. We used multievent modelling to include information of 147 identified wintering tracks in the analysis of 1104 long‐term individual capture histories (2000–2022) of migratory seabird Calonectris diomedea and then test if individual preferences for wintering areas may drive heterogeneity in adult survival. We also examined individual fidelity to wintering areas and tested if climatic and oceanographic conditions, as represented by the wNAO and SOI climatic indices, influenced survival and fidelity. The probability of fidelity to a wintering area was ca. 0.79. Annual changes between areas were influenced by environmental variability driven by the wNAO. Survival probability was influenced by the SOI and differed between wintering areas; these differences coupled with high wintering site fidelity, generated individual heterogeneity in adult survival. Our study reveals that, over the last two decades, some individuals wintered in less suitable areas, with nonnegligible consequences on adult survival, the parameter to which the population growth rate is most sensitive in long‐lived species. Winter oceanographic conditions such as stormy weather or the proximity to upwellings probably play a relevant role in driving survival heterogeneity. Further research is needed to enhance our understanding of how the interlinked effects of climate, local selective pressures and individual condition shape population dynamics in migratory species.

Intracolony variability in winter feeding and migration strategies of Atlantic puffins and black-legged kittiwakes

Breeding stage and tissue isotopic consistency suggests colony-level flexibility in niche breadth of an Arctic marine bird

Energetic consequences of contrasting winter migratory strategies in a sympatric Arctic seabird duet

Evidence of colony- and individual-level variation in habitat usage of Atlantic Puffins (Fratercula arctica)

Winter-ground microhabitat use by differently coloured phenotypes affects return rate in a long-distance migratory bird

Is individual consistency in body mass and reproductive decisions linked to individual specialization in foraging behavior in a long‐lived seabird?

Geolocator-tracking seabird migration and moult reveal large-scale, temperature-driven isoscapes in the NE Atlantic

Oceanographic drivers of winter habitat use in Cassin's Auklets

Individual variation in migratory movements of chinstrap penguins leads to widespread occupancy of ice-free winter habitats over the continental shelf and deep ocean basins of the Southern Ocean

Behavioural flexibility in an Arctic seabird using two distinct marine habitats to survive the energetic constraints of winter

Inter-population synchrony in adult survival and effects of climate and extreme weather in non-breeding areas of Atlantic puffins

Multiple methods of diet assessment reveal differences in Atlantic puffin adult and chick diets both between and within years

Individual Choices of Wintering Areas Drive Adult Survival Heterogeneity in a Long‐Lived Seabird

Multiple methods of diet assessment reveal differences in Atlantic puffin diet between ages, breeding stages, and years

Stay or go? Changing breeding conditions affect sexual difference in colony attendance strategies of Atlantic puffins Fratercula arctica

Differential Responses of Arctic Vegetation to Nutrient Enrichment by Plankton- and Fish-Eating Colonial Seabirds in Spitsbergen

Hierarchical foraging strategies of migratory short-tailed shearwaters during the non-breeding stage

Ice type matters: impacts of landfast and drift ice on body condition in a high Arctic seabird community

Plastic Behaviour Buffers Climate Variability in the Wandering Albatross

Changes in Behaviour and Proxies of Physiology Suggest Individual Variation in the Building of Migratory Phenotypes in Preparation for Long-Distance Flights

Influence of sea ice concentration, sex and chick age on foraging flexibility and success in an Arctic seabird