Abstract:Densely populated deltas are so vulnerable to sea level rise and climate change that they cannot wait for global mitigation to become effective. The Netherlands therefore puts huge efforts in adaptation research and planning for the future, for example through the national research programme Knowledge for Climate and the Delta Programme for the Twenty-first century. Flood risk is one of the key issues addressed in both programmes. Adaptive management planning should rely on a sound ex-ante policy analysis which encompasses a future outlook, establishing whether a policy transition is required, an assessment of alternative flood risk management strategies, and their planning in anticipation without running the risk of regret of doing too little too late or too much too early. This endeavour, addressed as adaptive delta management, calls for new approaches, especially because of uncertainties about long-term future developments. For flood risk management, it also entails reconsideration of the underlying principles and of the application of portfolios of technical measures versus spatial planning and other policy instruments. To this end, we first developed a conceptualisation of flood risk which reconciles the different approaches of flood defence management practice and spatial planning practice in order to bridge the gap between these previously detached fields. Secondly, we looked abroad in order to be better able to reflect critically on a possible Dutch bias which could have resulted from many centuries of experience of successful adaptation to increasing flood risk, but which may no longer be sustainable into the future. In this paper, we explain the multiple conceptualisation of flood risk and argue that explicitly distinguishing exposure determinants as a new concept may help to bridge the gap between engineers and spatial planners, wherefore we show how their different conceptualisations influence the framing of the adaptation challenge. Also, we identify what the Netherlands may learn from neighbouring countries with a different framing of the future flood risk challenge.

Planning for Adaptation? Examining the Planning Integration for Hazard Risk Reduction

A Study on Climate Resilient City and Urban Planning

Institutional Foundations of Adaptive Planning: Exploration of Flood Planning in the Lower Rio Grande Valley, Texas, USA

Responding strategically to natural hazards: the role of hazard experience, infrastructure vulnerability, and risk perception in transit agency coordination with stakeholders

How well are US communities planning for resilience, climate adaptation, and sustainability—and what's missing? Results of a national survey of local staff and officials

Integrated Framework for Emergency Shelter Planning Based on Multihazard Risk Evaluation and Its Application: Case Study in China

Enhancing urban flood resilience: interdisciplinary integration of climate adaptation, flood control, and land-use planning from 3PA to 4PA

How Plans Prepare for Future Uncertainty: Integrating Land Change Modeling and the Plan Integration for Resilience ScorecardTM

Strategic hazard mitigation planning

Multi-stage planning of LID-GREI urban drainage systems in response to land-use changes

Integrated Risk Assessment and Management Methods Are Necessary for Effective Implementation of Natural Hazards Policy

Steps Towards Modeling Community Resilience under Climate Change: Hazard Model Development

Managing systemic risk in emergency management, organizational resilience and climate change adaptation

LOCAL PLANNING ACTION FOR ADDRESSING GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE:DILEMMAS BETWEEN MITIGATION AND ADAPTATION

Study on Adapting Urban Comprehensive Disaster Prevention Plan to Climate Change

Operational Networks: Adaptation to Extreme Events in China

Adaptive flood risk management planning based on a comprehensive flood risk conceptualisation

Evaluating Urban Heat Mitigation across Networks of Plans

Collaborative Planning in Adaptive Flood Risk Management under Climate Change

Strengthening opportunities to integrate informal resilience practices in formal flood resilience planning

Enhancing Sustainability and Resilience through Multi-Level Infrastructure Planning