Abstract:Trying to answer the question posed in the title, we have carried out a detailed theoretical investigation of the biologically important mechanism of the tautomerization of the A·T Watson-Crick DNA base pair, information that is hard to establish experimentally. By combining theoretical investigations at the MP2 and density functional theory levels of QM theory with quantum theory of atoms in molecules analysis, the tautomerization of the A·T Watson-Crick base pair by the double proton transfer (DPT) was comprehensively studied in vacuo and in the continuum with a low dielectric constant (ϵ = 4) corresponding to a hydrophobic interfaces of protein-nucleic acid interactions. Based on the sweeps of the electron-topological, geometric, and energetic parameters, which describe the course of the tautomerization along its intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC), it was proved that the A·T → A(∗)·T(∗) tautomerization through the DPT is a concerted (i.e. the pathway without an intermediate) and asynchronous (i.e. protons move with a time gap) process. The limiting stage of this phenomenon is the final PT along the N6H⋯O4 hydrogen bond (H-bond). The continuum with ϵ = 4 does not affect qualitatively the course of the tautomerization reaction: similar to that observed in vacuo, it proceeds via a concerted asynchronous process with the same structure of the transition state (TS). For the first time, the nine key points along the IRC of the A·T base pair tautomerization, which could be considered as electron-topological "fingerprints" of a concerted asynchronous process of the tautomerization via the DPT, have been identified and fully characterized. These nine key points have been used to define the reactant, TS, and product regions of the DPT in the A·T base pair. Considering the energy dependence of each of the three H-bonds, which stabilize the Watson-Crick and Löwdin's base pairs, along the IRC of the tautomerization, it was found that all these H-bonds in the А·Т base pair are cooperative, reinforcing each other, whereas the C2H⋯O2 H-bond in the А(∗)·Т(∗) base pair behaves anticooperatively, in other words it gets weakened while two others get strengthened. From a quantum-mechanical point of view, the A(∗)·T(∗) Löwdin's base pair appeared to be dynamically unstable because the electronic energy of the back-reaction barrier of the A·T → A(∗)·T(∗) tautomerization does not exceed zero-point vibrational energy associated with the mode for which vibrational frequency becomes imaginary in the TS of tautomerization. Additionally, it was demonstrated using the conductor-like polarizable continuum model that the effects of biomolecular environment (ϵ = 4) cannot ensure dynamic stabilization of the A(∗)·T(∗) Löwdin's base pair. These findings, together with data available from the literature, indicate that the tautomerization of the A·T Watson-Crick base pair to the A(∗)·T(∗) Löwdin's base pair through the DPT cannot be a source of spontaneous point errors that occur during DNA replication.

Amplificative–dissipative tunneling: the problem of genetic mutation

An Open Quantum Systems approach to proton tunnelling in DNA

Spontaneous Mutations from Terahertz Proton Tunneling

Tautomeric Transitions in DNA

Multiscale simulations reveal the role of PcrA helicase in protecting against spontaneous point mutations in DNA

A review on point mutations via proton transfer in DNA base pairs in the absence and presence of electric fields

Dynamics of spontaneous mutations: implications of guanine–cytosine tautomers on chromatin integrity

Can tautomerization of the A·T Watson–Crick base pair via double proton transfer provoke point mutations during DNA replication? A comprehensive QM and QTAIM analysis

The Importance of DNA Repair in Tumor Suppression

Mutagenesis and Metallic DNA

Metastable Hydrogen-bonds Featuring Negative Dissociation Energies in Protein-bound DNA in Hole Migration

Electronic and Nuclear Quantum Effects on Proton Transfer Reactions of Guanine–Thymine (G-T) Mispairs Using Combined Quantum Mechanical/Molecular Mechanical and Machine Learning Potentials

Oxidative thymine mutation in DNA: water-wire-mediated proton-coupled electron transfer

Concerted motion of protons in hydrogen bonds of DNA-type molecules

Novel pathway for mutagenic tautomerization of classical А∙Т DNA base pairs via sequential proton transfer through quasi-orthogonal transition states: A QM/QTAIM investigation

Premelting Thermal Fluctuational Interbase Hydrogen-Bond Disrupted States of a B-DNA Guanine-Cytosine Base Pair: Significance for Amino and Imino Proton Exchange.

TOWARD THE MECHANISM OF LONG-RANGE CHARGE TRANSFER IN DNA: THEORIES AND MODELS

Deep proton tunneling in the electronically adiabatic and non-adiabatic limits: comparison of the quantum and classical treatment of donor-acceptor motion in a protein environment

Biophysical Spandrels form a Hot-Spot for Kosmotropic Mutations in Bacteriophage Thermal Adaptation

Polaron tunneling dynamics in the DNA molecule

Neural-network-based molecular dynamics simulations reveal that proton transport in water is doubly gated by sequential hydrogen-bond exchange