Tobacco dermatitis
R. Rycroft
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2133.1980.tb06596.x
IF: 11.113
1980-08-01
British Journal of Dermatology
Abstract:Green or raw tobacco has to be cured, aged and fermented before it is ready to smoke. As is the case with wine, the chemical constituents of mature tobacco depend both qualitatively and quantitatively on a wide variety of factors. The precise chemical composition of a tobacco leaf varies even from one part ofthe leaf to another (Wolf, 1967). The main variables which determine the chemical content of the leaf as a whole are: the hybrid status ofthe plant; the soil and climate it grows in; the height of the leaf up the stalk ofthe plant; the time and method of harvesting; whether it is air-cured or heatcured (flue-cured); and precisely how it is aged and fermented (Wolf, 1967). As a result a vast range of different waxes, paraffins, fatty acids, organic acids, aldehydes, ketones, phenols, polyphenols, catechols, tannins and other low molecular weight chemicals come to be present in the finished leaf. It is against this background of chemical variation from one batch of tobacco to another that it is essential to consider the problem of tobacco dermatitis. Convincing reports of allergic contact dermatitis from tobacco are rare among workers in cigarette and cigar factories and excessively rare among tobacco users. Much commoner among cigarette and cigar factory workers handling tobacco are comparatively minor erythemas, urticarias and mild eczemas, associated with the mechanical trauma of operations such as hand stripping and the primary irritancy of tobacco, which is probably due to its content of nicotine and related alkaloids (Knowles, 1913; Rutledge, 1934; Vero & Genovese, 1941; Schwartz, Tulipan & Birmingham, 1957; Gordon-Smith, 1957). Tobacco harvesters, however, can suffer the pallor, vomiting and prostration of nicotine poisoning without any associated dermatitis (Gehlbach et al., 1974). The earliest reports of tobacco dermatitis are anecdotal only. Blaisdell (1924) described a middleaged male cigar roller with a work-related hand dermatitis and Davis (1924) a 56-year-old cigar salesman with an episodic hand dermatitis, which spread to his face and trunk. By the time these reports were published the mechanization of cigar making had begun and female cigar making machine operators were replacing male cigar rollers (Samitz, Mori & Long, 1949). A cigar making machine operator, however, still continuously handles the tobacco leaves from which the outer wrapper of each cigar is cut. In general there remains more direct skin contact with tobacco leaf in cigar factories than in cigarette factories, but there have always been certain jobs within cigarette factories where contact could be heavy enough to allow sensitization to take place. Karrenberg (1928) reported a severe dermatitis in a 40-year-old female cigarette factory worker, which started on her hands 3-4 days after she began work on separating tightly packed tobacco leaves. A few days later an acute exudative eczema appeared on her face. The condition cleared when she stopped working and recurred on her return. Patch tests with the tobacco leaves she worked with gave strongly positive, persistent reactions, with vesiculation. The history, clinical findings and patch test results all support a diagnosis of allergic contact dermatitis. Stauffer (1929) published a report of vesicular hand dermatitis in a 44-year-old woman who had worked in a factory since her youth. Away from the factory her hands healed in 3 months but recurrence occurred repeatedly and increasingly rapidly when she tried to return. A patch test with dry tobacco leaf gave no reaction, but when moist the same tobacco caused severe oedema, erythema and vesiculation. While an aqueous infusion of tobacco in a i : 1000 dilution gave a positive patch test reaction, nicotine in a corresponding dilution did not. Attempts at desensitization by intramuscular injections of tobacco infusion failed. 0007-0963/80/0800-0225502.00 © 1980 British Association of Dermatologists