Note on tax enforcement and transfer pricing manipulation

Alex Augusto Timm Rathke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1506.08743

2015-06-29

ECONOMICS

Abstract:This note proposes the segregation of independent endogenous and exogenous components of tax penalty probability to introduce a formal demonstration that enforcement and tax penalties are negatively related with income shifting. JEL F23; H26.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Transfer pricing manipulation, tax penalty cost and the impact of foreign profit taxation

Alex Augusto Timm Rathke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1508.03853

2015-08-16

ECONOMICS

Abstract:This paper analizes the optimal level of transfer pricing manipulation when the expected tax penalty is a function of the tax enforcement and the market price parameter. The arm's length principle implies the existence of a range of acceptable prices shaped by market, and firms can manipulate transfer prices more freely if market price range is wide, or if its delimitations are difficult to determine. Home taxation of foreign profits can reduce income shifting incentive, depending on the portion of repatriation for tax purposes. We find that the limited tax credit rule tends to be a less efficient measure, nonetheless it is the most widely adopted rule by countries, so to spark the perspective of more powerful approaches for taxation of foreign profits.
Taxing the Second Nature ∗

Dao-Zhi Zeng,Shin-Kun Peng,Xiwei Zhu

2017-01-01

Abstract:This paper examines the tax competition for mobile capital between symmetric countries. All first-nature features are completely abstracted away in such a framework so agglomeration and dispersion forces come purely from the second nature features such as monopolistic competition, increasing returns to scale, and trade costs. A positive tax indicates dispersion while a negative tax implies agglomeration. We find that the income effect and the pro-competitive effect together foster a strong dispersion force which is explored by the local government in the form of a positive tax rate.
Tax Evasion, Audits with Memory, and Portfolio Choice

Yong Ma,Hao Jiang,Weilin Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iref.2020.10.010

IF: 3.399

2021-01-01

International Review of Economics & Finance

Abstract:In this study, we consider the memory property of tax audits to investigate the tax evasion problem from the perspective of portfolio choice. We explore the implications of the memory property for tax evasion, consumption, and asset allocation. Assuming that tax audits and jumps in the risky asset both follow self-exciting Hawkes processes, we provide a semi-analytical solution to this problem for an agent with constant relative risk aversion (CRRA) utility. We find that the memory feature does not change the agent’s effective holding in the risky asset, and its effects on tax evasion and consumption are determined by the agent’s risk aversion. It is suggested that government should treat agents differentially by their risk preferences and set audit-related parameters carefully to avoid unnecessary public expenditure.
Taxpayer deductions and the endogenous probability of tax penalisation

Alex A. T. Rathke,Alex A.T. Rathke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2202.13695

2022-02-28

General Economics

Abstract:We propose a parametric specification of the probability of tax penalisation faced by a taxpayer, based on the amount of deduction chosen by her to reduce total taxation. Comparative analyses lead to a closed-form solution for the optimum tax deduction, and provide the maximising conditions with respect to the probability parameters.
Administrative procedures as tax enforcement tools

Wei Cui,Jeffrey Hicks,Michael Wiebe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econlet.2024.111649

IF: 1.469

2024-03-21

Economics Letters

Abstract:We study how common administrative procedures affect firm tax evasion. We begin with the counter-intuitive observation that many firms bunch above, rather than below, large notches in China's corporate income tax. Cross-sectional patterns suggest that administrative procedures in the prepayment and refund system served as de facto enforcement tools that prevented some firms from accessing the reduced tax rates below the notches. Following a regulatory reform that eliminated these procedures, bunching below the notches increased dramatically. The results imply a trade-off between reducing administrative barriers and allowing much taxpayer non-compliance in low-compliance environments.

economics
On the Interdependency of Profit Shifting Channels and the Effectiveness of Anti-Avoidance Legislation

Katharina Nicolay,Hannah Nusser,Olena Pfeiffer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3091567

2017-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The issue of base erosion and profit shifting has been on the international policy agenda for several years now. The aim of this paper is to examine how firms adjust their profit shifting mechanisms in a changing institutional environment. In particular, we test whether firms substitute one profit shifting strategy for another if respective costs change. To this end, we exploit changes in the strictness of transfer pricing regulations and thin capitalization rules over time in a panel of European multinational firms and study a quasi-experimental reform setting in France. We confirm existing evidence that tightening transfer pricing regulations reduces the tax sensitivity of earnings before interest and taxes (EBIT) substantially. Our results show, however, that this reduction includes both a reduction in profit shifting activity via the transfer pricing channel and a substitution with debt shifting. Moreover, firms using debt shifting to begin with rely more heavily on tax optimization of transfer prices when thin capitalization rules are strengthened. If transfer pricing regulations are also strict, the conditional reform effects show that the substitutive response is more pronounced for a subsample of firms with a high share of intangible property (IP). The difference-in-difference approach for the French tax reform illustrates an increase in profit shifting based on transfer prices for treated firms facing new restrictions on debt shifting. Again, the effect is stronger for IP intensive firms.
Leveling the playing field: Constraints on multinational profit shifting and the performance of national firms

P. Gauß,M. Kortenhaus,N. Riedel,M. Simmler

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpubeco.2024.105116

IF: 8.262

2024-04-25

Journal of Public Economics

Abstract:A flourishing literature quantifies the corporate tax revenue losses from multinational profit shifting to low-tax economies. Other consequences of international tax avoidance have received little attention. In this paper, we empirically assess the widespread perception that international tax avoidance impacts product market outcomes and can put national competitors of multinational firms at a competitive disadvantage. The empirical identification strategy relies on changes in transfer pricing regulations that constrain multinational profit shifting by strategic mis-pricing of intra-firm trade. Based on rich data on firms in European high-tax countries, we show that tighter transfer pricing provisions raise multinational firms' effective tax costs and lower their sales. The sales and profits of affected firms' national competitors increase significantly, while mark-ups remain largely unchanged. We discuss policy implications of our findings.

economics
Taxation and Corporate Risk-Taking

Dominika Langenmayr,Rebecca Lester

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2460931

2014-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We study whether the corporate tax system provides incentives for risky firm investment. We analytically and empirically show two main findings: first, risk-taking is positively related to the length of tax loss periods because the loss rules shift some risk to the government; and second, the tax rate has a positive effect on risk-taking for firms that expect to use losses, and a weak negative effect for those that cannot. Thus, the sign of the tax effect on risky investment hinges on firm-specific expectations of future loss recovery.
Endogenous Inefficient Institutions

Pan Shiyuan

2008-01-01

Abstract:Following Acemoglu(2006),we construct a simple model to investigate how the elite's preference for high intermediate good price translates into inefficient economic institutions and political institutions.Price manipulation mechanism implies that the elite prefer to high profits through monopoly pricing.An increase in tax rate declines the demand for intermediate good from the middle class,hence reducing monopoly profits,hence the price manipulation motive always decreases taxes to below the pure revenue-maximizing level,which is opposite to the case in Acemoglu(2006).
Detect and Deter or Catch and Release: Are Financial Penalties an Effective Way to Penalise Deliberate Tax Evaders?

Chris Leech

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3161239

2018-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:Tax penalties play an important and often undervalued role in the tax system. They primarily serve two functions: to deter non-compliance, and to reinforce community perceptions that the tax system is fair because non-compliant taxpayers will suffer consequences. Most tax penalties are administrative financial penalties imposed by the tax authority, ranging from minor penalties to financial penalties imposed on deliberate tax evaders. This exploratory paper draws on new data relating to payment of tax penalties for false and misleading statements. The data is subject to limitations and qualifications as detailed in the paper. Overall, the data shows that the majority of financial penalties imposed on deliberate tax evaders are never paid. The paper then seeks to explain how this can serve to undermine the effectiveness of these penalties. The paper reviews literature explaining the role of tax penalties and the hallmarks of effective tax penalties. It also reflects on a chapter of Australian tax history where community perceptions that tax evaders were not being effectively penalised jeopardised the perceived fairness of the tax system. The paper argues that if the current tax penalty regime is not strengthened then this will likely pose a risk to the perceived fairness of Australia’s tax system, and it therefore proposes some potential solutions, including arguing for two new penalties to be introduced into the regime.

English Else
Tax penalties on fluctuating incomes: estimates from longitudinal data

Daniel V. Gordon,Jean-François Wen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10797-017-9456-1

2017-05-26

International Tax and Public Finance

Abstract:Progressive personal income taxes can cause individuals with fluctuating incomes to pay more taxes over time than individuals with constant incomes of the same average value. The implicit tax penalty violates principles of equity and may harm efficiency by discouraging risk-taking activities, such as entrepreneurship. This paper uses longitudinal data to estimate the tax penalties in six panels of Canadian data from 1993 to 2010. The effects of various income averaging policies for mitigating tax penalties are then examined.

economics
Tax havens and cross-border licensing with transfer pricing regulation

Jay Pil Choi,Jota Ishikawa,Hirofumi Okoshi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10797-022-09770-w

2022-12-06

Abstract:Multinational enterprises (MNEs) have incentive to reduce tax payment through transfer pricing. The incentive is stronger when MNEs own intangibles, because it is easy to transfer them across countries. To mitigate such strategic tax planning, the OECD proposes the arm's length principle (ALP). This paper deals with technology patents as an example of intangibles and investigates how the ALP affects MNEs' licensing strategies and welfare in a model with a tax haven. The ALP may distort MNEs' licensing decisions, because providing a license to unrelated firms restricts MNEs' profit-shifting opportunities due to the emergence of comparable transaction. Interestingly, the termination of licensing in the presence of the ALP may worsen domestic welfare if the (potential) licensee and the MNE's subsidiary do not compete in the domestic market but may improve welfare if they compete. The results under ad valorem royalty are in distinct contrast with those under per-unit royalty.
A macroeconomic perspective on taxing multinational enterprises

Sebastian Dyrda,Guangbin Hong,Joseph B. Steinberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jinteco.2024.104022

IF: 3.712

2024-11-08

Journal of International Economics

Abstract:We develop a general-equilibrium model to study the macroeconomic consequences of international profit shifting by multinational enterprises (MNEs). In our model, MNEs shift profits by exploiting intangible capital transfer pricing rules, which makes intangible investment more attractive and leads to higher output at home and abroad. We use the model to quantify the effects of two reforms proposed by the OECD: (i) reallocating MNEs' profit tax bases to the countries where they sell their products; and (ii) a minimum global corporate income tax. Both reforms would reduce profit shifting substantially, but (i) would reduce global output whereas (ii) would have little macroeconomic impact. The reforms' distributional implications would also be important. In high-tax countries, tax revenues would increase more than output declines, raising gross national income and enabling redistribution that could offset lower wages. In contrast, output and tax revenues would both drop in low-tax countries, significantly reducing national income.

economics
Profit shifting under the arm's length principle

Alex A.T. Rathke

2023-09-24

Abstract:This study analyses the tax-induced profit shifting behaviour of firms and the impact of governments' anti-shifting rules. We derive a model of a firm that combines internal sales and internal debt in a full profit shifting strategy, and which is required to apply the arm's length principle and a general thin capitalisation rule. We find several cases where the firm may shift profits to low-tax countries while satisfying the usual arm's length conditions in all countries. Internal sales and internal debt may be regarded either as complementary or as substitute shifting channels, depending on how the implicit concealment costs vary after changes in all transactions. We show that the cross-effect between the shifting channels facilitates profit shifting by means of accepted transfer prices and interest rates.

General Economics
Taxation of Foreign Profits with Heterogeneous Multinational Firms

Johannes Becker

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9701.2012.01474.x

2012-08-07

The World Economy

Abstract:This paper analyses optimal taxation of foreign profits using a model with heterogeneous multinational firms that serve a foreign market through exports or foreign direct investment (FDI). If a firm switches from exporting to FDI, domestic activity and tax payments may decrease, stay constant or even rise because of intra‐firm trade. It turns out that, in contrast to recent claims, in all three cases, the optimal tax system implies full taxation after deduction of foreign tax payments. If the country accounts for the effects of its policy on the foreign price level, the case for taxing foreign income becomes even stronger. However, the globally optimal tax system may require exemption of foreign income from tax.
Income Shifting and International Transfer Pricing: A Three-Country Example

Clive R. Emmanuel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-6281.00045

1999-10-01

Abacus

Abstract:There is a long held belief that international transfer pricing (ITP) is used by multinational enterprises (MNEs) to minimize global tax liability. On the one hand, this is a rational economic response to market imperfections created by national governments. An alternative view decries such actions as anti‐competitive and an abuse of power. This article ex‐amines the potential benefit to enterprises of ITP manipulation when a real world combination of fiscal rules are simultaneously applied in practice. The countervailing impact of different national rules appears to result in ITP having a minor significance on parent after‐tax income. Differential rates cause minor benefits but the absence of a form of tax, such as withholding tax, can provide substantial opportunities to maximize global after‐tax income through the choice of transfer price. ITP can therefore provide benefits when national jurisdictions do not have consistent forms of taxation. In all the scenarios explored, major variations are apparent in the after‐tax income of subsidiaries operating under different combinations of fiscal regimes and ITP policies. The tension between head‐quarter and subsidiary management may be most pronounced when a subsidiary is located in a jurisdiction not having a complete range of tax forms.
A Theory of Tax Avoidance -- Managerial Incentives for Tax Planning in a Multi-Task Principal-Agent Model

Ralf Ewert,Rainer Niemann

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2463582

2014-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:We derive determinants of tax avoidance by means of a multi-task principal-agent model. We extend prevailing models by integrating both corporate and individual income taxation as well as by including tax planning effort in the agent’s action portfolio. Our model shows novel and apparently paradoxical results regarding the impact of increased tax rates on efforts, risks, and incentive schemes. First, the principal’s after-tax profit can increase with a higher corporate tax rate. Second, tax planning effort can decrease in the corporate tax rate. Third, operational effort can increase with increasing corporate tax rates. We show that differences in productivities, differences in operational and tax risk and the correlations of these risks are crucial determinants for the optimal degree of tax avoidance. These determinants can explain why some firms are more tax aggressive than others and should therefore be considered in empirical studies. Related to this insight, we demonstrate that our results are consistent with recent empirical evidence.
Tax authority governance and corporate internal control quality

Xiaojian Tang,Dongying Du,Ying Chen,Stephanie Tsui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/acfi.13306

IF: 2.473

2024-07-13

Accounting and Finance

Abstract:Prior studies of tax enforcement neglect the effect of tax enforcement officers' discretion on corporate internal control quality. This study exploits a unique quasi‐natural experimental setting of the reform of Chinese province‐level tax administrative penalty discretion standards since 2016 to examine the effect of tax authority governance on corporate internal control quality. We show that tax authority governance can improve corporate internal control quality. And this positive effect is more pronounced in firms with more tax avoidance and more collusion with tax supervisors. Furthermore, further analysis shows that legal enforcement and financial reporting environment can strengthen the positive relationship between tax authority governance and corporate internal control quality. Therefore, the above results show that tax authority governance not only increases the predictability of tax violation and its consequential penalties, but also restricts tax enforcement personnel's discretionary power, thereby reducing opportunities for tax avoidance and rent‐seeking behaviour.

business, finance
The influence of fiscal regulations on transfer pricing: a bibliometric review

Renata Fulop,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24193/rvm.2022.15.84

2022-05-16

Virgil Madgearu Review of Economic Studies and Research

Abstract:It has been concluded that the concept “transfer price” means the price generated by multinational corporations in the process of commercial activity between the affiliated companies located in different countries and, correspondingly, different tax jurisdictions. The potential use of international transfer pricing as an income shift by multinational enterprises has long been recognized. Many tax-related scandals have been made public in the past few years involving some of the major multinational enterprises at this time. These were accused of practicing tax avoidance on an industrial scale by shifting profits to lower-tax jurisdictions through transfer pricing techniques. Multinational enterprises perform intra-firm transactions with foreign related parties to shift taxable profits by manipulating internal transfer prices. This bibliometric review of the literature we proposed aimed to summarize existing research, recognize patterns, problems, and identify the conceptual content of the field, contributing to the existing theory.
Financial Repression and Optimal Taxation

CE Bai,DD Li,YY Qian,YJ Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/s0165-1765(00)00358-x

IF: 1.469

2001-01-01

Economics Letters

Abstract:Financial repression entails an implicit taxation on savings. When effective income-tax rates are very uneven, as common in developing countries, raising some government revenue through mild financial repression can be more efficient than collecting income tax only.

Note on tax enforcement and transfer pricing manipulation

Transfer pricing manipulation, tax penalty cost and the impact of foreign profit taxation

Taxing the Second Nature ∗

Tax Evasion, Audits with Memory, and Portfolio Choice

Taxpayer deductions and the endogenous probability of tax penalisation

Administrative procedures as tax enforcement tools

On the Interdependency of Profit Shifting Channels and the Effectiveness of Anti-Avoidance Legislation

Leveling the playing field: Constraints on multinational profit shifting and the performance of national firms

Taxation and Corporate Risk-Taking

Endogenous Inefficient Institutions

Detect and Deter or Catch and Release: Are Financial Penalties an Effective Way to Penalise Deliberate Tax Evaders?

Tax penalties on fluctuating incomes: estimates from longitudinal data

Tax havens and cross-border licensing with transfer pricing regulation

A macroeconomic perspective on taxing multinational enterprises

Profit shifting under the arm's length principle

Taxation of Foreign Profits with Heterogeneous Multinational Firms

Income Shifting and International Transfer Pricing: A Three-Country Example

A Theory of Tax Avoidance -- Managerial Incentives for Tax Planning in a Multi-Task Principal-Agent Model

Tax authority governance and corporate internal control quality

The influence of fiscal regulations on transfer pricing: a bibliometric review

Financial Repression and Optimal Taxation