Abstract:This paper gives a classification of classes of discrete dynamical systems (a set equipped with an endofunction) closed under finite limits and small colimits. The conclusion is simple: they bijectively correspond to the ideals of the product poset $\mathbb{N} \times \mathbb{N}$, where the first $\mathbb{N}$ is ordered by the usual order and the second is by the divisibility. Our method is based on a detailed analysis of the behaviors of states, especially non-periodic behaviors, in discrete dynamical systems. Specifically, extending the fundamental quantity, time until entering a loop, to even those states that do not enter a loop plays a crucial role. Our classification is closely related to epimorphisms from $\mathbb{N}$ in the category of monoids. There are countably many injective epimorphisms from $\mathbb{N}$, including $\mathbb{N} \to \mathbb{Z}$. Those injective epimorphisms correspond to the non-periodic behaviors of states of discrete dynamical systems. We discuss this point at the end of the paper. This fun puzzle is motivated by an open problem in topos theory. Lawvere left open problems in topos theory on his webpage, and the first problem is called quotient toposes. The main theorem of this paper provides a non-trivial example of this problem, which is not implied by any known results. This paper also provides a theoretical framework to address the open problem. We define a preorder among the objects of a Grothendieck topos (which we have named generative order), which enables us to reduce calculations of quotient toposes to calculations of objects. Our method is its application to the topos of discrete dynamical systems.

Quotient toposes of discrete dynamical systems

Quotient toposes of discrete dynamical systems

A solution to the first Lawvere's problem A Grothendieck topos that has a proper class many quotient topoi

On Topological Representation Theory from Quivers

Quasitoposes as elementary quotient completions

Profinite completions of topological operads

On topological groupoids that represent theories

Topoi of automata I: Four topoi of automata and regular languages

Elementary Quotient Completions, Church's Thesis, and Partioned Assemblies

Existentially closed models and locally zero-dimensional toposes

On categories O for quantized symplectic resolutions

$(\infty,2)$-Topoi and descent

Double Categories of Open Dynamical Systems (Extended Abstract)

From Yoneda to Topoi morphisms

Topological Factoring of Zero Dimensional Dynamical Systems

The operator theory on complete partially ordered objects in a topos

On morphisms of relative toposes

A homotopy-theoretic model of function extensionality in the effective topos

A Halmos-von Neumann theorem for actions of general groups

Automata in toposes, and general Myhill-Nerode theorems

Elementary axioms for parts in toposes