Abstract:Background: Parental refusal of routine childhood vaccination remains an ethically contested area. This systematic review sought to explore and characterise the normative arguments made about parental refusal of routine vaccination, with the aim of providing researchers, practitioners, and policymakers with a synthesis of current normative literature. Methods: Nine databases covering health and ethics research were searched, and 121 publications identified for the period Jan 1998 to Mar 2022. For articles, source journals were categorised according to Australian Standard Field of Research codes, and normative content was analysed using a framework analytical approach. Results: Most of the articles were published in biomedical journals (34%), bioethics journals (21%), and journals that carry both classifications (20%). Two central questions dominated the literature: (1) Whether vaccine refusal is justifiable (which we labelled 'refusal arguments'); and (2) Whether strategies for dealing with those who reject vaccines are justifiable ('response arguments'). Refusal arguments relied on principlism, religious frameworks, the rights and obligations of parents, the rights of children, the medico-legal best interests of the child standard, and the potential to cause harm to others. Response arguments were broadly divided into arguments about policy, arguments about how individual physicians should practice regarding vaccine rejectors, and both legal precedents and ethical arguments for vaccinating children against a parent's will. Policy arguments considered the normative significance of coercion, non-medical or conscientious objections, and possible reciprocal social efforts to offset vaccine refusal. Individual physician practice arguments covered nudging and coercive practices, patient dismissal, and the ethical and professional obligations of physicians. Most of the legal precedents discussed were from the American setting, with some from the United Kingdom. Conclusions: This review provides a comprehensive picture of the scope and substance of normative arguments about vaccine refusal and responses to vaccine refusal. It can serve as a platform for future research to extend the current normative literature, better understand the role of cultural context in normative judgements about vaccination, and more comprehensively translate the nuance of ethical arguments into practice and policy.

Not taking "no" for an answer: the interactional organization of accepting and refusing childhood vaccination in the Netherlands

The Delicate Situation of Childhood Vaccination: On the Dispreferredness of Soliciting Parents' Intent to Vaccinate

Navigating vaccine hesitancy: Strategies and dynamics in healthcare professional-parent communication

“Following Your Gut” or “Questioning the Scientific Evidence”: Understanding Vaccine Skepticism among More-Educated Dutch Parents

Going with the Grain of Cognition: Applying Insights from Psychology to Build Support for Childhood Vaccination

Healthcare Professionals' Discursive Constructions of Parental Vaccine Hesitancy: A Tale of Multiple Moralities

Understanding parental hesitancy toward children's COVID-19 vaccinations: The influence of government, media and interpersonal communication

Increasing trust and vaccine uptake: Offering invitational rhetoric as an alternative to persuasion in pediatric visits with vaccine-hesitant parents (VHPs)

Exploring Vaccine Hesitancy Among Parents in a Rural Pediatric Clinic System: A Statistical Study

Challenging the 'acceptable option': Public health's advocacy for continued care in the case of pediatric vaccine refusal

Hesitant but vaccinated: Lessons learned from hesitant adopters

Individual decisions to vaccinate one's child or oneself: A discrete choice experiment rejecting free-riding motives

Childhood vaccine refusal and what to do about it: a systematic review of the ethical literature

Parental intention, attitudes, beliefs, trust and deliberation towards childhood vaccination in the Netherlands in 2022: Indications of change compared to 2013

Determinants of vaccine refusal, delay and reluctance in parents of 2-year-old children in Canada: Findings from the 2017 Childhood National Immunization Coverage Survey (cNICS)

Risk, emotion and responsibility: an analysis of the storylines used by vaccine hesitant mothers

Strategies for Improving Vaccine Communication and Uptake

Embracing context: Lessons from designing a dialogue-based intervention to address vaccine hesitancy

Nurse and parent partnership during children's vaccinations: a conversation analysis

Inattention or reluctance? Parental responses to vaccination reminder letters

'Why did nobody ask us?': A mixed-methods co-produced study in the United Kingdom exploring why some children are unvaccinated or vaccinated late