Establishment of a novel protocol for assessing the severity of subarachnoid hemorrhage in circle Willis perforation mouse model

Rui Zhang,Dilaware Khan,Sajjad Muhammad

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-60237-w

IF: 4.6

2024-05-04

Scientific Reports

Abstract:The Circle of Willis perforation (cWp) mouse model is a key tool in subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) research; however, inconsistent bleeding volumes can challenge experimental reliability. To address this issue, we introduced the ROB Scoring System, a novel protocol integrating Rotarod Tests (RT), Open-field Tests (OT) video analysis, and daily Body Weight Loss (BWL) monitoring to precisely categorize SAH severity. Forty C57BL/6 mice underwent cWp SAH induction, categorized by ROB into severity subgroups (severe, moderate, mild). Validation compared ROB trends in subgroups, and ROB outcomes with autopsy results on postoperative days three and seven for acute and sub-acute evaluations. Mortality rates were analyzed via the survival log-rank test, revealing a significant difference among SAH subgroups ( P < 0.05). Strong correlations between ROB grades and autopsy findings underscored its precision. Notably, the severe group exhibited 100% mortality within 4 days post SAH onset. Single parameters (RT, OT, BWL) were insufficient for distinguishing SAH severity levels. The ROB score represents a significant advancement, offering an objective method for precise categorization and addressing inherent bleeding variations in the cWp SAH model. This standardized protocol enhances the reliability and effectiveness of the SAH translational research, providing a valuable tool for future investigations into this critical area.

multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the reduced reliability of experimental results due to inconsistent blood loss in the circle of Willis puncture (cWp) mouse model. To address this challenge, the researchers introduced a new evaluation method - the ROB scoring system. This system combines the Rotarod Test (RT), Open - field Test (OT) video analysis, and daily Body Weight Loss (BWL) monitoring, aiming to accurately classify the severity of Subarachnoid Hemorrhage (SAH).

Specifically, the paper solves the problem in the following aspects:

1. **Accurately Classify the Severity of SAH**: The ROB scoring system can accurately divide the SAH model into three different subgroups: severe, moderate, and mild. This refined classification is crucial for research because it makes it possible to distinguish data within each subgroup. For example, on the third day after surgery, the overall mortality rate was 13.79%, but in the severe group, this rate was as high as 66.67%, almost five times that of the former. This significant difference highlights the inadequacy of simply dividing experimental subjects into "sham - operated group" and "SAH group".

2. **Dynamic Evaluation and Timely Identification**: The ROB scoring system not only provides a static assessment of the severity of SAH but also the ability of dynamic evaluation. Evaluating and updating the ROB score every day after surgery is very valuable for predicting adverse outcomes (such as mouse death). By using the ROB score as a predictive tool to identify severe cases, the research helps to improve animal welfare, reduce unnecessary suffering, and improve the ethical treatment of research animals.

3. **Promote the Consistency of Experimental Models**: By providing an accurate and refined method to identify the severity of SAH, the ROB scoring system, as an innovative tool, makes the cWp SAH model closer to the injection model in terms of the consistency of SAH severity. This consistency has far - reaching practical significance in drug treatment research. For example, in drug treatment research, severe or mild cWp SAH mouse models can be excluded, thus ensuring that experimental results are less affected by changes in disease severity. This improves the reliability of experimental conditions, enhances the validity of research findings, and lays a solid foundation for potential treatment interventions.

In conclusion, by introducing the ROB scoring system, this paper solves the problem of inconsistent blood loss in the cWp SAH model, improves the reliability and validity of the experiment, and provides a valuable tool for future SAH research.