Leaders of Peer Groups in Chinese Early Adolescents: The Roles of Social, Academic, and Psychological Characteristics in Group Leadership

Jiaxi Zhou,Xinyin Chen,Dan Li,Junsheng Liu,Liying Cui
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-024-02003-9
2024-05-17
Journal of Youth and Adolescence
Abstract:Leadership in peer groups is an important issue in adolescent socioemotional development, yet it has received limited attention in research. This one-year longitudinal study examined peer group leadership and the roles of social, academic, and psychological characteristics in the dynamics of group leadership. Participants included 1061 Chinese students (initial mean age =11.17 years; SD = 6.98 months; 49.4% female). Data were collected from peer assessments, teacher ratings, and self-reports. The longitudinal social network analysis (SIENA) indicated that peer group leadership was fluid with leadership status evolving over time across groups in a hierarchical manner. Adolescents displaying higher social competence and aggression and lower shyness were more likely to become group leaders. Academic performance and loneliness were not significantly associated with the dynamics of peer group leadership. The results help understand peer group leadership and contributions of social behaviors to the attainment of leadership status in peer groups in early adolescence.
psychology, developmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the characteristics of early Chinese adolescents' peer - group leadership and its relationship with social, academic and psychological characteristics. Specifically, the study aims to examine the dynamic changes of peer - group leadership within one year and which personal characteristics (such as social ability, aggression, shyness, academic performance and loneliness) are related to leadership positions in peer groups through the Social Network Analysis (SIENA) method. ### Research Background - **The Importance of Leadership in Adolescents' Social - Emotional Development**: Although leadership plays a crucial role in adolescents' growth, research in this area is relatively scarce, especially in informal peer groups. - **Research Gaps**: Most studies on adolescent leadership focus on formal settings such as classrooms and schools, while less research has been done on leadership in informal peer groups. - **Research Purposes**: This study aims to fill this gap and explore the dynamic changes of peer - group leadership and its relationship with individual social, academic and psychological characteristics through a longitudinal research method. ### Research Hypotheses 1. **Reciprocal Effect**: Non - leadership members may be nominated by their leaders to assume leadership roles. 2. **Positive Transmission Effect**: Adolescents are more likely to follow the leaders of their leaders. 3. **Negative Three - Cycle Effect**: Adolescents are less likely to lead those led by their leaders. 4. **Selection Effect**: - Adolescents with higher social ability, aggression and academic performance are more likely to become leaders. - Adolescents with higher shyness and loneliness are less likely to become leaders. 5. **Self - Other Interaction Effect**: Adolescents are more inclined to establish leadership relationships with peers with similar characteristics. ### Methods - **Participants**: 1,061 early Chinese adolescents (average age 11.17 years, standard deviation 6.98 months, 49.4% female). - **Data Collection**: Data were collected through peer assessment, teacher rating and self - report. - **Data Analysis**: The Social Network Analysis (SIENA) method was used to track the changes in peer - group leadership and its related characteristics within one year. ### Main Variables - **Peer - Group Leadership**: Determined through peer nomination. - **Social Ability, Aggression and Shyness**: Measured through peer assessment. - **Academic Performance**: Measured through teacher rating. - **Loneliness**: Measured through self - report. ### Research Significance - **Theoretical Contribution**: The research results are helpful for understanding the dynamic changes of peer - group leadership and its relationship with individual characteristics, especially in the early stage of Chinese adolescents. - **Practical Significance**: The research results can provide guidance for educators and parents to help them better support the development of adolescents' leadership in peer groups. Through these studies, we can have a more comprehensive understanding of the leadership dynamics of adolescents in peer groups and which personal characteristics contribute to or hinder their acquisition of leadership positions in peer groups.