Abstract:The approach used to map risk (here, vessel collision to whales), affected the location, and total area, identified as 'high risk'. The variation in outputs, depending on approach used, underscores the importance of methodological transparency, informed data selection and careful interpretation when predicting collision risk. We provide practical recommendations for enhancing transparency when predicting risk, and discuss choice of approach suitable for different situations or management applications. It is critical that managers and policy makers are aware of the implications of applying different approaches when interpreting risk evaluation outputs. A growing and increasingly globalised human population, requiring the movement of goods and commodities, is placing increasing demands on the maritime industry, resulting in a concurrent increase in global shipping activities. This has consequences for the marine environment, particularly for species vulnerable to the impacts of vessel traffic. For example, vessel collisions can result in sub‐lethal or fatal injuries for marine mammals, whilst vessel noise can cause acoustic masking that effectively reduces an animal's listening space, potentially impacting their communication, navigation and foraging capacity. While a number of parallel approaches to mapping collision risk to large whales have arisen, these methods vary in their focus, usually on either co‐occurrence, collision probability, or probability of mortality. However, little attention has been given to the implications of methodological choice and data selection on subsequent risk predictions. To assess differences between these approaches, we used a standardised input dataset comprised of telemetry‐point data from tagged bowhead whales, and satellite‐based Automated Identification System (AIS) data of spatial vessel movements covering the Davis‐Baffin Arctic Marine Area. We applied this data to eight different, previously published analyses for deriving areas of vessel risk. We found that the choice of risk mapping approach affected the location, and total area, identified as 'high risk', and that more computationally complex approaches did not necessarily equate to different predictions. There was considerable variation in the total area of 'high risk' predicted within each map (range = 20–42,246 km2). Synthesis and Applications. The results underscore the importance of methodological transparency, informed data selection and careful interpretation when predicting collision risk. We provide practical recommendations for enhancing transparency when predicting risk, and discuss choice of approach suitable for different situations or management applications. It is critical that managers and policy makers are aware of the implications of applying different approaches when interpreting risk evaluation outputs.

The need to consider recreational vessels in risk assessments of vessel strikes to humpback whales ( Megaptera novaeangliae )

Not all maps are equal: Evaluating approaches for mapping vessel collision risk to large baleen whales

Use of a behavioural response method to assess the risk of collision between migrating humpback whales and vessels

Using Satellite AIS to Analyze Vessel Speeds off the Coast of Washington State, U.S., As a Risk Analysis for Cetacean-Vessel Collisions

Estimating reductions in the risk of vessels striking whales achieved by management strategies

A quantitative method for the analysis of ship collision risk using AIS data

Ais Data Based Identification Of Systematic Collision Risk For Maritime Intelligent Transport System

Effectiveness of marine protected areas in safeguarding important migratory megafauna habitat

A Systematic Approach for Collision Risk Analysis Based on Ais Data

Application of a New Shore-Based Vessel Traffic Monitoring System Within San Francisco Bay

Vessel noise levels drive behavioural responses of humpback whales with implications for whale-watching

Unseen overlap between fishing vessels and top predators in the northeast Pacific

Persistent near real‐time passive acoustic monitoring for baleen whales from a moored buoy: system description and evaluation

Assessing Marine Mammal Abundance: A Novel Data Fusion

Vessels Disturb Bottlenose Dolphin Behavior and Movement in an Active Ship Channel

Combining passive acoustic data from a towed hydrophone array with visual line transect data to estimate abundance and availability bias of sperm whales (Physeter macrocephalus)

A quantitative assessment of continuous versus structured methods for the detection of marine mammals and seabirds via opportunistic shipboard surveys

Radiated noise from commercial ships in the Gulf of Maine: implications for whale/vessel collisions

Recreational vessel networks reveal potential hot spots for marine pest introduction and spread

New urban habitat for endangered humpback whales: San Francisco Bay

Dynamic ensemble models to predict distributions and anthropogenic risk exposure for highly mobile species