Overnutrition is a risk factor for iron, but not for zinc or vitamin A deficiency in children and young people: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Xiaomian Tan,Pui Yee Tan,Yun Yun Gong,J Bernadette Moore
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjgh-2024-015135
IF: 8.056
2024-04-01
BMJ Global Health
Abstract:Introduction Traditionally associated with undernutrition, increasing evidence suggests micronutrient deficiencies can coexist with overnutrition. Therefore, this work aimed to systematically review the associations between iron, zinc and vitamin A (VA) status and weight status (both underweight and overweight) in children and young people. Methods Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase, Scopus and Cochrane databases were systematically searched for observational studies assessing micronutrient status (blood, serum or plasma levels of iron, zinc or VA biomarkers) and weight status (body mass index or other anthropometric measurement) in humans under 25 years of any ethnicity and gender. Risk of bias assessment was conducted using the American Dietetic Association Quality Criteria Checklist. Where possible, random effects restricted maximum likelihood meta-analyses were performed. Results After screening, 83 observational studies involving 190 443 participants from 44 countries were identified, with many studies having reported on more than one micronutrient and/or weight status indicator. Iron was the most investigated micronutrient, with 46, 28 and 27 studies reporting data for iron, zinc and VA status, respectively. Synthesising 16 records of OR from seven eligible studies, overnutrition (overweight and obesity) increased odds of iron deficiency (ID) (OR (95% CI): 1.51 (1.20 to 1.82), p<0.0001, I 2 =40.7%). Odds appeared to be higher for children living with obesity (1.88 (1.33 to 2.43), p<0.0001, I 2 =20.6%) in comparison to those with overweight (1.31 (0.98 to 1.64), p<0.0001, I 2 =40.5%), although between group differences were not significant (p=0.08). Conclusions Overnutrition is associated with increased risk of ID, but not zinc or VA deficiencies, with an inverted U-shaped relationship observed between iron status and bodyweight. Our results highlight significant heterogeneity in the reporting of micronutrient biomarkers and how deficiencies were defined. Inflammation status was rarely adequately accounted for, and the burden of ID may well be under-recognised, particularly in children and young people living with overnutrition. PROSPERO registration number CRD42020221523.
public, environmental & occupational health
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Attempts to Address This paper aims to systematically review and analyze the association between the status of iron, zinc, and vitamin A (VA) and the weight status of children and young people (including malnutrition and overweight). Specifically, the authors hope to answer the following questions through this study: 1. **Is the deficiency of iron, zinc, and vitamin A related to being overweight or obese?** - Traditionally, micronutrient deficiencies have been considered mainly related to malnutrition, but increasing evidence suggests that these deficiencies may also coexist with overweight and obesity. Therefore, the authors aim to explore whether deficiencies in iron, zinc, and vitamin A are more common among overweight or obese children and young people. 2. **What is the relationship between the deficiency of iron, zinc, and vitamin A and weight?** - The authors hope to reveal the specific relationship between the status of iron, zinc, and vitamin A and weight by analyzing existing observational studies. In particular, they want to understand if there is a specific pattern, such as a "U-shaped" relationship, where iron deficiency is more common among both malnourished and overweight or obese children and young people. 3. **What are the consistencies and differences between different studies?** - Since different studies have used various methods and standards to assess micronutrient deficiencies and weight status, the authors aim to identify the consistencies and differences in the study results through a systematic review and meta-analysis and explore possible reasons. ### Main Findings of the Study - **Relationship between iron deficiency and being overweight or obese**: - Meta-analysis results show that the risk of iron deficiency is significantly increased in overweight or obese children and young people (OR (95% CI): 1.51 (1.20 to 1.82), p<0.0001). This risk is particularly higher in obese children (OR (95% CI): 1.88 (1.33 to 2.43), p<0.0001), although the difference between the two groups is not significant (p=0.08). - The data indicate a "U-shaped" relationship between iron status and weight, where iron deficiency is more common among both malnourished and overweight or obese children and young people. - **Relationship between zinc deficiency and being overweight or obese**: - For zinc deficiency, the study results are more complex. While most studies found a direct relationship between zinc deficiency and malnutrition, this relationship is inconsistent among overweight or obese children. Some studies found a positive correlation between zinc levels and weight, while others did not find a significant association. - Overall, the data support an exponential plateau curve relationship between zinc status and weight, where the risk of zinc deficiency is highest among severely malnourished children and young people, but no higher risk was found among overweight or obese children. - **Relationship between vitamin A deficiency and being overweight or obese**: - For vitamin A deficiency, the study results are also diverse. Most studies found a direct relationship between vitamin A deficiency and malnutrition, but this relationship is unclear among overweight or obese children. Some studies found a positive correlation between vitamin A levels and weight, while others did not find a significant association. - Overall, the data support a similar relationship between vitamin A status and weight, where vitamin A deficiency is more common among malnourished children, but no higher risk was found among overweight or obese children. ### Conclusion - **Being overweight or obese is associated with an increased risk of iron deficiency**, but not with the risk of zinc and vitamin A deficiencies. - **There is a "U-shaped" relationship between iron status and weight**, where iron deficiency is more common among both malnourished and overweight or obese children and young people. - **The heterogeneity of study results is high**, and more high-quality studies are needed to further validate these findings and explore potential mechanisms. ### Implications for Research, Practice, and Policy - **Healthcare practitioners** will increasingly recognize that overweight or obese children and young people may suffer from iron deficiency, thereby improving clinical practice and care. - **Future research** needs to focus more on the issue of multiple malnutrition in low- and middle-income countries and improve the quality of research and transparency of reporting. - **In future micronutrient deficiency research**, there is a need to enhance the measurement and definition of inflammatory status to more accurately assess the risk of malnutrition.