Assessment of Panorama Photogrammetry as a Tool for Long-Range Deformation Monitoring

Peyman Javadi,Luis García-Asenjo,Raquel Luján,José Luis Lerma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s24113298

IF: 3.9

2024-05-23

Sensors

Abstract:This study investigates panorama photogrammetry (PPh) as a potential method to collect massive 3D information for long-range deformation monitoring. Particularly, this study focuses on areas with measuring restrictions, i.e., inaccessible objects and distances above 0.6 km. Under these particular conditions, geodetic techniques based on Electromagnetic Distance Meters (EDMs) or Total Stations (TSs) can provide coordinates with a precision better than 1 cm, but only for a limited number of discrete points. For mass capture, Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS) is normally the preferred solution, but long-range instruments are expensive, and drawbacks such as weak return signals and non-automatic target recognition appear. As an alternative, PPh is investigated in the well-controlled area of La Muela in Cortes de Pallas, where images are automatically captured from geodetic pillars using a GigaPan device, processed, and then rigorously compared to TLS point clouds. The results obtained after integrating both techniques into a high-accuracy geodetic reference frame show that PPh and TLS provide similar precision to within approximately 4 cm in the range of 0.6–1.0 km. Therefore, considering cost-effectiveness and ease of use, the proposed method can be considered a low-cost alternative to TLS for long-range deformation monitoring.

engineering, electrical & electronic,instruments & instrumentation,chemistry, analytical

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper attempts to address the issue of how to use panoramic photogrammetry (PPh) as an effective and low-cost method to collect a large amount of 3D information in long-distance deformation monitoring, especially in areas that are difficult to access or have measurement limitations (such as places more than 0.6 kilometers away). Traditional methods such as Total Stations (TSs) and Electromagnetic Distance Meters (EDMs) can provide high-precision point information but are limited to a finite number of discrete points and are complex and time-consuming to operate. While Terrestrial Laser Scanning (TLS) can provide dense information, its equipment is expensive, and at long distances, the signal is weak, target recognition is not automatic, leading to incomplete point cloud data.

Therefore, the paper evaluates the effectiveness of panoramic photogrammetry as a long-distance deformation monitoring tool through experimental research conducted in the La Muela area of Cortes de Pallas, Spain. The study found that within the distance range of 0.6 to 1.0 kilometers, PPh provides similar accuracy to TLS, approximately 4 centimeters. This indicates that PPh can serve as a low-cost alternative to TLS in terms of cost-effectiveness and ease of use, suitable for long-distance deformation monitoring.