有机与常规种植对广东菜心品质和经济效益的影响 Effect of Organic and Conventional Cultivation on Quality and Profits of Chinese Flowering Cabbage in Guangdong Province

Bosi Lu,Jian-zhong Shen,Wen-kai Chen,H. Shen,Shuo Ma
DOI: https://doi.org/10.12677/HJAS.2018.82023
2018-02-13
Abstract:有机种植体系因其安全、绿色、可持续的特点得到广泛重视。本文研究了有机与常规两种种植方式对广东菜心品质及经济效益的影响。有机种植以腐熟鸡粪有机肥为底肥,追肥为海藻/蛋白水解液,人工除草、频振式杀虫灯等手段防治病虫害。常规种植以复合肥为底肥,追肥为复合肥,除草、防病虫用除草剂、杀虫杀菌剂。结果表明,低温条件下,苗期喷施海藻/蛋白水解物的菜心株高和鲜重分别比清水对照增加了3.2%~11.7%和2.6%~8.5%。移栽大田后,与常规种植相比,有机种植处理的菜心可溶性糖、可溶性蛋白、维生素C分别提高了18.8%~23.2%、24.3%~30.8%和9.0%~18.5%,粗纤维素、可滴定酸降低了7.14%~20.45%和6.45%~8.14%,可溶固形物没有明显变化,口感清甜。经济效益分析发现,有机种植生产的菜心比常规种植增加投入成本1664~2487元/亩,但纯利润增加1584~2459元/亩。 Organic planting is paid much attention due to its safety, green and sustainable characteristics. In this study, two planting systems including organic and conventional cultivation were compared to evaluate their effects on the quality and profits of Chinese flowering cabbage in Guangdong province. In organic farming system, chicken manure and seaweed/protein hydrolysates were used as base and topdressing fertilizers, and artificial weeding and frequency vibration of insecticidal lamp were adopted to prevent disease and insect pest. In conventional planting, compound fertilizers were used as base and topdressing fertilizers, and herbicide, insecticide and bactericide were used to prevent weed and pest damages. Results indicated that under low temperature condition, the height and biomass of cabbage seedlings with spraying seaweed/protein hydrolysates were 103.2%~111.7% and 102.6%~108.5% of those with water. At harvesting periods, in comparison to conventional planting, the contents of soluble sugar, soluble protein, vitamin C in flowering cabbage were increased by 18.8%~23.2%, 24.3%~30.8% and 9.0%~18.5% respectively, while those of coarse fiber and titratable acid were reduced by 7.1%~20.5% and 6.5%~8.1% in organic planting system. The total soluble solid of cabbage did not vary greatly, and it was tasted sweet. Results from economic analysis indicated that more investment cost of 1664 to 2487 yuan per mu was needed in organic planting system than that in conventional planting system, but a net profit of 1584 to 2459 yuan per mu in the former one.
Biology,Business,Agricultural and Food Sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?