Abstract:Abstract Background The 16S mitochondrial rRNA gene is the most widely sequenced molecular marker in amphibian systematic studies, making it comparable to the universal CO1 barcode that is more commonly used in other animal groups. However, studies employ different primer combinations that target different lengths/regions of the 16S gene ranging from complete gene sequences (~ 1500 bp) to short fragments (~ 500 bp), the latter of which is the most ubiquitously used. Sequences of different lengths are often concatenated, compared, and/or jointly analyzed to infer phylogenetic relationships, estimate genetic divergence ( p -distances), and justify the recognition of new species (species delimitation), making the 16S gene region, by far, the most influential molecular marker in amphibian systematics. Despite their ubiquitous and multifarious use, no studies have ever been conducted to evaluate the congruence and performance among the different fragment lengths. Results Using empirical data derived from both Sanger-based and genomic approaches, we show that full-length 16S sequences recover the most accurate phylogenetic relationships, highest branch support, lowest variation in genetic distances (pairwise p -distances), and best-scoring species delimitation partitions. In contrast, widely used short fragments produce inaccurate phylogenetic reconstructions, lower and more variable branch support, erratic genetic distances, and low-scoring species delimitation partitions, the numbers of which are vastly overestimated. The relatively poor performance of short 16S fragments is likely due to insufficient phylogenetic information content. Conclusions Taken together, our results demonstrate that short 16S fragments are unable to match the efficacy achieved by full-length sequences in terms of topological accuracy, heuristic branch support, genetic divergences, and species delimitation partitions, and thus, phylogenetic and taxonomic inferences that are predicated on short 16S fragments should be interpreted with caution. However, short 16S fragments can still be useful for species identification, rapid assessments, or definitively coupling complex life stages in natural history studies and faunal inventories. While the full 16S sequence performs best, it requires the use of several primer pairs that increases cost, time, and effort. As a compromise, our results demonstrate that practitioners should utilize medium-length primers in favor of the short-fragment primers because they have the potential to markedly improve phylogenetic inference and species delimitation without additional cost.

Development and validation of a universal primer pair for the taxonomic and phylogenetic studies of vertebrates

Species identification through mitochondrial rRNA genetic analysis

Identification of Mammalian Species Using the Short and Highly Variable Regions of Mitochondrial DNA.

Universal DNA primers for amplification of complete mitochondrial protein-coding genes and ribosomal RNA genes from Crocodilia

Study on the Bacterial Identification Using 16S-23S Rrna Gene Spacer Regions

A new versatile primer set targeting a short fragment of the mitochondrial COI region for metabarcoding metazoan diversity: application for characterizing coral reef fish gut contents

Development of a Prokaryotic Universal Primer for Simultaneous Analysis of Bacteria and Archaea Using Next-Generation Sequencing

A rapid, inexpensive, culture-free, universal bacterial identification system using internal transcribed spacer targeting primers: a proof-of-principle study

Development of a rapid, culture-free, universal microbial identification system using internal transcribed spacer targeting primers

A PCR Method That Can Be Further Developed into PCR-RFLP Assay for Eight Animal Species Identification

Development and validation of versatile species-specific primer assays for eDNA monitoring and authentication of 10 commercially important Peruvian marine species

Development of short‐target primers for species identification in biological studies of Carnivora

Three-gene PCR and high-resolution melting analysis for differentiating vertebrate species mitochondrial DNA for biodiversity research and complementing forensic surveillance

Exploring the feasibility of utilizing universal primers in detecting mucormycosis pathogens: An in-silico analysis

Development of primer pairs from diverse chloroplast genomes for use in plant phylogenetic research

Design of Targeted Primers Based on 16S Rrna Sequences in Meta-Transcriptomic Datasets and Identification of a Novel Taxonomic Group in the Asgard Archaea.

Widely used, short 16S rRNA mitochondrial gene fragments yield poor and erratic results in phylogenetic estimation and species delimitation of amphibians

Developing the script "degenerate primer 111" to enhance the coverage of universal primers for the small subunit rRNA gene on target microorganisms

Redesign of PCR primers for mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase subunit I for marine invertebrates and application in all‐taxa biotic surveys

Development of mitochondrial DNA cytochrome c oxidase subunit I primer sets to construct DNA barcoding library using next-generation sequencing

Development of environmental DNA metabarcoding primers for marine mollusks and comparison with published primers