Abstract:This paper examines hybrid threats to maritime transportation systems and their governance responses; focusing on the congested Straits of Malacca and Singapore (SOMS) as an illustrative case study. The methodology combines secondary sources with primary data from 42 expert interviews, a 28 respondent survey, and two maritime security roundtables. Key findings were that ships' critical systems are increasingly interconnected, yet aging IT infrastructure and minimal cybersecurity awareness among crews heighten risks. Meanwhile, regional terrorist groups have previously targeted shipping and shown considerable skill in exploiting online tools, aligning with broader calls for jihadist violence. Furthermore, opportunistic piracy persists in the SOMS with the potential to disrupt shipping. Experts confirmed that maritime cybersecurity lags behind other critical infrastructure sectors and needs updated governance. Initial International Maritime Organization (IMO) guidelines lack specificity but revisions and updated IMO guidance are in process, while Port state implementation of maritime cybersecurity standards varies. Crucially, information sharing remains inadequate, even as recorded attacks increase. Findings underscore that although major hybrid incidents have not occurred, simulations and threat actors' capabilities demonstrate potential for catastrophic collisions or cascading disruption in congested waterways. Mitigating factors like redundancy and crew training are deficient currently. Some alignment between SOMS states on maritime security cooperation exists, but not on cyber threats specifically. Key recommendations include an anonymous cyber attack reporting system, reinforced training and shipboard systems, and consolidated regional frameworks. Until these priorities are addressed, the analysis concludes that hybrid vulnerabilities in this vital global chokepoint remain a serious concern.

Safety measure and cost benefit assessment for ship collision in the Malacca straits using AIS data

Navigation Safety for Marine Traffic in the Malacca Strait using AIS Data

Ship Collision Risk Assessment using AIS Data

Maritime Safety Analysis in Retrospect

ANALYSIS OF COLLISION AVOIDANCE IN THE MALACCA STRAITS BASED ON HUMAN FACTOR MODEL AND AIS DATA

Prediction of Ship Collision Risk on Singapore Strait Using AIS Data

Collision Avoidance Evaluation for Vessels Navigating in the Straits of Malacca

Fuzzy FMEA model for risk evaluation of ship collisions in the Malacca Strait: based on AIS data

An Economic Approach to Maritime Risk Management and Safety Regulation

A quantitative method for the analysis of ship collision risk using AIS data

Ship collision risk assessment for the Singapore Strait

Data mining analysis on Ships collision risk and marine traffic characteristic of Port Klang Malaysia waterways from automatic identification system (AIS) / Masnawi Mustaffa ... [et al.]

Preliminary study on Strait of Malacca Tide Wave Characteristic from AIS Data Mining

ANALYSIS OF MARITIME ACCIDENTS IN MALAYSIAN WATERS

Ais Data Based Identification Of Systematic Collision Risk For Maritime Intelligent Transport System

Analyses and Implications of Accidents in Singapore Strait

A Case Study of Hybrid Maritime Security in the Straits of Malacca and Singapore

New frontiers in the risk assessment of ship collision

DYNAMIC COLLISION RISK ASSESMENT OF TANKER ON MADURA STRAIT SHIPPING LINE BY USING TRAFFIC BASED MODEL

Safety Assessment of Shipping Routes in the South China Sea Based on the Fuzzy Analytic Hierarchy Process

Risk Assessment of Ship Traffic Safety in Port Waters Based on AIS Data