Abstract:Mixed models are now well-established methods in ecology and evolution because they allow accounting for and quantifying within- and between-individual variation. However, the required normal distribution of the random effects can often be violated by the presence of clusters among subjects, which leads to multi-modal distributions. In such cases, using what is known as mixture regression models might offer a more appropriate approach. These models are widely used in psychology, sociology, and medicine to describe the diversity of trajectories occurring within a population over time (e.g. psychological development, growth). In ecology and evolution, however, these models are seldom used even though understanding changes in individual trajectories is an active area of research in life-history studies. Our aim is to demonstrate the value of using mixture models to describe variation in individual life-history tactics within a population, and hence to promote the use of these models by ecologists and evolutionary ecologists. We first ran a set of simulations to determine whether and when a mixture model allows teasing apart latent clustering, and to contrast the precision and accuracy of estimates obtained from mixture models versus mixed models under a wide range of ecological contexts. We then used empirical data from long-term studies of large mammals to illustrate the potential of using mixture models for assessing within-population variation in life-history tactics. Mixture models performed well in most cases, except for variables following a Bernoulli distribution and when sample size was small. The four selection criteria we evaluated [Akaike information criterion (AIC), Bayesian information criterion (BIC), and two bootstrap methods] performed similarly well, selecting the right number of clusters in most ecological situations. We then showed that the normality of random effects implicitly assumed by evolutionary ecologists when using mixed models was often violated in life-history data. Mixed models were quite robust to this violation in the sense that fixed effects were unbiased at the population level. However, fixed effects at the cluster level and random effects were better estimated using mixture models. Our empirical analyses demonstrated that using mixture models facilitates the identification of the diversity of growth and reproductive tactics occurring within a population. Therefore, using this modelling framework allows testing for the presence of clusters and, when clusters occur, provides reliable estimates of fixed and random effects for each cluster of the population. In the presence or expectation of clusters, using mixture models offers a suitable extension of mixed models, particularly when evolutionary ecologists aim at identifying how ecological and evolutionary processes change within a population. Mixture regression models therefore provide a valuable addition to the statistical toolbox of evolutionary ecologists. As these models are complex and have their own limitations, we provide recommendations to guide future users.

Combining envelope methodology and aster models for variance reduction in life history analyses

Local adaptation and genetic effects on fitness: Calculations for exponential family models with random effects

General model-free weighted envelope estimation

Weighted envelope estimation to handle variability in model selection

Estimating arthropod survival probability from field counts: a case study with monarch butterflies

METHODS Skewed distributions of lifetime reproductive success: beyond mean and variance

Multiple‐batch spawning as a bet‐hedging strategy in highly stochastic environments: An exploratory analysis of Atlantic cod

Detecting non-binomial sex allocation when developmental mortality operates

Skewed Distributions of LRS: Beyond Mean and Variance

Combining geometric morphometrics and finite element analysis with evolutionary modeling: towards a synthesis

Evolutionary Fitness in Variable Environments

Reliable and efficient parameter estimation using approximate continuum limit descriptions of stochastic models

Expansions of Price Equation for Viability and Fecundity Selection

Metabolism, Growth, and the Energetic Definition of Fitness: A Quantitative Genetic Study in the Land Snail Cornu aspersum

Modelling insect demography from capture–recapture data: comparison between the constrained linear models and the Jolly–Seber analytical method

Likelihood Function through the Delta Approximation in Mixed SDE Models

Mating system and the evolution of sex-specific mortality rates in two nymphalid butterflies

Model-free Envelope Dimension Selection

Assessing variation in life-history tactics within a population using mixture regression models: a practical guide for evolutionary ecologists

Improved state-space models for inference about spatial and temporal variation in abundance from count data

Reducing Subspace Models for Large-Scale Covariance Regression