Material Flow Patterns of the Global Waste Paper Trade and Potential Impacts of China’s Import Ban

Zijie Ma,Yi Yang,Wei-Qiang Chen,Peng Wang,Chao Wang,Chao Zhang,Jianbang Gan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.1c00642

2021-06-21

Abstract:Waste paper, an essential substitute for wood and other plant-based fibers in paper making, is an indispensable part of the circular economy; yet, the impacts of China's ban on global waste paper cycles have not been well understood. We modeled the evolution of the global waste paper trade network during 1995–2019. We found that the cumulative trade volume of global waste paper reached 1010 million tons in the last 25 years and showed a downward trend since 2015. The global import center of waste paper experienced a transfer from Europe to East Asia and then to Southeast Asia. The ban has stimulated some developed countries to reduce the exports of unsorted waste paper since 2017, but for many major importers their changes in waste paper trade patterns were related to waste paperboard, which was not banned by China, suggesting that this import change trend may be inevitable and irrespective of China's ban. Besides, India has replaced China to become a new import hub of unsorted waste paper. Our results lay a foundation for exploring the evolution of the future global solid waste cycle under the background of zero import of solid waste increasingly implemented by China and many other developing countries.The global waste paper trade center shows the transfer trend from Europe to East Asia and then to Southeast Asia.This article has not yet been cited by other publications.

environmental sciences,engineering, environmental

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the impact of China's ban on imported waste paper on the global waste - paper trade network. Specifically, by modeling the evolution of the global waste - paper trade network from 1995 to 2019, the author explored the following issues:

1. **Evolution pattern of the global waste - paper trade network**: Study how the structure of the global waste - paper trade network changes over time, especially after China implemented the import ban.
2. **Key nodes and their trade patterns**: Identify the countries and regions that play important roles in the global waste - paper trade and analyze the trade patterns of these key nodes.
3. **Potential impacts of China's waste - paper import ban**: Evaluate the impact of China's waste - paper import ban on the global waste - paper recycling and propose policy recommendations for sustainable development.

### Background of the paper

As an important alternative material, waste paper is widely used in the paper - making industry and helps promote the development of the circular economy. However, changes in China's waste - paper import policies, especially the waste - paper import ban implemented since 2017, have had a significant impact on the global waste - paper trade. Using the complex network theory, the paper analyzed the evolution pattern of the global waste - paper trade network and the impact of China's ban on this network.

### Research methods

1. **System boundaries and trade network model**: The study covered more than 200 countries and regions from 1995 to 2019. Waste - paper commodities include four subtypes (HS code 4707), namely waste carton board (470710), waste office paper (470720), waste newspaper (470730) and mixed unclassified waste paper (470790).
2. **Data sources and processing**: Use the annual import and export data from the United Nations Comtrade database to study the evolution of the global waste - paper trade network. During the data processing, the problems of data inconsistency and missing data were solved.
3. **Complex network indicators**: Use indicators such as degree centrality (In - Degree and Out - Degree), strength (In - Strength and Out - Strength) and modularity index (Modularity Index) to analyze the network structure.

### Main findings

1. **Uneven distribution of global waste - paper trade**: The global waste - paper trade grew rapidly in the early 21st century, reached its peak in 2012 and then began to decline with fluctuations. As the largest waste - paper importer, China's relevant policies have had a significant impact on the global waste - paper trade.
2. **Characteristics of key nodes**: China and the United States are the largest net importer and net exporter respectively. Other key nodes can be divided into export clusters, import clusters and countries with both imports and exports.
3. **Evolution of trade patterns**: The global waste - paper trade mainly flows from developed countries to developing countries. China has gradually become an important country for waste - paper recycling from 1995 to 2019. After 2018, India has gradually replaced China as the new waste - paper import center.
4. **Impact of China's waste - paper import ban**: The ban has not significantly changed the structure of the global waste - paper trade network, but has promoted some developed countries to reduce the export of unclassified waste paper. Meanwhile, Asian countries such as India and Vietnam have increased their waste - paper import volumes.

### Conclusion

Using the complex network theory, the paper analyzed in detail the evolution pattern of the global waste - paper trade network and the potential impact of China's waste - paper import ban. The research results show that although China's ban has had an impact on the waste - paper trade in some countries, the main flow direction of the global waste - paper trade remains unchanged. In addition, countries such as India are gradually becoming new waste - paper import centers, which may bring new environmental challenges. The research provides policy recommendations for the sustainable development of global solid waste recycling in the future.