Abstract:The software development community has been using code quality metrics for the last five decades. Despite their wide adoption, code quality metrics have attracted a fair share of criticism. In this paper, first, we carry out a qualitative exploration by surveying software developers to gauge their opinions about current practices and potential gaps with the present set of metrics. We identify deficiencies including lack of soundness, i.e., the ability of a metric to capture a notion accurately as promised by the metric, lack of support for assessing software architecture quality, and insufficient support for assessing software testing and infrastructure. In the second part of the paper, we focus on one specific code quality metric-LCOM as a case study to explore opportunities towards improved metrics. We evaluate existing LCOM algorithms qualitatively and quantitatively to observe how closely they represent the concept of cohesion. In this pursuit, we first create eight diverse cases that any LCOM algorithm must cover and obtain their cohesion levels by a set of experienced developers and consider them as a ground truth. We show that the present set of LCOM algorithms do poorly w.r.t. these cases. To bridge the identified gap, we propose a new approach to compute LCOM and evaluate the new approach with the ground truth. We also show, using a quantitative analysis using more than 90 thousand types belonging to 261 high-quality Java repositories, the present set of methods paint a very inaccurate and misleading picture of class cohesion. We conclude that the current code quality metrics in use suffer from various deficiencies, presenting ample opportunities for the research community to address the gaps.

An approach for improving the concept of Cyclomatic Complexity for Object-Oriented Programming

Improved Iterative Object-Oriented Reengineering Process based on Dynamic Coupling Measures

IMPROVING ON OBJECT ORIENTED SOFTWARE COUPLING METRIC

Software testing method researching of Cyclomatic complexity

Design Level Metrics to Measure the Complexity Across Versions of AO Software

Assessment of maintainability metrics for object-oriented software system

The utility of complexity metrics during code reviews for CSE software projects

Mechanical Engineering Design Complexity Metrics: Size, Coupling, and Solvability

The Correlation among Software Complexity Metrics with Case Study

Research on Object Oriented Software Fan-in Coupling Metric

Significance of Coupling and Cohesion on Design Quality

Evaluate How Cyclomatic Complexity Changes in the Context of Software Evolution

Statistical analysis of software coupling measurement based on complex networks

A Metrics-Based Comparative Study on Object-Oriented Programming Languages.

A New Complexity Metric for UML Sequence Diagrams

A Parsing Scheme for Finding the Design Pattern and Reducing the Development Cost of Reusable Object Oriented Software

Improving the Testability of Object-oriented Software during Testing and Debugging Processes

Do We Need Improved Code Quality Metrics?

The Impact of Mutability on Cyclomatic Complexity in Java

Interactive Complexity: Software Metrics from an Ecosystem Perspective

Evaluating the Dependency Between Cyclomatic Complexity and Response For Class