Current evidences in poorly differentiated thyroid carcinoma: a systematic review and subsection meta-analysis for clinical decision making

Sataksi Chatterjee,Manish Mair,Ashok R. Shaha,Vinidh Paleri,Shikhar Sawhney,Aananya Mishra,Swayambhu Bhandarkar,Anil Keith D’Cruz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12020-024-03771-x
2024-03-21
Endocrine
Abstract:Poorly differentiated thyroid carcinoma (PDTC) is a distinct entity with intermediate prognosis between indolent follicular thyroid cancers and anaplastic carcinoma. The management guidelines are not standardized for these cancers due its low prevalence and limited available literature. Therefore, we did this systematic review with emphasis on current evidence on diagnosis, imaging, molecular markers, and management of these carcinomas.
endocrinology & metabolism
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the lack of standardized guidelines regarding the diagnosis, imaging examinations, molecular markers, and management strategies of poorly differentiated thyroid carcinoma (PDTC). Due to the low incidence of PDTC and the limited relevant literature, its management guidelines have not been standardized yet. Therefore, this systematic review aims to explore the diagnosis, imaging features, molecular marker expression, and management methods of PDTC through current evidence to support clinical decision - making. ### Main research questions: 1. **Diagnostic criteria**: Explore the pathological diagnostic criteria of PDTC and the prognostic differences under different diagnostic criteria. 2. **Imaging examinations**: Evaluate the application of different imaging techniques in the diagnosis and staging of PDTC. 3. **Molecular markers**: Analyze the expression of common molecular markers in PDTC and their clinical significance. 4. **Management strategies**: Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of surgical treatment, radioactive iodine treatment (RAI), radiotherapy, and other non - surgical treatments for PDTC. ### Research background: - **Definition of PDTC**: PDTC is an entity between indolent follicular thyroid carcinoma and anaplastic carcinoma, with an intermediate prognosis. - **Diagnostic challenges**: Pre - operative fine - needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) has a low diagnostic accuracy for PDTC and there is morphological overlap with other subtypes of thyroid carcinoma. - **Molecular markers**: Common molecular markers include TERT, BRAF, and P53, etc. The expression of these markers is related to the invasiveness and prognosis of PDTC. - **Management status quo**: Currently, there are differences in the management strategies of PDTC, especially in terms of radioactive iodine treatment, the scope of neck lymph node dissection, and adjuvant treatment. ### Methods: - **Literature search**: Search for relevant literature up to October 2023 in four databases: PubMed, Medline, EMBASE, and Emcare. - **Inclusion criteria**: Include studies reporting diagnostic tests, imaging, molecular marker expression, and management of PDTC. - **Data analysis**: Use a random - effects model for meta - analysis to calculate the pooled estimates of molecular marker expression and their 95% confidence intervals. ### Results: - **Pathological diagnosis**: There are differences in the pathological diagnostic criteria of PDTC, and different diagnostic criteria will affect prognosis assessment. - **Imaging**: Ultrasonography is the preferred imaging method for evaluating the lesion range of PDTC, but CT or MRI may be required for the evaluation of advanced diseases. - **Molecular markers**: The most commonly expressed molecular markers are TERT (41%), BRAF (28%), and P53 (25%). - **Management strategies**: Surgical treatment is recommended for early - stage PDTC, but for locally advanced or metastatic PDTC, non - surgical treatments such as targeted therapy and immunotherapy are being explored. ### Conclusions: - **High fatality rate**: The fatality rate of PDTC is as high as 31%, and 85% of patients die due to distant metastasis. - **Personalized treatment**: Although there are few literature reports, evidence - based management strategies are helpful for personalized treatment, thereby optimizing the prognosis of patients. Through this systematic review, the author hopes to provide clinicians with the latest evidence on PDTC in order to better guide clinical decision - making.