Effects of the First Wave of the COVID-19 Pandemic on the Work Readiness of Undergraduate Nursing Students in China: A Mixed-Methods Study
Lifang He,Jean Rizza Dela Cruz
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/rmhp.s448965
2024-03-12
Risk Management and Healthcare Policy
Abstract:Lifang He, 1, 2 Jean Rizza A Dela Cruz 3 1 School of Nursing, XiangNan University, Chenzhou, 423000, People's Republic of China; 2 College of Nursing and Allied Health Sciences St.Paul University Manila, Manila, 1004, Philippines; 3 Department of Nursing Olivarez College Tagaytay, Tagaytay City, 4120, Philippines Correspondence: Jean Rizza A Dela Cruz, Department of Nursing Olivarez College Tagaytay, Tagaytay City, 4120, Philippines, Tel +639175507389, Email Background: Newly graduated nurses with strong work readiness are more likely to smoothly transition from school to clinical settings. However, even before the pandemic, this transition from nursing graduate to clinical nurse was often challenging. Therefore, this study aims to investigate the impact of the initial wave of COVID-19 on the work readiness of nursing students. Methods: A convergent mixed-method design was employed. For the quantitative study, an online cross-sectional survey was conducted among 500 graduating nursing students from four Chinese public higher education institutions. The questionnaire comprises three parts: socio-demographic information, the Chinese version of the Work Readiness Scale for Graduate Nurse, and a questionnaire on the socio-behavioral impact of COVID-19 on the general population. In the qualitative study, a semi-structured interview was carried out with 8 students who took part in the survey. The results from both parts were integrated using the "Pillar Integration Process". Results: The study identified six key pillars: "Graduating nursing students possess fundamental knowledge, skills, and a preparedness in terms of attitude and psychology"; "Specialist knowledge and skills and soft skills for transition from nursing students to clinical nurses need to be strengthened"; "The most obvious impact of COVID-19 on nursing students are the adoption of preventive measures and the limitations in study and daily life due to household confinement"; "Growth in both personal and professional awareness"; "Negative effects of fear and anxiety"; and "Negative effects of household confinement". Conclusion: Graduating nursing students require additional preparation in specialized nursing knowledge, skills, and soft skills to make a successful transition from students to clinical nurses. It is important to acknowledge that the impact of COVID-19 on students' work readiness has both positive and negative aspects. Therefore, whether during the pandemic or post-graduation, these students will benefit from increased support from universities and hospitals. Keywords: work readiness, COVID-19, nursing students, nursing education, mixed methods, pillar integration process Nowadays, the global shortage of nurses presents a significant challenge. Effectively and swiftly transitioning from school to clinical work, as well as retaining nursing staff, has become a crucial concern within academic circles and various medical institutions. However, owing to the highly specialized and high-risk nature of clinical work, the demanding workload, patient complexity, and a general lack of confidence and experience among graduates, the shift from graduate to clinical nurse often proves less seamless than anticipated. 1,2 Nursing graduates encounter challenges upon entering the workforce, experiencing not only the transition from a school to a professional environment, but also a shift in their social roles. According to the Ulupinar & Aydogan study, 47.7% of newly graduated nurses faced difficulties adjusting to nursing work in their initial year, with 53.5% struggling to adapt to their roles, 42.5% contemplating leaving the nursing industry, and 50.9% planning to depart from their respective organizations. 3 Similarly, in China, 17.2% of newly graduated nurses intend to leave shortly after commencing their careers; this percentage escalated to 59.6%, 74.4%, and 71.8% after four months, eight months, and one year, respectively. 4 Recent studies have indicated that new graduate nurses with strong work readiness are more likely to navigate the transition from school to the hospital setting with greater ease, and this readiness level serves as an indicator of their potential for future performance and career development. 5 However, the current state of work readiness among new graduate nurses is not encouraging. Most studies reveal that they tend to lack practical preparation in complex professional domains. Kavanagh et al examined the entry-level competencies and practical readiness of new graduate nurses and discovered that only 23% of them met the entry-level competencies. 6 In the study by Missen et al, the coordinator for nurse residency programs obs -Abstract Truncated-
health care sciences & services,health policy & services