Unleashing the Power of Closed-Loop Supply Chains: A Stackelberg Game Analysis of Rare Earth Resources Recycling

Chenghao Lai,Xiuli Wang,Hengkai Li,Yanbing Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16124899

IF: 3.9

2024-06-08

Sustainability

Abstract:Due to the rapid development of the clean energy sector against the global backdrop of carbon emission reduction, the availability of rare earths is becoming scarce. The strategic recycling of rare earth resources serves the dual purpose of alleviating supply shortages and aligning with the global quest for carbon reduction and environmental preservation. This study establishes a second-level, closed-loop supply chain that includes a rare earth group (REG) that synergizes rare earth mining and smelting companies with rare earth material manufacturing companies, as well as a specialized rare earth recycler. The study considers three different recycling scenarios: the recycler only recycles oil sludge scrap (S1), the recycler only recycles end-of-life products (S2), and the recycler both recycles oil sludge scrap and end-of-life products (S3). In addition, the study examines the impact of government subsidies, carbon trading mechanisms, and corporate research and development (R&D) initiatives on closed-loop supply chains. The findings are summarized below. (1) Rare earth recycling does not impact the rare earth market downstream. (2) The profits of both REG and the recycler have a positive correlation with the quantity of recycling. However, recycling sludge waste can generate higher revenues for the recycler compared to recycling end-of-life products. (3) Government subsidies exert a positive effect on the recycler's profits and the production of secondary rare earths. However, the REG redirects a segment of the recycler's profits in its direction. Elevated carbon trading prices encroach upon the REG's profitability, prompting increased procurement of secondary supply rare earths. (4) The benefits of increasing rare earth recycling rates outweigh government subsidies and carbon trading valuations in the supply chain. Therefore, enterprise-focused research and development initiatives play a critical role in improving the efficiency of the closed-loop rare earth supply chain.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in the context of global carbon emission reduction, due to the development of the clean energy industry, rare earth resources have become scarce. How to alleviate the supply shortage through rare earth recycling in the closed - loop supply chain and be consistent with the global goals of carbon emission reduction and environmental protection? Specifically, the paper constructs a two - level closed - loop supply chain model, which includes a Rare Earth Group (REG). This group integrates rare earth mining and smelting companies as well as rare earth material manufacturing companies, and there is also a specialized rare earth recycler. The research considers three different recycling scenarios: the recycler only recycles sludge waste (S1), the recycler only recycles waste products (S2), and the recycler recycles both sludge waste and waste products (S3). In addition, the research also explores the impacts of government subsidies, carbon trading mechanisms and corporate research and development (R&D) activities on the closed - loop supply chain.

The main objectives of the paper are to answer the following questions:
1. How does the reverse supply of rare earths affect the downstream part of the rare earth industry?
2. What are the respective impacts of different recycling sources on the rare earth group and the recycling entities?
3. How do the strategies of the government and enterprises affect the closed - loop supply chain, and how do these strategies contribute to achieving "Pareto optimality" within the framework of the closed - loop supply chain?

Through the exploration of these questions, the paper aims to provide an in - depth understanding of how rare earth recycling can be economically viable and how to promote the effective management and sustainable use of rare earth resources through policy and technological progress.