Abstract:Calcium imaging with fluorescent protein sensors is widely used to record activity in neuronal populations. The transform between neural activity and calcium-related fluorescence involves nonlinearities and low-pass filtering, but the effects of the transformation on analyses of neural populations are not well understood. We compared neuronal spikes and fluorescence in matched neural populations in behaving mice. We report multiple discrepancies between analyses performed on the two types of data, including changes in single-neuron selectivity and population decoding. These were only partially resolved by spike inference algorithms applied to fluorescence. To model the relation between spiking and fluorescence we simultaneously recorded spikes and fluorescence from individual neurons. Using these recordings we developed a model transforming spike trains to synthetic-imaging data. The model recapitulated the differences in analyses. Our analysis highlights challenges in relating electrophysiology and imaging data, and suggests forward modeling as an effective way to understand differences between these data.Many studies in neuroscience revolve around understanding the patterns of activity of neurons and their relation to behavior. To be able to address such questions one must first record the activity of neurons. Broadly speaking, two different approaches are commonly used, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. Imaging can sample neural activity of hundreds of neurons in a local area and can be targeted to specific cell-types. But it does not record activity directly, reporting it rather through a transformation from intracellular calcium. Electrophysiological recordings report neural activity directly with high temporal precision but have limitations of their own such as being less likely to accurately pickup neurons with low activity. We compared neuronal spikes and fluorescence recorded in matched neural populations in behaving mice performing the same task. We report multiple discrepancies between analyses performed on the two types of data at the single neuron and population level. We developed a model transforming spike trains to synthetic-imaging data which recapitulated many of the differences in analyses. Our analysis highlights challenges in relating electrophysiology and imaging data, and suggests forward modeling as an effective way to predict and understand differences between them.

Information-Theoretic Approach and Fundamental Limits of Resolving Two Closely Timed Neuronal Spikes in Mouse Brain Calcium Imaging

Accurate spike estimation from noisy calcium signals for ultrafast three-dimensional imaging of large neuronal populations in vivo

Exact Continuous Spiking Rate Inference

Direct Estimation of Firing Rates from Calcium Imaging Data

Time-varying $\ell_0$ optimization for Spike Inference from Multi-Trial Calcium Recordings

Predicting neuronal firing from calcium imaging using a control theoretic approach

High-fidelity Estimates of Spikes and Subthreshold Waveforms from 1-Photon Voltage Imaging in Vivo.

Community-based benchmarking improves spike rate inference from two-photon calcium imaging data

High-speed low-light in vivo two-photon voltage imaging of large neuronal populations

A comparison of neuronal population dynamics measured with calcium imaging and electrophysiology

Seizure Event Detection Using Intravital Two-Photon Calcium Imaging Data

A structured matrix factorization framework for large scale calcium imaging data analysis

Spike inference from mouse spinal cord calcium imaging data

Multiscale relevance and informative encoding in neuronal spike trains

Correlation in Neuronal Calcium Spiking: Quantification based on Empirical Mutual Information Rate

Supervised learning sets benchmark for robust spike detection from calcium imaging signals

Information Content in Neuronal Calcium Spike Trains: Entropy Rate Estimation based on Empirical Probabilities

What can neuromorphic event-driven precise timing add to spike-based pattern recognition?

Bayesian nonparametric analysis for the detection of spikes in noisy calcium imaging data

Simultaneous dual-color calcium imaging in freely-behaving mice

An Algorithm Based on a Cable-Nernst Planck Model Predicting Synaptic Activity throughout the Dendritic Arbor with Micron Specificity