A New School, a Fresh Start? Change and Stability in Peer Relationships and Academic Performance in the Transition from Primary to Secondary School
Sofie J. Lorijn,Dieuwke Zwier,Lydia Laninga-Wijnen,Mark Huisman,René Veenstra
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-024-01991-y
2024-05-08
Journal of Youth and Adolescence
Abstract:Previous studies on peer relationships in school transitions neglected individual differences, or did not examine the relation with academic performance in secondary school. This study followed 649 students from their last year of primary school to their first year in secondary school ( M age at T1 = 11.6 ( SD = 0.6); 53.6% girls). Results revealed that students became more attached to peers, less lonely, and were stable in victimization across the transition. Particularly students with more negative peer experiences in primary school enjoyed a "fresh start" in terms of peer experiences in secondary school. Students who had more co-transitioning peers experienced greater reductions in loneliness. Changes in peer experiences over the transition did not relate to academic performance in secondary school.
psychology, developmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore the changes and stability in students' peer relationships (including attachment, loneliness, and bullying) during the transition from elementary to middle school, and to examine the impact of these changes on academic performance in middle school.
### Main Research Questions:
1. **Changes and Stability in Peer Relationships**: The paper focuses on whether students' peer attachment, loneliness, and bullying experiences change or remain stable during the transition from elementary to middle school.
2. **Predictors of Peer Experiences**: It investigates how peer experiences in elementary school and the proportion of classmates transitioning to the same middle school influence these changes in peer relationships.
3. **Impact of Changes in Peer Experiences on Academic Performance**: The study examines whether changes in peer relationships affect students' academic performance.
### Research Background:
- The school transition period is challenging for students, especially in terms of peer relationships and social adaptation.
- Previous research has mainly focused on the average effects of changes in peer relationships, neglecting individual differences.
- Students with negative peer experiences in elementary school may have a "fresh start" in middle school, but the specific mechanisms are unclear.
- Whether changes in peer relationships impact academic performance is also an underexplored question.
### Research Methods:
- Data Source: The study uses data from the PRIMS project, which investigates the transition from elementary to middle school.
- Sample: 649 students were tracked from the last semester of elementary school to the first semester of middle school.
- Measurement Indicators: Peer attachment, loneliness, bullying experiences, and academic performance.
- Statistical Analysis: Latent Change Score Models were used to analyze the changes.
### Research Hypotheses:
1. Students with poor peer relationships in elementary school may improve in middle school.
2. The more classmates transition together, the more stable the peer relationships.
3. Positive changes in peer relationships may lead to better academic performance.
Through this study, the authors hope to better understand the changes in peer relationships during the school transition period and their impact on academic performance, thereby providing guidance for educational practice.