Letter: -125I-fibrinogen test in diagnosis of deep vein thrombosis.

C. Ruckley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.5969.498-c

1975-05-31

British Medical Journal

Abstract:SM,-In your leading aricle (10 May, p. 296) on the risks of total hip rePlacement, you mention introperative circulatory collapse attributed to acrylic cement. Modig says that the literature records "at least 30 deaths during the operative procedure and possibly there are many moire unrecorded cases." The original reports which led to the Department of Health and Social Security -setting up an inquiry in 1971 a-re now over four years old and during these four years the use of acrylic cement in hip therapy must have mutliplied many times, but we no longer seem to hear of these complications in the scientific meetings of surgeons who are using this subsitance almost daily. 'This would appear to be the case even when used to cement femoral head prostheises in suboapital fractures of the neck of the femur, though special danger in this case was a feature of ithe literature ito which the D.MH.SS. report2 drew our attention. I think I am right in saying that all experinen;tal investigations have now exonerated methylnethacrylate monomer in the concentrations likely to be encounitered in the blood stream during a surgical operation. The other suggestions, such as fiat embolism, neurogenic impulses from raised intramed,ullary pressure, or microemboli of thtromoplastic products from the marrow, all seem unsatiisfactory as explanations of sudden intraoperative collapse leading to death. It is importanrt from the historical point of view that we should try to put the record straight now thart we lhave four years of hindsight. Are these complications still occurring in any numbers or even at all? Most especially, are they still occurring during total 'hip replacement? The possibility of collapse after suddenly removing a tourniquet when acrylic cemenit has been used in a knee is perhaps a rather different matter. I would very much welcome oommunications from those interested in this subject.-I am, etc., JOHN CHARNLEY Centre for H:p Surgery, Wrightington Hospital, Wigan, Lancs