Abstract:Background: The phylogenetic ecology of the Afro-Asian dragonfly genus Trithemis has been investigated previously by Damm et al. (in Mol Phylogenet Evol 54:870-882, 2010) and wing ecomorphology by Outomuro et al. (in J Evol Biol 26:1866-1874, 2013). However, the latter investigation employed a somewhat coarse sampling of forewing and hindwing outlines and reported results that were at odds in some ways with expectations given the mapping of landscape and water-body preference over the Trithemis cladogram produced by Damm et al. (in Mol Phylogenet Evol 54:870-882, 2010). To further explore the link between species-specific wing shape variation and habitat we studied a new sample of 27 Trithemis species employing a more robust statistical test for phylogenetic covariation, more comprehensive representations of Trithemis wing morphology and a wider range of morphometric data-analysis procedures. Results: Contrary to the Outomuro et al. (in J Evol Biol 26:1866-1874, 2013) report, our results indicate that no statistically significant pattern of phylogenetic covariation exists in our Trithemis forewing and hindwing data and that both male and female wing datasets exhibit substantial shape differences between species that inhabit open and forested landscapes and species that hunt over temporary/standing or running water bodies. Among the morphometric analyses performed, landmark data and geometric morphometric data-analysis methods yielded the worst performance in identifying ecomorphometric shape distinctions between Trithemis habitat guilds. Direct analysis of wing images using an embedded convolution (deep learning) neural network delivered the best performance. Bootstrap and jackknife tests of group separations and discriminant-function stability confirm that our results are not artifacts of overtrained discriminant systems or the "curse of dimensionality" despite the modest size of our sample. Conclusion: Our results suggest that Trithemis wing morphology reflects the environment's "push" to a much greater extent than phylogeny's "pull". In addition, they indicate that close attention should be paid to the manner in which morphologies are sampled for morphometric analysis and, if no prior information is available to guide sampling strategy, the sample that most comprehensively represents the morphologies of interest should be obtained. In many cases this will be digital images (2D) or scans (3D) of the entire morphology or morphological feature rather than sparse sets of landmark/semilandmark point locations.

Quantitative Morphological Variation in the Developing Drosophila Wing

Molecular Mechanisms of Wing Polymorphism in Insects.

Transcriptome Analysis of the Regulatory Mechanism of FoxO on Wing Dimorphism in the Brown Planthopper, Nilaparvata Lugens (hemiptera: Delphacidae)

Comparative thoracic anatomy of the wild type and wingless (wg1cn1) mutant of Drosophila melanogaster (Diptera)

A Single-Wing Removal Method to Assess Correspondence Between Gene Expression and Phenotype in Butterflies: The Case of Distal-less

Dimensionality-Reduction in the Drosophila Wing as Revealed by Landmark-Free Measure-ments of Phenotype

Quantitative Relationships Between Growth, Differentiation, and Shape That Control Drosophila Eye Development and Its Variation

The Morphological Transformation of the Thorax During the Eclosion of Drosophila Melanogaster (diptera: Drosophilidae)

Natural variation in the regulation of neurodevelopmental genes modifies flight performance in Drosophila

A Quantitative Analysis of Growth and Size Regulation in Manduca sexta: The Physiological Basis of Variation in Size and Age at Metamorphosis

Morph‐specific life‐history correlations in a wing‐dimorphic water strider

The development of wing shape in Lepidoptera: mitotic density, not orientation, is the primary determinant of shape

Regulatory evolution tuning pigmentation intensity quantitatively in Drosophila

Quantifying the Bicoid morphogen gradient in living fly embryos

Quantitative Mechanical Evaluation and Analysis of Drosophila Embryos Through the Stages of Embryogenesis

Single Cell Transcriptomic Landscapes Of Pattern Formation, Proliferation And Growth In Drosophila Wing Imaginal Discs

A mechanical model for diversified insect wing margin shapes

A developmental atlas of male terminalia across twelve species of Drosophila

Developmental correspondence of juvenile stages across the locust, harlequin ladybird, and diamondback moth

What you sample is what you get: ecomorphological variation in Trithemis (Odonata, Libellulidae) dragonfly wings reconsidered

Gene regulatory dynamics during the development of a paleopteran insect, the mayfly Cloeon dipterum