Climbing and the Olympics
Luke Hughes
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1258/jmb.2012.012057
2012-08-01
Journal of Medical Biography
Abstract:The mountain guide, Kenton Cool (1973-), was reported by The Guardian (on 19 May 2012) to be proposing to take to the summit of Mount Everest the Olympic Gold Medal awarded to the medic Arthur Wakefield (1876–1949) for his part in the first full expedition to Everest in 1922 (Figure 1). The whole 1922 team, including the other medic, Howard Somervell (1890–1975), had been awarded medals for their contribution to the expedition. As it transpired, in 1924 Somervell bettered his 1922 high-point and struggled, without oxygen, to within 270 metres of the summit, a feat not matched until 1952 and only then with the use of supplementary oxygen. Baron Pierre de Coubertin (1863–1937), founder of the modern Olympics, admired the ethos behind mountaineering and wanted to recognize the pioneers’ exceptional achievements. Colonel Charles Bruce (1866–1939), the leader of the 1922 expedition was invited to accept the medals at the first winter Olympics in Chamonix in February 1924. He felt he was too busy preparing for the departure of the new expedition so he sent his deputy, Edward Strutt (1874– 1948) to collect the medals. Strutt commendably asked for, and secured, extra medals for the seven Sherpas who had been killed in an avalanche on the North ridge in 1922 and in so doing promised that no effort would be spared in meeting de Courbetin’s wish that a medal be carried to the summit. After Mallory and Irvine’s disappearance in June 1924, the pledge was forgotten. Cool finally completed the task on 24 May 2012. Roll on 64 years. In 1988 the Polish climber Jerzy Kukuczka (1948–89) and the Italian, Reinhold Messner (1944-) were retrospectively awarded Olympic Silver Medals for being the first to climb all 12 mountains in the world with summits greater than 8000 metres. So, leaving aside whether or not the choice of climbing as a sport is wise, the notion of recognizing it as worthy of Olympic recognition is not new. As Doug Scott, one of Britain’s most eminent mountaineers, has memorably pointed out the idea of competitive mountaineering was first promoted in the former Soviet bloc as early as 1948, heralding an approach that suffered a catastrophic setback in 1974 with the loss of eight Russian women climbers who had set out to make the first all-women traverse of Peak Lenin. Lacking experience and suitable equipment, they perished in a terrible storm at 23,000 ft; they were blinded to the build up of danger by their overwhelming ambition to succeed, being locked into a pre-planned itinerary that precluded changing direction as conditions dictated. The considerable backup of guides on patrol with radios and helicopters in the area may have induced a false sense of security. The disaster laid bare for all to see the problem of external organization subverting a small group from taking responsibility for their own lives through flexible selfreliance and prudent decision-making. This tragedy brought home to many the folly of promoting highaltitude mountaineering as another Olympic event (Figure 2). Today the questions appear to be both less noble and less aspirational. Golf and Rugby Sevens have just been voted on to the programme for the 2016 Olympics in Rio de Janeiro. Sport climbing is being considered for the Olympics 2020 along with fistball, korfball, flying disc (better known as Frisbee) and squash. A decision is expected from the International Olympic Committee (IOC) in Buenos Aires in 2013. Cynics point out that there are powerful new revenue streams for the IOC to exploit. Powerful brands (for example North Face) have for years been aching to get a stronger association with the Olympics. Most formal sports require formal competition to function; some, like climbing, do not. Outdoor sports can boast a high participation factor, certainly higher than many current Olympic disciplines. Yachting, horse-riding, mountain biking and canoeing all have Olympic status but are mostly valued as recreation. These are sports in which our increasingly clubby nation actually participates rather than just watching on television. The fact they are informal with few rules makes them more accessible. So one of the questions being debated by the climbing fraternity is whether the focus on competitions that Olympic status would bring will undermine climbing’s recreational appeal. There is a certain amount of tension between the purists and the pragmatists. The British Mountaineering Council (BMC) is equivocal, not least because the purists within their ranks think of climbing as a higher form of sport – in the words of Don Whillans ‘there has always been competition in climbing but for the route, not to be better than anyone else’. That’s the big difference between an adventure sport like climbing and track-and-field sports where the main point is to beat somebody else. Nevertheless, the Luke Hughes is a furniture designer and mountaineer who has scaled the North Face of the Eiger, climbed within 200 metres of the summit of Everest and made more than a dozen trips more to the Himalayas to explore much of the unmapped, unexplored areas of central Tibet. His furniture designs have been commissioned by the General Medical Council, the Royal College of Paediatrics and the British Heart Foundation. Correspondence: Old Wardour House, Tisbury, Wilts SP3 6RP, UK (email: l.hughes@lukehughes.co.uk)