Abstract:Many studies have employed spatial, temporal, or a combination of both specifications for analysis of roadway crashes at different spatial levels. However, there is lack of a comprehensive study which compares the crash estimation performance of different spatial weight matrices and their combination with various temporal treatments. The current study fills the research gap by comparing different Full Bayesian (FB) multivariate spatiotemporal crash models. The pedestrian and bicyclist crash data across an eight-year period for 58 counties in California were used as a case study. Three groups of models were developed based on temporal treatment, where each group comprised of 17 models differing on the basis of different adjacency- and distance-based spatial weight matrices. The first group of multivariate models incorporated only unstructured random error term and spatially structured conditional autoregressive (CAR) term. The second group built upon the former and introduced a linear time trend to develop a spatiotemporal model, while the third group allowed the interaction of space and time. The predictive performance of the alternate models across and within groups was assessed by employing several evaluation criteria. The modeling results demonstrated the robustness of models based on the similar signs and closeness of coefficients for the posterior estimates of parameters. For overall model comparison, the pure-distance model D0.5 demonstrated the best performance for different evaluation criteria based on training and test errors across three groups. The variability in performance of other distance models suggested that caution must be exercised for the choice of exponents. The correlation analysis revealed the presence of positive correlations among the criteria based on training errors, as well as with cross-validation. However, a very strong positive correlation was observed between the criteria based on effective number of parameters and posterior deviance, indicating that an increased number of parameters may not lead to improved model fit. This finding reinforced the importance of selecting the optimum weight matrix for spatial correlation as a more complex structure may not lead to expected advantages at model performance. For comparison among three groups of different temporal treatments, the third group demonstrated the best performance and conveyed the benefits of incorporating the spatial and temporal interaction. The results from ANOVA (analysis of variance) and HSD (Honest Significant Differences) tests also established the existence of statistical differences for the superiority of space-time interactions models. However, the box and whisker plots demonstrated high variability among the models of the third group, suggesting that some models may not benefit from interaction term. For comparison among adjacency- and distance-based models, the distance-based models were mostly observed to be superior. However, the greater variability of model performance associated with distance-based models suggested for careful consideration during their selection. Additionally, it is important to note that the results observed in this study are specific to the county-level crash data of California. As such, the study does not recommend generalization of the results for extension to other spatial levels of roadway network, and readers and future research studies are advised to exercise caution before implementing the models.

Crash data modeling with a generalized estimator

On the nature of over-dispersion in motor vehicle crash prediction models

Modeling crash spatial heterogeneity: random parameter versus geographically weighting

CGAN-EB: A Non-parametric Empirical Bayes Method for Crash Hotspot Identification Using Conditional Generative Adversarial Networks: A Simulated Crash Data Study

Injury severity assessment of rear-end crashes via approaches based on generalized estimating equations

Gas Dynamic Analogous Exposure Approach to Interaction Intensity in Multiple-Vehicle Crash Analysis: Case Study of Crashes Involving Taxis

Assessment of Expressway Traffic Safety Using Gaussian Mixture Model Based on Time to Collision

Disaggregated Crash Prediction Models for Different Crash Types Using Joint Probability Model

A negative binomial Lindley approach considering spatiotemporal effects for modeling traffic crash frequency with excess zeros

An Efficient Parallel Sampling Technique for Multivariate Poisson-Lognormal Model: Analysis with Two Crash Count Datasets

Analyzing Factors and Interaction Terms Affecting Urban Fatal Crash Types Based on a Hybrid Framework of Econometric Model and Machine Learning Approaches

Geographically weighted machine learning for modeling spatial heterogeneity in traffic crash frequency and determinants in US

A Study of Factors Affecting Intersection Crash Frequencies Using Random-Parameter Multivariate Zero-Inflated Models

Analytic Methods in Accident Research

Modeling Traffic Accident Counts with a Parameterization of Discrete Choice Distributions

A process convolution model for crash count data on a network

A Roadway Safety Sustainable Approach: Modeling for Real-Time Traffic Crash with Limited Data and Its Reliability Verification

Modeling the service-route-based crash frequency by a spatiotemporal-random-effect zero-inflated negative binomial model: An empirical analysis for bus-involved crashes

An empirical evaluation of multivariate spatial crash frequency models

Modeling of Low Visibility-Related Rural Single-Vehicle Crashes Considering Unobserved Heterogeneity and Spatial Correlation

Crash frequency prediction based on extreme value theory using roadside lidar-based vehicle trajectory data