Abstract:Do people have well-defined social preferences waiting to be applied when making decisions? Or do they have to construct social decisions on the spot? If the latter, how are those decisions influenced by the way in which information is acquired and evaluated? These temporal dynamics are fundamental to understanding how people trade off selfishness and prosociality in organizations and societies. Here, we investigate how the temporal dynamics of the choice process shape social decisions in three studies using response times and mouse tracking. In the first study, participants made binary decisions in mini-dictator games with and without time constraints. Using mouse trajectories and a starting time drift diffusion model, we find that, regardless of time constraints, selfish participants were delayed in processing others’ payoffs, whereas the opposite was true for prosocial participants. The independent mouse trajectory and computational modeling analyses identified consistent measures of the delay between considering one’s own and others’ payoffs (self-onset delay, SOD). This measure correlated with individual differences in prosociality and predicted heterogeneous effects of time constraints on preferences. We confirmed these results in two additional studies, one a purely behavioral study in which participants made decisions by pressing computer keys, and the other a replication of the mouse-tracking study. Together, these results indicate that people preferentially process either self or others’ payoffs early in the choice process. The intrachoice dynamics are crucial in shaping social preferences and might be manipulated via nudge policies (e.g., manipulating the display order or saliency of self and others’ outcomes) for behavior in managerial or other contexts. This paper was accepted by Yan Chen, behavioral economics and decisions analysis. Funding: F. Chen acknowledges support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grants 71803174 and 72173113]. Z. Zhu acknowledges support from the Ministry of Science and Technology [Grant STI 2030-Major Projects 2021ZD0200409]. Q. Shen acknowledges support from the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Grants 71971199 and 71942004]. I. Krajbich acknowledges support from the U.S. National Science Foundation [Grant 2148982]. This work was also supported by the James McKeen Cattell Fund. Supplemental Material: The online appendix and data are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2023.4732 .

Similarity and decision time in preferential choice

Attribute Latencies Causally Shape Intertemporal Decisions

Attribute commensurability and context effects in preferential choice

Parallel processing of value-related information during multi-attribute decisions

The Impact of Predecision Similarity Upon the Postdecision Evaluation of the Chosen and Unchosen Alternatives in an Unobtrusive Experimental Setting

Multiattribute Decision-making in Macaques Relies on Direct Attribute Comparisons

The unified tradeoff model.

The Contrast Effect in Temporal and Probabilistic Discounting

Intrachoice Dynamics Shape Social Decisions

How time flies: Time perception and intertemporal choice

Individual differences in the discounting of combination outcomes in which immediate gains are followed by delayed losses

Subjective Importance of a Common Feature Decides Its Consideration in Multi-attribute Decision-making

The determinants of decision time in an ambiguous context

Tradeoffs and Comparison Complexity

Mutual inclusivity improves decision-making by smoothing out choice’s competitive edge

How Maximizers Estimate Their Decision Time: the Mediating Effect of Memory Reduction

The neural substrates of probabilistic and intertemporal decision making

Magnitude-sensitive reaction times reveal non-linear time costs in multi-alternative decision-making

Temporal context effects on suboptimal choice

Multinomial Logit Processes and Preference Discovery: Inside and Outside the Black Box

Taking Decisions Too Seriously: Why Maximizers Often Get Mired in Choices