Branchial cysts: congenital or acquired?

R. Srinivasan

1992-05-01

Annals of The Royal College of Surgeons of England

Abstract:We read the paper written by R A Greatorex and N M Denny (Annals, November 1991, vol 73, p352) with interest, but feel several points require further comment. The use of the fibreoptic laryngoscope to visualise the vocal cords while simultaneously stimulating the recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) during thyroid surgery has been described previously (1,2). These patients had endotracheal intubation which did not interfere with assessing vocal cord movement. Though we agree with the authors that vocal cord trauma is prevented using the Laryngeal Mask Airway (LMA) this risk has been estimated at only 3% using endotracheal tubes (3). More importantly, identification of the external laryngeal nerve (ELN) in addition to the RLN reduces the incidence of voice change from 25% to 5% (3). Damage to the ELN causes paralysis of the cricothyroid muscle resulting in hoarseness and a reduction in both vocal pitch and range (4). We are unclear as to their advice on the use of LMA during thyroid surgery when the trachea is deviated or narrowed. In their conclusion they assert surgery can be safely undertaken with the LMA in these patients, but contradict this in their next sentence by stating tracheal narrowing or deviation is a relative