Catalyst: the Renaissance of Molecular Electronics
Na Xin,Xuefeng Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chempr.2017.08.006
IF: 23.5
2017-01-01
Chem
Abstract:Na Xin is a PhD candidate of chemistry under the guidance of Prof. Xuefeng Guo at Peking University. She received her BS degree in 2013 from Central South University. Her research is focused on probing optoelectronic properties of single-molecule junctions.Prof. Xuefeng Guo received his PhD from the Chinese Academy of Sciences and then was a postdoctoral scientist at the Columbia University Nanocenter until 2007. He joined Peking University as a professor under the “Peking 100-Talent” Program in 2008. In 2012, he received support from the National Science Fund for Distinguished Young Scholars of China. His current research is focused on functional nanometer and molecular devices. Na Xin is a PhD candidate of chemistry under the guidance of Prof. Xuefeng Guo at Peking University. She received her BS degree in 2013 from Central South University. Her research is focused on probing optoelectronic properties of single-molecule junctions. Prof. Xuefeng Guo received his PhD from the Chinese Academy of Sciences and then was a postdoctoral scientist at the Columbia University Nanocenter until 2007. He joined Peking University as a professor under the “Peking 100-Talent” Program in 2008. In 2012, he received support from the National Science Fund for Distinguished Young Scholars of China. His current research is focused on functional nanometer and molecular devices. At the beginning of 2016, a paper published in Nature acknowledged that the worldwide semiconductor industry would abandon its pursuit of Moore’s law.1Waldrop M.M. Nature. 2016; 530: 144-147Crossref PubMed Scopus (1158) Google Scholar Moore’s law states that the number of transistors in a dense integrated circuit doubles approximately every 2 years—which has generally meant that the chip’s performance will too. This has promoted the rapid development of microelectronics, thus leading the world into the information era. However, the doubling trend has already begun to falter as a result of the heat that is inevitably produced when more and more silicon circuitry is jammed into the same small area. Rather than focusing on Moore’s law, the semiconductor industry has agreed to let the performance of chips and the applications follow. Then, what’s the ultimate limit in the miniaturization of electronics? Molecular electronics again came into the view of scientists to provide an alternative direction for this tremendous challenge. Utilizing one or a few molecules as an electronic component, though logically understandable at present, was revolutionary when Aviram and Ratner first put forward this thought in 1974.2Aviram A. Ratner M.A. Chem. Phys. Lett. 1974; 29: 277-283Crossref Scopus (3317) Google Scholar With theoretical calculations, they designed an organic molecule with the structure of D-σ-A, which could function as a rectifier. At that time, this proposal was something between science fiction and the state of the art, but it aroused great interest among scientists from different backgrounds. The use of organic molecules as the functional center has several advantages, such as low cost and smaller size. In addition to these, the most exclusive advantage is the endless possibility of structures and functionalities offered by chemical synthesis. However, the question of how to anchor a single molecule or a few molecules to two electrodes had confused experimental researchers for many years. Obviously, the popular top-down method, though mature in the fabrication of complementary metal-oxide semiconductors (CMOSs), cannot meet the fabrication of molecular junctions. Thanks to the development of scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and later atomic force microscopy in the 1980s, researchers began to realize that these could be useful tools for investigating the conductance of single molecules. The first significant work occurred in the late 1990s, when Reed, Tour, and colleagues developed a mechanical controller to fracture a notched gold wire into a nanogap, thus realizing a real single-molecule device.3Reed M.A. Zhou C. Muller J. Burgin T.P. Tour J.M. Science. 1997; 278: 252-254Crossref Scopus (3254) Google Scholar Since then, different approaches to fabricating single-molecule devices have sprung up, making it more accessible to probe the conductance characteristics of individual molecules. Charge transport through molecular junctions is quantum mechanical in nature, thus enabling scientists to reveal and understand the function of materials at both the atomic and molecular levels. In addition to realizing various functionalities, molecular electronics could lead to the direct observation of novel effects or the fundamental discovery of physical phenomena that cannot be accessible in bulky materials. Up until now, many experiments have been carried out to explore charge-transport mechanisms through molecular junctions, resulting in considerable research advances in both functionalities and quantum phenomena. In the past decade, groundbreaking research in building specific functionalities of molecular devices has emerged. Rectification, thermoelectricity, switching, negative differential conductance, spintronics, and the gating effect have all been realized in molecular junctions. However, in these previous reports, few molecular electronic devices can rival silicon-based electronics in performance—there are indeed some big steps. In 2014, Schull’s group at the University of Strasbourg in France made the first single-molecule light-emitting diode, which has the same electroluminescent mechanism as that in conventional organic light-emitting diodes, by using a conducting polymer polythiophene spanning between two metallic electrodes.4Reecht G. Scheurer F. Speisser V. Dappe Y.J. Mathevet F. Schull G. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2014; 112: 047403Crossref PubMed Scopus (126) Google Scholar In 2015, Venkataraman’s group at Columbia University realized single-molecule diodes with a rectification ratio of more than 200—an important step for maintaining a high signal gain as the devices shrink (see review by Xiang et al.5Xiang D. Wang X. Jia C. Lee T. Guo X. Chem. Rev. 2016; 116: 4318-4440Crossref PubMed Scopus (836) Google Scholar). In 2016, our group demonstrated a fully reversible two-mode, single-molecule electrical switch consisting of a single diarylethene molecule sandwiched between nanogapped graphene electrodes; this switch showed unprecedented levels of accuracy, stability, and reproducibility.6Jia C. Migliore A. Xin N. Huang S. Wang J. Yang Q. Wang S. Chen H. Wang D. Feng B. et al.Science. 2016; 352: 1443-1445Crossref PubMed Scopus (526) Google Scholar In addition to these, some breakthroughs in spin control at the atomic and molecular levels have been reported. In 2014, Wernsdorfer’s group at the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique in France realized coherent manipulation of single nuclear spin by using only an electric field because of the hyperfine Stark effect.7Thiele S. Balestro F. Ballou R. Klyatskaya S. Ruben M. Wernsdorfer W. Science. 2014; 344: 1135-1138Crossref PubMed Scopus (570) Google Scholar Earlier that year, IBM Research–Almaden produced the world’s smallest magnet and demonstrated that it is possible to use that magnet—an individual holmimum atom—to store a single bit of data.8Natterer F.D. Yang K. Paul W. Willke P. Choi T. Greber T. Heinrich A.J. Lutz C.P. Nature. 2017; 543: 226-228Crossref PubMed Scopus (263) Google Scholar In addition to utilizing organic molecules, Xu’s group at the University of Georgia constructed a molecular rectifier by using designed DNA strands.9Guo C. Wang K. Zerah-Harush E. Hamill J. Wang B. Dubi Y. Xu B. Nat. Chem. 2016; 8: 484-490Crossref PubMed Scopus (135) Google Scholar Several quantum phenomena—such as Coulomb blockade, the Kondo effect, quantum interference, and image-charge effect—have been observed in molecular junctions as well as in semiconductors. Importantly, these fundamental research efforts provide inspiration for the study of intrinsic and novel mechanisms that are unavailable in traditional ensemble methods. For example, the groups of Hou and Dong at the University of Science and Technology of China have done a series of excellent work in studying the optical process and photochemistry of a single molecule by the subtly controlled local nanocavity plasmons.10Zhang Y. Luo Y. Zhang Y. Yu Y.J. Kuang Y.M. Zhang L. Meng Q.S. Luo Y. Yang J.L. Dong Z.C. Hou J.G. Nature. 2016; 531: 623-627Crossref PubMed Scopus (231) Google Scholar They found that the “forbidden light” from porphyrin molecules, which obeys Kasha’s rule, provided new insight into the basic understanding of the emitting mechanism in molecules. Nuckolls’s group at Columbia University observed two different conductance states in oligosilane molecular junctions, which they attributed to the stereoelectronic effect of the sulfur-methylene σ bond (see review by Xiang et al.5Xiang D. Wang X. Jia C. Lee T. Guo X. Chem. Rev. 2016; 116: 4318-4440Crossref PubMed Scopus (836) Google Scholar). In addition, Coote’s group at Australian National University demonstrated the first experimental evidence of a nonredox, bond-forming process in Diels-Alder reactions accelerated by an oriented external electric field within STM-based molecular junctions.11Aragonès A.C. Haworth N.L. Darwish N. Ciampi S. Bloomfield N.J. Wallace G.G. Diez-Perez I. Coote M.L. Nature. 2016; 531: 88-91Crossref PubMed Scopus (449) Google Scholar Our group first demonstrated the capability of molecular electronic devices in carrying out direct, real-time single-molecule detection in solution containing the certain substance and revealed the detailed dynamic information in host-guest interactions at the single-molecule level.12Wen H. Li W. Chen J. He G. Li L. Olson M.A. Sue A.C.-H. Stoddart J.F. Guo X. Sci. Adv. 2016; 2: e1601113Crossref PubMed Scopus (66) Google Scholar Tao’s group at Arizona State University investigated different sequence-dependent charge-transport mechanisms existing in a DNA helix (see review by Xiang et al.5Xiang D. Wang X. Jia C. Lee T. Guo X. Chem. Rev. 2016; 116: 4318-4440Crossref PubMed Scopus (836) Google Scholar). Correspondingly, theories explaining current-voltage characteristics in molecular junctions have been recently developed. Though many concepts were at first borrowed from semiconductor electronics, qualitative descriptions of electron transport through a single molecule have been established by the adaptation of non-equilibrium Green function techniques and are consistent with experimental data. In spite of these exciting advances, we have to admit that some tremendous challenges still need to be overcome for the vision of practical molecular electronic devices. The most critical challenge in the field of single-molecule electronics is the variability among devices featuring the same structure of single molecules. When the device size decreases to the atomic and molecular levels, every atomic detail is able to affect device performance. At present, neither metal electrodes nor carbon-based point contacts can realize the control with atomic precision at the edges of the electrodes, thus leading to variable contact configurations at the molecule-electrode interface. For metal electrodes, because of the mobile metal atom, the bonding sites for the anchoring group in the molecule are different from device to device. What’s more, the sizes of the molecule and metal electrodes are not compatible, leading to a situation in which one molecule bridges two electrodes and many other molecules are absorbed into the surface of metal electrodes. This complexation significantly interferes with the conductance behavior of the bridging molecule. Accordingly, statistical conductance data obtained from STM-based junctions and mechanically controlled break junctions have revealed the fluctuations to some extent. This might be fatal, especially to the functionalization of single-molecule devices. For carbon-based electrodes, although the edge of a single-walled carbon nanotube (SWNT) or graphene nanogap is atomic and fixed, both different configurations at the edges and inhomogeneous electronic properties of SWNTs can lead to different molecular behaviors. Stability is the basic requirement of the devices for real-life applications. In molecular electronic devices, we cannot ignore the fact that metal-electrode-based molecular junctions have poor stability. To realize resonant transport, it is usually necessary to apply several volts to only a few nanometer-length junctions to lead to non-equilibrium dynamics and strong interactions between molecular orbitals and the electric field gradient across the junction. Gold (Au), the popular material used for electrodes in molecular junctions, is highly mobile, and as a result, atoms at the Au electrode surface tend to diffuse because of the heating effect resulting from the electric field or elevated temperatures. In addition, lone-pair species (Au-S bonds) are typically used to bridge the molecule and the metal electrode. As well known in chemistry, these coordination bonds are easily raptured or oxidized. Another fundamental challenge of molecular devices is the integration capability, which is critically important for realizing a computing system. Up until now, almost reported measurements were carried out in ideal media at the laboratory level. However, the actual devices are far more complex and definitely introduce a range of interfering and running effects. For an efficient integration, two main critical factors should be taken into consideration. (1) Although the core part of molecular devices is intrinsically tiny, there are always long leads and large pads for outer connections, which prevent a full exploitation of its potential. (2) Instead of replacing the present CMOS technology, molecular devices could serve as complement parts in CMOS circuits in the near future. Therefore, molecular devices need to be CMOS compatible. In this aspect, carbon-based molecular junctions have the advantage and might be a good candidate for integration. Still motivated by technological goals, molecular electronics continues to focus on the construction, characterization, understanding, and functionalization of molecular electronic devices. To this end, gate control of the conductance behaviors in molecular devices deserves hard work, and the inspiration of organic spintronics opens another window for the development of a new, less power-consuming field of molecular spintronics. This needs effective collaboration of researchers from interdisciplinary backgrounds: materials chemists, experimental physicists, computational theorists, and engineers. Installing functionalities in molecular junctions mainly depends on molecular engineering.5Xiang D. Wang X. Jia C. Lee T. Guo X. Chem. Rev. 2016; 116: 4318-4440Crossref PubMed Scopus (836) Google Scholar Two main factors should be taken into consideration. One is the intrinsic function of the molecular material itself. The other is the molecule-electrode interfacial coupling, which is related to the spectral density between the functional center of the molecule and the electrode. Within strong coupling, the molecular conductance is the best, but some functionalities could be quenched or screened by the electrodes.13Jia C. Guo X. Chem. Soc. Rev. 2013; 42: 5642-5660Crossref PubMed Scopus (197) Google Scholar The control of the molecule-electrode interfacial coupling is still one of the most challenging issues in molecular electronics. This can realized via the design of different anchoring groups and/or incorporation of suitable spacers (usually methylene groups) between the functional center and the anchoring group in the molecular structure (Figure 1). Therefore, achieving the intrinsic properties of single molecules requires a compromise between the conductance and the functionality. If molecular electronics are to move from the laboratory level toward real applications, it is critical to consider candidate materials for electrodes. Among different nanomaterials, carbon isotopes (such as SWNTs and graphene) seem more suitable as electrode materials for the construction of molecular devices.14Lörtscher E. Nat. Nanotechnol. 2013; 8: 381-384Crossref PubMed Scopus (135) Google Scholar This is because SWNTs and graphene are low-dimensional carbon nanomaterials entirely composed of immovable sp2-hybridized carbon monolayers with rich carbon chemistry that allows the covalent formation of robust connections between molecules and electrodes. In addition, they have good size alignment and are naturally compatible with organic and biological molecules. However, none of the current techniques are able to create the nanoscale gap with atomic-level control. The precise formation of single-molecule electronics at the atomic level is key to promoting the rapid development of molecular devices toward practical applications (Figure 1). Another unique feature of single-molecule devices is the fact that they contain only one or two molecules as conductive elements, thus distinguishing them as reliable platforms capable of translating the dynamic processes of either chemical reactions or biological functions into detectable electrical signals at the single-event level (Figure 1). This might open a mainstream approach to single-molecule electrical detection for the study of single-molecule and single-event dynamics in an interdisciplinary realm. In comparison with conventional optical techniques, this nanocircuit-based architecture is complementary but obviously has advantages, such as avoiding problems with bleaching and fluorescent labeling. These advantages offer endless opportunities for scientists to elucidate the fundamental mechanisms underlying reactions and uncover important details of the most basic processes of life, which will immediately invite intense research activities. This work was supported by the Ministry of Science and Technology of China (grant 2017YFA0204901) and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (grants 21373014 and 21727806). Reaction: Technological Aspects of Molecular ElectronicsEmanuel LörtscherChemSeptember 14, 2017In BriefDr. Emanuel Lörtscher received his PhD with distinction (summa cum laude) in 2006 from the University of Basel in Switzerland and a master in physics in 2003 from the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology. He has been a research staff member at IBM Research since 2008. He has received various prizes, including the Swiss Physical Society Award for Applied Physics in 2007 and the Faculty Prize of the University of Basel in the same year. His current research focuses on fabrication, electronics, optics, and chemistry at the nanoscale for applications in novel computing applications, biology, medicine, and the Internet of Things. Full-Text PDF Open ArchiveReaction: New Insights into Molecular ElectronicsHsu et al.ChemSeptember 14, 2017In BriefLiang-Yan Hsu is an assistant research fellow at the Institute of Atomic and Molecular Science. He earned his PhD from Princeton University (2015) and was a postdoctoral fellow at Northwestern University (2017). His research focuses on theoretical chemical physics, nanoelectronics, quantum-transport methodology, and nanoscale light-matter interactions. Bih-Yaw Jin is a chemistry professor at National Taiwan University (NTU). His research interests include the electronic structure of conjugated organic materials, quantum molecular processes in condensed matter and molecular devices, and self-trapping phenomena in quantum systems. Chun-hsien Chen is a Distinguished Professor at NTU. His research interests involve electrochemistry, solid-liquid interfacial phenomena, and scanning-probe-microscopy-based I-V characterization of single molecules. Shie-Ming Peng is a chair professor at NTU, academician, and fellow of the World Academy of Sciences, Royal Society of Chemistry, Russian Academy of Engineering, and Japan Society for the Promotion of Science. He is a synthetic and structural coordination chemist with interests in metal-string complexes. Full-Text PDF Open Archive