Observation of New Charmonium or Charmoniumlike States in Decays

R. Aaij,A. S. W. Abdelmotteleb,C. Abellan Beteta,F. Abudinén,T. Ackernley,A. A. Adefisoye,B. Adeva,M. Adinolfi,P. Adlarson,C. Agapopoulou,C. A. Aidala,Z. Ajaltouni,S. Akar,K. Akiba,P. Albicocco,J. Albrecht,F. Alessio,M. Alexander,Z. Aliouche,P. Alvarez Cartelle,R. Amalric,S. Amato,J. L. Amey,Y. Amhis,L. An,L. Anderlini,M. Andersson,A. Andreianov,P. Andreola,M. Andreotti,D. Andreou,A. Anelli,D. Ao,F. Archilli,M. Argenton,S. Arguedas Cuendis,A. Artamonov,M. Artuso,E. Aslanides,M. Atzeni,B. Audurier,D. Bacher,I. Bachiller Perea,S. Bachmann,M. Bachmayer,J. J. Back,P. Baladron Rodriguez,V. Balagura,W. Baldini,J. Baptista de Souza Leite,M. Barbetti,I. R. Barbosa,R. J. Barlow,S. Barsuk,W. Barter,M. Bartolini,J. Bartz,F. Baryshnikov,J. M. Basels,G. Bassi,B. Batsukh,A. Battig,A. Bay,A. Beck,M. Becker,F. Bedeschi,I. B. Bediaga,A. Beiter,S. Belin,V. Bellee,K. Belous,I. Belov,I. Belyaev,G. Benane,G. Bencivenni,E. Ben-Haim,A. Berezhnoy,R. Bernet,S. Bernet Andres,C. Bertella,A. Bertolin,C. Betancourt,F. Betti,J. Bex,Ia. Bezshyiko,J. Bhom,M. S. Bieker,N. V. Biesuz,P. Billoir,A. Biolchini,M. Birch,F. C. R. Bishop,A. Bitadze,A. Bizzeti,T. Blake,F. Blanc,J. E. Blank,S. Blusk,V. Bocharnikov,J. A. Boelhauve,O. Boente Garcia,T. Boettcher,A. Bohare,A. Boldyrev,C. S. Bolognani,R. Bolzonella,N. Bondar,F. Borgato,S. Borghi,M. Borsato,J. T. Borsuk,S. A. Bouchiba,T. J. V. Bowcock,A. Boyer,C. Bozzi,M. J. Bradley,A. Brea Rodriguez,N. Breer,J. Brodzicka,A. Brossa Gonzalo,J. Brown,D. Brundu,E. Buchanan,A. Buonaura,L. Buonincontri,A. T. Burke,C. Burr,A. Bursche,A. Butkevich,J. S. Butter,J. Buytaert,W. Byczynski,S. Cadeddu,H. Cai,R. Calabrese,L. Calefice,S. Cali,M. Calvi,M. Calvo Gomez,J. I. Cambon Bouzas,P. Campana,D. H. Campora Perez,A. F. Campoverde Quezada,S. Capelli,L. Capriotti,R. Caravaca-Mora,A. Carbone,L. Carcedo Salgado,R. Cardinale,A. Cardini,P. Carniti,L. Carus,A. Casais Vidal,R. Caspary,G. Casse,J. Castro Godinez,M. Cattaneo,G. Cavallero,V. Cavallini,S. Celani,J. Cerasoli,D. Cervenkov,S. Cesare,A. J. Chadwick,I. Chahrour,M. Charles,Ph. Charpentier,C. A. Chavez Barajas,M. Chefdeville,C. Chen,S. Chen,Z. Chen,A. Chernov,S. Chernyshenko,V. Chobanova,S. Cholak,M. Chrzaszcz,A. Chubykin,V. Chulikov,P. Ciambrone,X. Cid Vidal,G. Ciezarek,P. Cifra,P. E. L. Clarke,M. Clemencic,H. V. Cliff,J. Closier,C. Cocha Toapaxi,V. Coco,J. Cogan,E. Cogneras,L. Cojocariu,P. Collins,T. Colombo,A. Comerma-Montells,L. Congedo,A. Contu,N. Cooke,I. Corredoira,A. Correia,G. Corti,J. J. Cottee Meldrum,B. Couturier,D. C. Craik,M. Cruz Torres,E. Curras Rivera,R. Currie,C. L. Da Silva,S. Dadabaev,L. Dai,X. Dai,E. Dall’Occo,J. Dalseno,C. D’Ambrosio,J. Daniel,A. Danilina,P. d’Argent,A. Davidson,J. E. Davies,A. Davis,O. De Aguiar Francisco,C. De Angelis,F. De Benedetti,J. de Boer,K. De Bruyn,S. De Capua,M. De Cian,U. De Freitas Carneiro Da Graca,E. De Lucia,J. M. De Miranda,L. De Paula,M. De Serio,P. De Simone,F. De Vellis,J. A. de Vries,F. Debernardis,D. Decamp,V. Dedu,L. Del Buono,B. Delaney,H.-P. Dembinski,J. Deng,V. Denysenko,O. Deschamps,F. Dettori,B. Dey,P. Di Nezza,I. Diachkov,S. Didenko,S. Ding,L. Dittmann,V. Dobishuk,A. D. Docheva,A. Dolmatov,C. Dong,A. M. Donohoe,F. Dordei,A. C. dos Reis,A. D. Dowling,A. G. Downes,W. Duan,P. Duda,M. W. Dudek,L. Dufour,V. Duk,P. Durante,M. M. Duras,J. M. Durham,O. D. Durmus,A. Dziurda,A. Dzyuba,S. Easo,E. Eckstein,U. Egede,A. Egorychev,V. Egorychev,S. Eisenhardt,E. Ejopu,S. Ek-In,L. Eklund,M. Elashri,J. Ellbracht,S. Ely,A. Ene,E. Epple,S. Escher,J. Eschle,S. Esen,T. Evans,F. Fabiano,L. N. Falcao,Y. Fan,B. Fang,L. Fantini,M. Faria,K. Farmer,D. Fazzini,L. Felkowski,M. Feng,M. Feo,M. Fernandez Gomez,A. D. Fernez,F. Ferrari,F. Ferreira Rodrigues,S. Ferreres Sole,M. Ferrillo,M. Ferro-Luzzi,S. Filippov,R. A. Fini,M. Fiorini,K. M. Fischer,D. S. Fitzgerald,C. Fitzpatrick,F. Fleuret,M. Fontana,L. F. Foreman,R. Forty,D. Foulds-Holt,M. Franco Sevilla,M. Frank,E. Franzoso,G. Frau,C. Frei,D. A. Friday,J. Fu,Q. Fuehring,Y. Fujii,T. Fulghesu,E. Gabriel,G. Galati,M. D. Galati,A. Gallas Torreira,D. Galli,S. Gambetta,M. Gandelman,P. Gandini,H. Gao,R. Gao,Y. Gao,Y. Gao,Y. Gao,M. Garau,L. M. Garcia Martin,P. Garcia Moreno,J. García Pardiñas,K. G. Garg,L. Garrido,C. Gaspar,R. E. Geertsema,L. L. Gerken,E. Gersabeck,M. Gersabeck,T. Gershon,Z. Ghorbanimoghaddam,L. Giambastiani,F. I. Giasemis,V. Gibson,H. K. Giemza,A. L. Gilman,M. Giovannetti,A. Gioventù,P. Gironella Gironell,C. Giugliano,M. A. Giza,E. L. Gkougkousis,F. C. Glaser,V. V. Gligorov,C. Göbel,E. Golobardes,D. Golubkov,A. Golutvin,A. Gomes,S. Gomez Fernandez,F. Goncalves Abrantes,M. Goncerz,G. Gong,J. A. Gooding,I. V. Gorelov,C. Gotti,J. P. Grabowski,L. A. Granado Cardoso,E. Graugés,E. Graverini,L. Grazette,G. Graziani,A. T. Grecu,L. M. Greeven,N. A. Grieser,L. Grillo,S. Gromov,C. Gu,M. Guarise,M. Guittiere,V. Guliaeva,P. A. Günther,A.-K. Guseinov,E. Gushchin,Y. Guz,T. Gys,K. Habermann,T. Hadavizadeh,C. Hadjivasiliou,G. Haefeli,C. Haen,J. Haimberger,M. Hajheidari,M. M. Halvorsen,P. M. Hamilton,J. Hammerich,Q. Han,X. Han,S. Hansmann-Menzemer,L. Hao,N. Harnew,T. Harrison,M. Hartmann,J. He,F. Hemmer,C. Henderson,R. D. L. Henderson,A. M. Hennequin,K. Hennessy,L. Henry,J. Herd,P. Herrero Gascon,J. Heuel,A. Hicheur,G. Hijano Mendizabal,D. Hill,S. E. Hollitt,J. Horswill,R. Hou,Y. Hou,N. Howarth,J. Hu,J. Hu,W. Hu,X. Hu,W. Huang,W. Hulsbergen,R. J. Hunter,M. Hushchyn,D. Hutchcroft,D. Ilin,P. Ilten,A. Inglessi,A. Iniukhin,A. Ishteev,K. Ivshin,R. Jacobsson,H. Jage,S. J. Jaimes Elles,S. Jakobsen,E. Jans,B. K. Jashal,A. Jawahery,V. Jevtic,E. Jiang,X. Jiang,Y. Jiang,Y. J. Jiang,M. John,D. Johnson,C. R. Jones,T. P. Jones,S. Joshi,B. Jost,N. Jurik,I. Juszczak,D. Kaminaris,S. Kandybei,Y. Kang,M. Karacson,D. Karpenkov,A. Kauniskangas,J. W. Kautz,F. Keizer,M. Kenzie,T. Ketel,B. Khanji,A. Kharisova,S. Kholodenko,G. Khreich,T. Kirn,V. S. Kirsebom,O. Kitouni,S. Klaver,N. Kleijne,K. Klimaszewski,M. R. Kmiec,S. Koliiev,L. Kolk,A. Konoplyannikov,P. Kopciewicz,P. Koppenburg,M. Korolev,I. Kostiuk,O. Kot,S. Kotriakhova,A. Kozachuk,P. Kravchenko,L. Kravchuk,M. Kreps,S. Kretzschmar,P. Krokovny,W. Krupa,W. Krzemien,J. Kubat,S. Kubis,W. Kucewicz,M. Kucharczyk,V. Kudryavtsev,E. Kulikova,A. Kupsc,B. K. Kutsenko,D. Lacarrere,A. Lai,A. Lampis,D. Lancierini,C. Landesa Gomez,J. J. Lane,R. Lane,C. Langenbruch,J. Langer,O. Lantwin,T. Latham,F. Lazzari,C. Lazzeroni,R. Le Gac,R. Lefèvre,A. Leflat,S. Legotin,M. Lehuraux,E. Lemos Cid,O. Leroy,T. Lesiak,B. Leverington,A. Li,H. Li,K. Li,L. Li,P. Li,P.-R. Li,S. Li,T. Li,T. Li,Y. Li,Y. Li,Z. Li,Z. Lian,X. Liang,S. Libralon,C. Lin,T. Lin,R. Lindner,V. Lisovskyi,R. Litvinov,F. L. Liu,G. Liu,K. Liu,Q. Liu,S. Liu,Y. Liu,Y. Liu,Y. L. Liu,A. Lobo Salvia,A. Loi,J. Lomba Castro,T. Long,J. H. Lopes,A. Lopez Huertas,S. López Soliño,C. Lucarelli,D. Lucchesi,M. Lucio Martinez,V. Lukashenko,Y. Luo,A. Lupato,E. Luppi,K. Lynch,X.-R. Lyu,G. M. Ma,R. Ma,S. Maccolini,F. Machefert,F. Maciuc,B. Mack,I. Mackay,L. M. Mackey,L. R. Madhan Mohan,M. J. Madurai,A. Maevskiy,D. Magdalinski,D. Maisuzenko,M. W. Majewski,J. J. Malczewski,S. Malde,B. Malecki,L. Malentacca,A. Malinin,T. Maltsev,G. Manca,G. Mancinelli,C. Mancuso,R. Manera Escalero,D. Manuzzi,D. Marangotto,J. F. Marchand,R. Marchevski,U. Marconi,S. Mariani,C. Marin Benito,J. Marks,A. M. Marshall,P. J. Marshall,G. Martelli,G. Martellotti,L. Martinazzoli,M. Martinelli,D. Martinez Santos,F. Martinez Vidal,A. Massafferri,M. Materok,R. Matev,A. Mathad,V. Matiunin,C. Matteuzzi,K. R. Mattioli,A. Mauri,E. Maurice,J. Mauricio,P. Mayencourt,M. Mazurek,M. McCann,L. Mcconnell,T. H. McGrath,N. T. McHugh,A. McNab,R. McNulty,B. Meadows,G. Meier,D. Melnychuk,M. Merk,A. Merli,L. Meyer Garcia,D. Miao,H. Miao,M. Mikhasenko,D. A. Milanes,A. Minotti,E. Minucci,T. Miralles,B. Mitreska,D. S. Mitzel,A. Modak,A. Mödden,R. A. Mohammed,R. D. Moise,S. Mokhnenko,T. Mombächer,M. Monk,S. Monteil,A. Morcillo Gomez,G. Morello,M. J. Morello,M. P. Morgenthaler,A. B. Morris,A. G. Morris,R. Mountain,H. Mu,Z. M. Mu,E. Muhammad,F. Muheim,M. Mulder,K. Müller,F. Muñoz-Rojas,R. Murta,P. Naik,T. Nakada,R. Nandakumar,T. Nanut,I. Nasteva,M. Needham,N. Neri,S. Neubert,N. Neufeld,P. Neustroev,J. Nicolini,D. Nicotra,E. M. Niel,N. Nikitin,P. Nogga,N. S. Nolte,C. Normand,J. Novoa Fernandez,G. Nowak,C. Nunez,H. N. Nur,A. Oblakowska-Mucha,V. Obraztsov,T. Oeser,S. Okamura,A. Okhotnikov,R. Oldeman,F. Oliva,M. Olocco,C. J. G. Onderwater,R. H. O’Neil,J. M. Otalora Goicochea,P. Owen,A. Oyanguren,O. Ozcelik,K. O. Padeken,B. Pagare,P. R. Pais,T. Pajero,A. Palano,M. Palutan,G. Panshin,L. Paolucci,A. Papanestis,M. Pappagallo,L. L. Pappalardo,C. Pappenheimer,C. Parkes,B. Passalacqua,G. Passaleva,D. Passaro,A. Pastore,M. Patel,J. Patoc,C. Patrignani,C. J. Pawley,A. Pellegrino,M. Pepe Altarelli,S. Perazzini,D. Pereima,A. Pereiro Castro,P. Perret,A. Perro,K. Petridis,A. Petrolini,S. Petrucci,J. P. Pfaller,H. Pham,L. Pica,M. Piccini,B. Pietrzyk,G. Pietrzyk,D. Pinci,F. Pisani,M. Pizzichemi,V. Placinta,M. Plo Casasus,F. Polci,M. Poli Lener,A. Poluektov,N. Polukhina,E. Polycarpo,S. Ponce,D. Popov,S. Poslavskii,K. Prasanth,C. Prouve,V. Pugatch,G. Punzi,W. Qian,N. Qin,S. Qu,R. Quagliani,R. I. Rabadan Trejo,J. H. Rademacker,M. Rama,M. Ramírez García,M. Ramos Pernas,M. S. Rangel,F. Ratnikov,G. Raven,M. Rebollo De Miguel,F. Redi,J. Reich,F. Reiss,Z. Ren,P. K. Resmi,R. Ribatti,G. R. Ricart,D. Riccardi,S. Ricciardi,K. Richardson,M. Richardson-Slipper,K. Rinnert,P. Robbe,G. Robertson,E. Rodrigues,E. Rodriguez Fernandez,J. A. Rodriguez Lopez,E. Rodriguez Rodriguez,A. Rogovskiy,D. L. Rolf,P. Roloff,V. Romanovskiy,M. Romero Lamas,A. Romero Vidal,G. Romolini,F. Ronchetti,M. Rotondo,S. R. Roy,M. S. Rudolph,T. Ruf,M. Ruiz Diaz,R. A. Ruiz Fernandez,J. Ruiz Vidal,A. Ryzhikov,J. Ryzka,J. J. Saavedra-Arias,J. J. Saborido Silva,R. Sadek,N. Sagidova,D. Sahoo,N. Sahoo,B. Saitta,M. Salomoni,C. Sanchez Gras,I. Sanderswood,R. Santacesaria,C. Santamarina Rios,M. Santimaria,L. Santoro,E. Santovetti,A. Saputi,D. Saranin,G. Sarpis,M. Sarpis,A. Sarti,C. Satriano,A. Satta,M. Saur,D. Savrina,H. Sazak,L. G. Scantlebury Smead,A. Scarabotto,S. Schael,S. Scherl,M. Schiller,H. Schindler,M. Schmelling,B. Schmidt,S. Schmitt,H. Schmitz,O. Schneider,A. Schopper,N. Schulte,S. Schulte,M. H. Schune,R. Schwemmer,G. Schwering,B. Sciascia,A. Sciuccati,S. Sellam,A. Semennikov,T. Senger,M. Senghi Soares,A. Sergi,N. Serra,L. Sestini,A. Seuthe,Y. Shang,D. M. Shangase,M. Shapkin,R. S. Sharma,I. Shchemerov,L. Shchutska,T. Shears,L. Shekhtman,Z. Shen,S. Sheng,V. Shevchenko,B. Shi,Q. Shi,E. B. Shields,Y. Shimizu,E. Shmanin,R. Shorkin,J. D. Shupperd,R. Silva Coutinho,G. Simi,S. Simone,N. Skidmore,T. Skwarnicki,M. W. Slater,J. C. Smallwood,E. Smith,K. Smith,M. Smith,A. Snoch,L. Soares Lavra,M. D. Sokoloff,F. J. P. Soler,A. Solomin,A. Solovev,I. Solovyev,R. Song,Y. Song,Y. Song,Y. S. Song,F. L. Souza De Almeida,B. Souza De Paula,E. Spadaro Norella,E. Spedicato,J. G. Speer,E. Spiridenkov,P. Spradlin,V. Sriskaran,F. Stagni,M. Stahl,S. Stahl,S. Stanislaus,E. N. Stein,O. Steinkamp,O. Stenyakin,H. Stevens,D. Strekalina,Y. Su,F. Suljik,J. Sun,L. Sun,Y. Sun,W. Sutcliffe,P. N. Swallow,F. Swystun,A. Szabelski,T. Szumlak,Y. Tan,M. D. Tat,A. Terentev,F. Terzuoli,F. Teubert,E. Thomas,D. J. D. Thompson,H. Tilquin,V. Tisserand,S. T’Jampens,M. Tobin,L. Tomassetti,G. Tonani,X. Tong,D. Torres Machado,L. Toscano,D. Y. Tou,C. Trippl,G. Tuci,N. Tuning,L. H. Uecker,A. Ukleja,D. J. Unverzagt,E. Ursov,A. Usachov,A. Ustyuzhanin,U. Uwer,V. Vagnoni,A. Valassi,G. Valenti,N. Valls Canudas,H. Van Hecke,E. van Herwijnen,C. B. Van Hulse,R. Van Laak,M. van Veghel,G. Vasquez,R. Vazquez Gomez,P. Vazquez Regueiro,C. Vázquez Sierra,S. Vecchi,J. J. Velthuis,M. Veltri,A. Venkateswaran,M. Vesterinen,M. Vieites Diaz,X. Vilasis-Cardona,E. Vilella Figueras,A. Villa,P. Vincent,F. C. Volle,D. vom Bruch,V. Vorobyev,N. Voropaev,K. Vos,G. Vouters,C. Vrahas,J. Wagner,J. Walsh,E. J. Walton,G. Wan,C. Wang,G. Wang,J. Wang,J. Wang,J. Wang,J. Wang,M. Wang,N. W. Wang,R. Wang,X. Wang,X. W. Wang,Y. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. Wang,Z. Wang,J. A. Ward,M. Waterlaat,N. K. Watson,D. Websdale,Y. Wei,B. D. C. Westhenry,D. J. White,M. Whitehead,A. R. Wiederhold,D. Wiedner,G. Wilkinson,M. K. Wilkinson,M. Williams,M. R. J. Williams,R. Williams,F. F. Wilson,W. Wislicki,M. Witek,L. Witola,C. P. Wong,G. Wormser,S. A. Wotton,H. Wu,J. Wu,Y. Wu,K. Wyllie,S. Xian,Z. Xiang,Y. Xie,A. Xu,J. Xu,L. Xu,L. Xu,M. Xu,Z. Xu,Z. Xu,Z. Xu,D. Yang,S. Yang,X. Yang,Y. Yang,Z. Yang,Z. Yang,V. Yeroshenko,H. Yeung,H. Yin,C. Y. Yu,J. Yu,X. Yuan,E. Zaffaroni,M. Zavertyaev,M. Zdybal,M. Zeng,C. Zhang,D. Zhang,J. Zhang,L. Zhang,S. Zhang,S. Zhang,Y. Zhang,Y. Z. Zhang,Y. Zhao,A. Zharkova,A. Zhelezov,X. Z. Zheng,Y. Zheng,T. Zhou,X. Zhou,Y. Zhou,V. Zhovkovska,L. Z. Zhu,X. Zhu,X. Zhu,V. Zhukov,J. Zhuo,Q. Zou,D. Zuliani,G. Zunica,LHCb Collaboration
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physrevlett.133.131902
IF: 8.6
2024-09-28
Physical Review Letters
Abstract:A study of resonant structures in B+→D*+D−K+ and B+→D*−D+K+ decays is performed, using proton-proton collision data at center-of-mass energies of s=7 , 8, and 13 TeV recorded by the LHCb experiment, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9 fb−1 . A simultaneous amplitude fit is performed to the two channels with contributions from resonances decaying to D*−D+ and D*+D− states linked by C parity. This procedure allows the C parities of resonances in the D*±D∓ mass spectra to be determined. Four charmonium or charmoniumlike states are observed decaying into D*±D∓ : ηc(3945) , hc(4000) , χc1(4010) , and hc(4300) , with quantum numbers JPC equal to 0−+ , 1+− , 1++ , and 1+− , respectively. At least three of these states have not been observed previously. In addition, the existence of the Tc ̄s ̄0*(2870)0 and Tc ̄s ̄1*(2900)0 resonances in the D−K+ mass spectrum, already observed in the B+→D+D−K+ decay, is confirmed in a different production channel. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.133.131902 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Funded by SCOAP 3 . © 2024 CERN, for the LHCb Collaboration
physics, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?