Abstract:Art therapists recognise the importance of clients' early attachment experience. The Bird's Nest Drawing (BND) is an attachment security measure with potential for research and practice, developed by American art therapists. The client draws a bird's nest and writes a corresponding narrative, the latter assisting an integrative evaluation. A systematic rating procedure currently only exists for the drawings. The present study was conducted to determine the psychometric properties of the BND after adding new ratings of the BND story using data from an earlier study with university students. The current investigators established a systematic method for coding BND stories (N = 136). Content analysis yielded five ratings, which were examined in conjunction with the corresponding drawings and existing drawing ratings, and two self-report attachment questionnaires. Four of the 11 drawing rating items and the overall attachment rating had acceptable psychometric properties, as did two of the new story ratings. However, the seven items did not inter-correlate consistently, nor yield improved internal reliability. Construct validity using the established attachment scales was not established convincingly. Results suggest a need for further development of the BND taking greater account of psychometric principles of scale development, with implications for art therapy research and practice.Plain-language summaryThe relationship people have with others can be greatly affected by the childhood experiences they have with those caring for them and can cause what art therapists call 'attachment difficulties'. The Bird's Nest Drawing, first developed in America, provides a way for therapists (and researchers) to understand people's attachment difficulties. Drawings can express what is difficult to say in words. The person draws a bird's nest and writes a short story about it. Inclusion of the story is intended to provide richer information about the client and his or her drawing.It is important that the drawing and accompanying story provide an accurate view of people's attachment experiences. This is more likely if they use a tested set of instructions to rate elements in the drawing, such as how the nest is positioned on the tree. Instructions for rating drawings already exist, however no instructions existed for rating the stories people tell. In this study, we used 136 drawings and stories from a previous study with American university students, and also participants' scores (from the same study) on well-established questionnaires about attachment relationships. We devised a rating system for the stories. Then we checked how reliable and accurate the ratings were for both the drawings and the stories. Part of this checking involved comparing the ratings with the questionnaire scores.We found that neither the existing drawing ratings nor the new story ratings were sufficient when judged by established principles for good design of assessment measures. For example, the ratings did not sufficiently fit the pattern of scores on the established questionnaires. Although drawings can be helpful in art therapy when people find it difficult to use words, we suggest that therapists and researchers exercise caution in how they use the Bird's Nest Drawing (even with stories) until it can be further developed as an assessment measure.

Attachment representations of school-aged Korean children: comparing family drawing and narrative assessments in a clinical and a community sample

A Correlation Study between Early Nurturing Experience and Mother-child Attachment Level

Attachment-Based Classifications of Children's Family Drawings: Psychometric Properties and Relations With Children's Adjustment in Kindergarten

AN EVALUATION OF ATTACHMENT STATUS OF 6-YEARS-OLD CHILDREN IN STUDIES INVOLVING INCOMPLETE DOLL FAMILY STORY SCALE TURKISH SAMPLE

Assessing both safe haven and secure base support in parent–child relationships

A Comparison of Attachment in Adolescents of Mainland China and Malaysia

Representations of the child's social behavior and attachment to the kindergarten teacher in their drawing

Attachment Representation and Emotion Recognition Ability in Children with ADHD and Their Parents: A Study Protocol

Patterns of attachment in adulthood and rearing style

Using Semi-Projective Doll Play Methods to Classify Middle Childhood Children Into Four Attachment Types: Types Associations With Distinctive Psychosocial Adaptation

The predictive validity of the strange situation procedure: Evidence from registered analyses of two landmark longitudinal studies

The bird's nest drawing and accompanying stories in the assessment of attachment security

A meta-analysis of the distribution of preschool and early childhood attachment as assessed in the strange situation procedure and its modified versions

Are narrative story stem methods valid in "non-Western" contexts? A systematic review

Differences in Problem Behaviors, School Adjustment and Home Environment according to profiles of Parental Depression and Socioeconomic status

Mothers' Attachment Representations and Children's Brain Structure

A family systems investigation on couple emotional intimacy, parent-child relationships, and child social skills in middle childhood

Maternal secure base scripts, children's attachment security, and mother-child narrative styles

ADHD Symptoms in Middle Childhood: The Role of Child Attachment and Maternal Emotional Availability in an Inpatient Clinical Sample

Classifying Korean children’s behavioral problems and their influencing factors: a latent profile analysis

Childrens' attachment story-completions and their theory of mind in three Turkish contexts: Seasonal migrant agricultural worker communities, residential group homes, and rural villages