Static and Dynamic Knee Alignment, Muscle Balance and Cartilage Composition in Young Adults
D. Kumar,S. Karupppasamy,W. Link,H. Alizai,S. Wu,K. Bauer,N. Neel,A. Luke,X. Li,R. Souza,S. Majumdar,T. M. Link
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joca.2012.02.105
IF: 7.507
2012-01-01
Osteoarthritis and Cartilage
Abstract:Purpose: Knee varus and related adduction moment (KAM) are risk factors associated with knee osteoarthritis (OA). It is unknown if these factors relate to pre-radiographic changes in cartilage composition as assessed by quantitative MR imaging of T1ρ- and T2 relaxation times. Also, since knee loading during dynamic activities is under neuromuscular control, any muscle imbalance could lead to dynamic overload in certain compartments accentuating the mechanical impact of malalignment. Muscle imbalance and altered loading patterns during walking are modifiable risk factors amenable to neuromuscular retraining interventions. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to analyze the relationship between static and dynamic knee malalignment, knee muscle cross-sectional area (CSA), and articular and meniscal cartilage composition. Methods: 33 young healthy (49 knees), active subjects, between the ages of 20-35 years, BMI < 28 kg/m2 completed 3-T MRI scans of the knee and 3-D motion capture while walking. Standard sequences were used for quantification of cartilage thickness (Th.Ct), T1ρ- and T2 relaxation times for 6 cartilage regions (medial/lateral- femoral condyle (MF/LF) tibial plateau (MT/LT), patella (P), and trochlea (TrF)), and 6 meniscus regions (anterior/body/posterior horn for medial and lateral meniscus). Medio-lateral ratios of Th.AC T1ρ- and T2 relaxation times were also calculated for tibia (T), femur (F), tibiofemoral (TF) compartment, patellofemoral (PF) compartment and global knee. Quadriceps (Q) and hamstrings (H) CSA were calculated along with medio-lateral (M:L) and Q:H muscle CSA ratios from axial T1W scans at mid-thigh. Sagittal and frontal plane kinematic (peak and excursion), kinetic (peak and rate of loading(ROL)) during stance phase of walking were calculated for each subject. Pearson's correlations were used to analyze relationships. Long limb radiographs were available from 27 knees for assessment of static alignment. Results: Static varus was associated with greater M:L ratio of articular cartilage T2. 1st and 2nd peaks of KAM and frontal plane ROL were related to high M:L ratio of meniscus T1ρ and T2 and high overall M:L ratio of Th.Ct. Frontal plane excursion and flexion excursion were related to lower TF and PF Th.Ct. In sagittal plane, peak external flexion moment was related to high articular cartilage TF T1ρ- and T2. Peak external extension moment was related to low articular cartilage T1ρ- and T2 and high T1ρ- and T2 in 4 of 6 meniscus compartments. Greater Q:H CSA ratio was related with greater TF T1ρ (r = 0.327) and T2 (r = 0.401). Greater M:L Q ratio was associated with greater M:L ratio of meniscus T1ρ (r = 0.337). Greater M:L Q ratio was associated with greater KAM peaks (r=0.357) and impulse (r=0.461), and greater frontal ROL (r= 0.303). Greater Q:H ratio was associated with greater peak frontal (r= 0.645) and sagittal moments (r = 0.360) and greater dynamic frontal malalignment (r = 0.330 Conclusions: These are the 1st results to show relationships between static/dynamic alignment, muscle balance and cartilage composition in young health subjects. Based on these data, young subjects with varus show worse medio-lateral balance of cartilage composition likely progressing to OA. The impact of static and dynamic loading is more pronounced on the meniscus than the articular cartilage indicating a more important role of meniscus in pathogenesis of knee OA than previously thought. These data also show for the 1st time that muscular imbalance (high Q:H and M:L CSA ratios) is related to high knee loads (high KAM impulse) and worse cartilage composition (high T1ρ- and T2). Overall, these data suggest the need for development of preventive programs that emphasize muscle retraining and strategies to alter medio-lateral balance of cartilage composition. We continue to process the data to assess relationship of functional mechanics with articular cartilage laminar T1ρ- and T2 relaxation times and texture values. We are also in the process of doing subregional analysis of articular cartilage in light of the findings of different relationship of flexion and extension moments with T1ρ- and T2 relaxation times.