Formal discussion of F. Teillet et al's paper, "a reappraisal of clinical and biological signs in staging of Hodgkin's disease.

H. Kaplan
IF: 11.2
1971-11-01
Cancer Research
Abstract:DepartmentofRadiology,StanfordUniversityMedicalCenter,Stanford,California94305IhaverecentlyhadoccasiontopresentaratherdetailedanalysisoflaboratorytestsasindicatorsofprognosisanddiseaseactivityinHodgkin'sdiseaseelsewhere(1).Ahostoflaboratory tests have been reported asyieldingcharacteristically abnormalvaluesinpatientswithactiveHodgkin'sdiseaseand/orreturningtonormallevelsduringperiodsofdiseasequiescence.Amongthesearethetotalwhitebloodcellcount,thepercentageoflymphocytes,theabsolutelymphocyte count,theabsoluteneutrophil count,theerythrocyte sedimentation rate, serum copper, andceruloplasmin,allofwhicharesaidtobeelevated,andtheserumzincandiron,whicharesaidtobedepressedduringdiseaseactivity.Theleukocytealkalinephosphatasehasbeenreportedtobeincreased,ashastheserummuramidase.Theserumalkalinephosphatase iselevatedunderspecialcircumstances,theheat-labilefractionbeingcharacteristicallyincreasedinthepresenceofliverdiseaseandtheheat-stablefractionreflectinginvolvementofboneorbonemarrow.Bromsulfthaleinretentionisalsonotedinthepresenceofliverdisease.Abnormalitieswhichoccurlessoftenincludeelevationofserumhaptoglobin andincreasedlevelsofseruma-glycoprotein and of hydroxyproline-rich proteins.MonoclonalgammopathyandhypogammaglobulinemiahavebeenreportedinrareinstancesofHodgkin'sdisease.Thedifficultywithallofthesetestsisthattheyareessentiallynonspecificincharacter,andsimilarabnormalitiesareencountered inavarietyofotherdiseasestates,particularlyininflammatoryandinfectiousconditions.Arecentanalysisofourowndatahassuggestedthattheerythrocytesedimentationratewasboththemostreliableand1ThepaperbyTeilletetal.wasactuallypresentedattheConferencebyDr.M.Boiron.theleastexpensiveoftheseindicatorsandwaselevatedinapproximately70%ofpatientswithpreviouslyuntreated,recentlybiopsy-provendisease.Elevationoftheserumceruloplasminwasdeterminedsimultaneouslyinthesamepatientsandwassignificantlylessoftenelevated;theserummuramidaseandleukocytealkalinephosphatasewereelevatedinonlyone-thirdtoone-fourthofthesamepatients.Accordingly,itwouldappearthatthesedimentationrateisprobablythebestofthevariouslaboratoryindicators,anditcertainlyhastheadvantageofsimplicityandinexpensiveness.Awordofcautionshouldbesounded,however,concerningtheinterpretationofelevatedvaluesofanyofthesetestsduringthefollow-upperiodinpatientswhoseHodgkin'sdiseasehasbeentreated.Althoughanelevatedsedimentationratemaywellreflectrecrudescenceofdisease,itcanequallywellindicatethepresenceofsomeintercurrentinflammatoryorinfectiouscondition.Accordingly,itshould,inmyopinion,neverbetakenasthebasisforinitiationofnewprogramsoftreatmentforpatientswithotherwisequiescentHodgkin'sdiseaseintheabsenceofsomeotherfirmdocumentaryevidence,preferablyinvolvingabiopsyofdemonstrablelesions.Thecontrarypolicyopensthewaytoiatrogeniccatastrophe;casestreatedwithchemotherapyonthebasisofanelevatedsedimentationratealonehavebeenknowntocometoautopsyasaconsequenceofsecondarycomplicationswithchemotherapyandtopresentnoevidencewhateverofthepresenceofHodgkin'sdisease.References1.Kaplan,H.S.Hodgkin'sDisease.Cambridge,Mass.:HarvardUniversityPress,inpress,1971.1730 CANCERRESEARCH VOL.31
What problem does this paper attempt to address?