Marine spatial planning to enhance coral adaptive potential
Daniel Lipshutz Forrest,Lisa C. McManus,Eden W. Tekwa,Daniel E. Schindler,Madhavi A. Colton,Michael M. Webster,Helen E. Fox,Timothy E. Essington,Stephen R. Palumbi,Peter J. Mumby,Lukas DeFilippo,Steven R. Schill,F. Joseph Pollock,Malin L. Pinsky
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1101/2024.08.27.609972
2024-08-29
Abstract:Ocean warming interacts with local stressors to negatively affect coral reefs. The adaptive capacity of reefs to survive these stressors is driven by ecological and evolutionary processes occurring at multiple spatial scales. Marine protected area (MPA) networks are one solution that can address both local and regional threats, yet the impacts of MPA network design on adaptive processes remains unclear. In this paper, we used an eco-evolutionary model to simulate hypothetical MPA configurations in the Caribbean, Southwest Pacific and Coral Triangle under projected warming. We found that protecting thermal refugia (i.e., cooler reefs) largely benefited corals inside the refugia while other reefs declined. In contrast, protecting a diverse habitat portfolio led to increased coral cover both inside and outside of the MPA network. We then quantified the thermal habitat and connectivity representations of reefs both inside and outside existing MPA networks across each region. Most strikingly, reefs in current MPA networks in the Southwest Pacific and Coral Triangle are approximately 2 degrees Celsius cooler than reefs outside the MPA networks, while the Caribbean's MPA network is approximately 1 degree Celsius warmer than reefs outside the network, based on mean temperatures from 2008-2018. These results suggest that the Caribbean MPA network is poised to protect sources of warm-adapted larvae but not destinations, and the opposite is true of the Southwest Pacific and Coral Triangle. Our results suggest that 1) by protecting sites with particular temperature and connectivity characteristics, marine spatial planning may alter eco-evolutionary processes to enhance or inhibit the adaptive capacity of a reef network and 2) the distribution, extent, and effectiveness of local interventions have the potential to affect regional distributions of coral cover beyond what would be expected from local benefits alone, due to the potentially wide-reaching effects of larval dispersal and gene flow.
Ecology