Impact of the Great Recession and Beyond Disparities in Wealth Building by Generation and Race
SIGNE-MARY MCKERNAN,CAROLINE RATCLIFFE,EUGENE STEUERLE,SISI ZHANG
2014-01-01
Abstract:This paper uses over two decades of Survey of Consumer Finances data and a pseudo-panel technique to measure the impact of the Great Recession on wealth relative to the counterfactual of what wealth would have been given wealth accumulation trajectories. Our regression-adjusted synthetic cohort-level models find that the Great Recession reduced the wealth of American families by 28.5 percent—nearly double the magnitude of previous pre-post mean descriptive estimates and double the magnitude of any previous recession since the 1980s. The housing market was only part of the story; all major wealth components fell as a result of the Great Recession. The nonpartisan Urban Institute publishes studies, reports, and books on timely topics worthy of public consideration.This research was funded by the Russell Sage Foundation, the Ford Foundation, and the Low-Income Working Families project, which is currently supported by the Annie E. Casey Foundation. We thank them for their support and acknowledge that the findings and conclusions presented are those of the authors alone, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the foundations, the Urban Institute, its board of trustees, or its sponsors. The authors are grateful to Doug Wissoker for excellent econometric advice and for the valuable audience participant input at the Russell Sage Foundation seminar, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation 3rd Annual Consumer Research Symposium, and the Urban Institute Low-Income Working Families and Opportunity and Ownership seminar. Impact of the Great Recession and Beyond With few assets to draw from in case of a financial emergency, many American families were in a vulnerable position at the onset of the Great Recession. The precipitous drop in home values and the sharp rise in unemployment that came about with the Great Recession made matters worse. By 2010, one out of every five US families (20 percent) was asset poor, up from 16 percent in 2007.1 Many families lost their homes through foreclosure. Family wealth was also lost through the stock market decline, and some families made early withdrawals (or made fewer deposits) from retirement savings to weather unemployment. Each of these events further weakened the economic security of American families. This paper uses over two decades of Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) triennial data to examine wealth changes in the context of the life cycle and compare the Great Recession with prior recessions. We use synthetic cohorts to construct pseudo-panel data based on the SCF’s repeated cross-sections to measure the impact of the Great Recession on wealth relative to the counterfactual of what wealth would have been given wealth accumulation trajectories. We examine changes in total wealth, as well as its major components, to better understand which components drove the total wealth changes. Wealth accumulation patterns differ across generations and racial/ethnic groups, so we estimate the effect of the Great Recession on different cohort groups (i.e., generations) and by race/ethnicity. In a literature dominated by studies using pre-post descriptive methods, this paper contributes by measuring the impact of the Great Recession on family wealth (1) within the context of life cycle wealth accumulation, (2) relative to prior business cycles, (3) by major wealth component, and (4) while controlling for educational attainment and other socioeconomic characteristics. 1 A family is categorized as asset poor if it does not have enough resources, measured as total wealth, to live at the federal poverty level for three months. This translates into $5,580 for a family of four in 2010 (Ratcliffe and Zhang 2012).