Abstract:Context A fundamental assumption behind a high stakes accountability system is that standardized testing, proficiency goal setting for demographic student subgroups, and sanctions would motivate teachers to focus on students whose performance had heretofore lagged. Students with disabilities became one such subgroup under the No Child Left Behind system. Special education teachers faced a novel pressure: to radically narrow the achievement gap between their students with disabilities towards proficiency or incur sanctions and corrective action for their schools and districts. Purpose The study uses the concept of “integrity” to analyze public service workers’ agency in situations of strain or crisis. Integrity consists of four overlapping domains of judgment: obligations of office, personal integrity, client needs, and prudence. Research Design The study is an in-depth multiple case study of seven teachers; 21 structured interviews, and 17 observations, augmented by a number of informal contact that included invitations to observe teacher meetings and conversations with school administrators. Findings The study found that the special education teachers faced a true dilemma. Teachers adopted contradictory solutions — some embraced the new demands, some rejected them. Both seemed equally untenable. The study reveals salient dimensions of this dilemma: how teachers related to the external moral obligation to equalize, what they chose to ‘see’ when they viewed the achievement gap; how they explained, or explained away, their agency in narrowing the gap; how they strategized and muddled through with instructional maneuvers to make the gap go away; and what they regarded, and guarded, as fields of professional responsibility and autonomous decision making. Implications What kind of accountability system would enable a collective dialogue among special education teachers in which high expectations, keen diagnosis, instructional expertise, internal responsibility for individualized learning gains, openness to external challenge, and attention to results would be the poles of the discussion? At the core, such an accountability system would validate the professionalism of the most expert teachers and avoid activating their defensiveness and demoralization. It would guard against middling expectations by making the performance of a wide spectrum of high and low performing schools or special education departments transparent. It would stay away from high pressure attached to unrealistic goals in order to discourage teachers from developing blind spots about their students, or acting with mere compliance and expediency. It would motivate a dynamic of student-centered continuous improvement in reference to a common standard, but also to low-stakes metrics that may guide iterative improvement.

Commentary: The Tyranny of Time and the Reality Principle

Achieving Better Educational Practices Through Research Evidence: A Critical Analysis and Case Illustration of Benefits and Challenges

Instruction in high schools: the evidence and the challenge

From Evidence to Impact: Joining Our Best School Mental Health Practices with Our Best Implementation Strategies

Sisyphean neoliberal reforms: the intractable mythology of student growth and achievement master narratives within the testing and TFA era

When the Achievement Gap Becomes High Stakes for Special Education Teachers: Facing a Dilemma with Integrity

The student, the text, and the classroom context: A case study of teacher response

Reflecting on decades of teacher expectations and teacher effectiveness research: considerations for current and future research

A Researcher Goes to School: Using Technology in the Kindergarten Literacy Curriculum

Tier I implementation supports for classroom management: A pilot investigation targeting teachers' praise

Teaching Against the Grain: One Title I School's Journey Toward Project-Based Literacy Instruction

The search for evidence-based features of effective teacher professional development: a critical analysis of the literature

Taking risks with a growth mindset: long-term influence of an elementary pre-service after school science practicum

Sustaining BEST in CLASS: Teacher-Reported Evidence-Based Practice Use with Students at Risk for Emotional and Behavioral Disorders Amidst the COVID-19 Pandemic

Advancing Educational Policy by Advancing Research on Instruction

Considering the implementation research-to-practice gap: An experimental evaluation of intervention-general methods for assessing and supporting intervention fidelity through coaching

The Effects of a Structured Classroom Management System in Secondary Resource Classrooms

Factors influencing teachers' sustained implementation of a kindergarten curriculum within the United States: A qualitative analysis

What's a middle school teacher to do? Five evidence-based practices to support English learners and students with learning disabilities

Paraprofessionals' Implementation of Constant Time Delay Procedures With Elementary Students With High-Intensity Behavioral Support Needs