Culturing Consent: Science and Democracy in the Stem Cell State

Ruha Benjamin

2008-01-01

Abstract:In this dissertation I examine the political struggles that have emerged around stem cell research by focusing on the institutions and collectives that vie for material and symbolic resources in the context of California's state-funded stem cell initiative. I ask what factors determine what collectives have their demands engaged and rendered legitimate, and what collectives have their demands ignored and rendered illegitimate by the state stem cell agency. Culturing Consent posits that cultivating a sufficiently supportive public is as vital to the Initiative as culturing stem cells in the lab, but that this' public support'is predicated on excluding and delegitimizing antagonistic publics from this social field. I examine the processes whereby these exclusions are produced. I find that stem cell" insiders" are those contestants whose demands resonate with the neoliberal ethos of autonomy and choice that undergird the Initiative and the human tissue economy of which it is a part. Stem cell" outsiders" are those contestants whose demands appeal to social disorder as the primary source of dis-ease thereby seeking to expand the political scope of the stem cell debate. This study contributes to an understanding of how the transformed conditions of