Abstract:Olfactory bulb activity has been postulated to be chaotic, as measured in the EEG, and to be subject to an attractor with many "wings" enabling classification of different learned odor classes. Two parallel questions are thus addressed by the work presented here: (1) what is the evidence for attractors in the olfactory system, which can mediate learned odor classes? and (2) how does the olfactory system enter a specific attractor or attractor wing associated with the learned odor during the classification process? Both of these questions address the wider notion of endogenous activity preparing the system for an expected stimulus, which is at the basis of the reafference principle. By viewing the brain as a distributed complex dynamical system with global attractors, these questions can be answered together. Rats were implanted with bipolar macroelectrodes in the Olfactory Bulb (OB), Prepyriform Cortex (PPC), Entorhinal Cortex (EC), and Dentate Gyrus (DG), and then trained in an operant paradigm to press a bar for a reward in the presence of one odor and to receive no reward in the presence of another odor. Local Field Potentials (LFP) were recorded simultaneously from the structures during the operant task. We present evidence for three endogenous events: (1) preafference, which is manifested both by the EC entering an attractor and a mid-range signal (15-30 Hz) which appears to be passed from the EC to the OB just before the OB enters an attractor; (2) afference, where the OB enters an attractor during the odor recognition period of the experiment and the LFP recordings indicate that the OB drives the other structures in all frequency bands, especially the high gamma band (65-100 Hz) associated with the OB burst frequency; and (3) reafference or post-afference, which is accompanied by a lower frequency gamma band signal (40-60 Hz) originating in the PPC and passed to both the OB and the EC just before the onset of the motor response to the odor. We use a new method, NECTAR (Nonparametric Exact Contingency Table Association Routine), related to mutual information, to verify what is seen with coherence and phase estimates, the apparent driving of each structure at different times in the odor trials, and to display evidence for non-periodic attractors governing both individual physiological structures and the system of structures. This is the first evidence of an endogenous, limbic event associated with sensory perceptual tuning in a mammal. These results are also the first experimental confirmation that the attractors governing olfactory activity involve multiple sites in the olfactory/limbic system and implement the process of attention.

Smelling Time: A Neural Basis for Olfactory Scene Analysis

A Bio-Inspired Olfactory Model Using Hierarchical Temporal Memory

Mammalian Odor Information Recognition by Implanted Microsensor Array in Vivo

Timing matters in olfaction

Decoding Olfactory Bulb Output: A Behavioral Assessment of Rate, Synchrony, and Respiratory Phase Coding

Sniff Olfactometry: Temporal effects on odorant mixture perception in humans

Disorder and the neural representation of complex odors: smelling in the real world

High-speed odor transduction and pulse tracking by insect olfactory receptor neurons

Odors in space

Metabolic activity organizes olfactory representations

Olfactory bulb tracks breathing rhythms and place in freely behaving mice

Odors in olfactory bulb are defined by a short discrete temporal sequence: recognition by brute-force conversion to a spatial pattern (chunking)

Reafference and attractors in the olfactory system during odor recognition

Odor Encoding as an Active, Dynamical Process: Experiments, Computation, and Theory

Human olfactory perception embeds fine temporal resolution within a single sniff

Data Science In Olfaction

Human Olfactory Perception is Sensitive to Temporal Information within a Single Sniff

Odour encoding in olfactory neuronal networks beyond synchronization.

Olfactory object recognition based on fine-scale stimulus timing in Drosophila

Common principles for odour coding across vertebrates and invertebrates

Challenges in inferring breathing rhythms from olfactory bulb local field potentials