Convergent evolution of bright coloration and toxicity in frogs

K. Summers
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2335928100
2003-10-20
Abstract:Brightly colored organisms abound in nature, and the evolutionary forces underlying this profusion of color have been the subject of scientific interest ever since Darwin. Aposematism, where color and pattern serve as advertisements of unprofitability to predators, is one of the main mechanisms thought to generate selection in favor of bright coloration and contrasting pattern. The theoretical underpinnings of aposematism, particularly the mechanisms whereby new bright mutants become established in a population, remain the subject of considerable interest (1). On an empirical level, a basic prediction is that brightly colored organisms will be unpalatable. Although many brightly colored organisms have proven to be toxic (2), the hypothesis of aposematism further predicts that the evolution of toxicity will occur before, or in tandem with, the evolution of bright coloration. Testing this prediction requires information on the evolutionary relationships of the species involved. Few studies have concomitantly analyzed the historical trajectories of both coloration and toxicity, thereby identifying the evolutionary sequence and association of both traits (3). In this issue of PNAS, Santos et al. (4) use phylogenetic analysis to investigate the evolution of coloration and toxicity in poison frogs of the family Dendrobatidae. The poison frogs of South America and Central America (toxic members of the family Dendrobatidae) provide a well known example of bright coloration associated with toxicity (in this case, the presence of lipophilic alkaloids in the skin) (5). The dendrobatids are a species-rich taxon (>200 species) with both brightly colored and cryptic members (Fig. 1). Traditionally, the brightly colored species were thought to form a monophyletic group, mainly on the basis of shared toxins (6). Most cryptic species were placed in the genus Colostethus although no shared derived characteristics united them (7). Colostethus has now been divided into several genera, but their phylogenetic relationships remain poorly understood (7 …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?