Abstract:Introduction: Like many countries around the world, Scotland faces a shortage of general practitioners (GPs) due to both recruitment and retention issues. Such workforce shortages are of particular concern in rural areas. There are many reasons why GPs are leaving general practice; however, satisfaction with working life is an important predictor of GP retention. It is important, therefore, to understand working life satisfaction of rural GPs. The purpose of this study was to compare the working lives and intentions to reduce work participation of rural GPs and GPs working elsewhere in Scotland. Methods: This study was a quantitative analysis of survey data from the Scottish School of Primary Care national working lives survey. GPs were classified as working in 'non-rural' or 'rural' practices based on the Scottish Government's rural binary classification system, and were compared using univariate and multivariate statistical analysis on four domains of working lives: job satisfaction, job stressors, positive and negative job attributes, and four intentions to reduce work participation: reducing working hours, working abroad, leaving direct patient care and leaving medical work entirely. Results: A total of 2465 GPs returned the survey, giving a response rate of 56%. Three-hundred and forty seven GPs who returned the survey worked in practices in rural areas (14.1%). Rural GPs were more likely to do out-of-hours work (p<0.001), to have worked in their practice for fewer years (p=0.014), to work in single-GP partnerships (p<0.001), and to work in practices with smaller list sizes (p<0.001), than GPs in non-rural settings. Compared with GPs elsewhere, rural GPs reported higher mean job satisfaction (5.23 v 5.39, respectively; p<0.005), lower mean job stressors (3.58 v 3.29; p<0.001) and lower mean negative job attributes (4.08 vs 3.78; p<0.001). These differences remained highly significant after controlling for potential confounders (age, gender and the differences in work practices shown above). In regression analysis, a significant interaction was found between gender and rurality for job satisfaction (p=0.008), which indicated that rural female GPs' higher job satisfaction mainly accounted for rural GPs' increased job satisfaction. No significant interaction was found between gender and rurality for the other domains of working lives. Compared with GPs elsewhere, however, rural GPs were more likely to intend to work abroad (mean 1.39 v 1.55; p=0.013) and leave medical work entirely within 5 years (mean 2.15 v 2.36; p=0.039). These intentions remained significant after controlling for potential confounders. No significant interaction was found between gender and rurality for variables for intentions to reduce work participation. Conclusion: Rural GPs in Scotland are more satisfied with their working lives than GPs working elsewhere in Scotland, which is mainly due to higher job satisfaction in female GPs in rural areas. Despite this, rural GPs as a whole have a higher intention to leave their job in the next 5 years than their non-rural counterparts. Although some of these differences are small, they may signal serious implications for the future care of patients in rural areas and require further research to understand the drivers of this.

[Reasons for General Practitioner Shortage – a Comparison Between France and Switzerland]

Dealing with the doctor shortage: a qualitative study exploring French general practitioners’ lived experiences, difficulties, and adaptive behaviours

How general practitioners in France are coping with increased healthcare demand and physician shortages. A panel data survey and hierarchical clustering.

Investigation and analysis of the factors of general practice research requirements

Comparing GPs according to their model of practice: are multiprofessional group practices associated with more favourable working conditions?

Measuring workload of Swiss general practice: a five-yearly questionnaire-based survey on general practitioners' self-reported working activities (2005-2020)

Which positive factors give general practitioners job satisfaction and make general practice a rewarding career? A European multicentric qualitative research by the European general practice research network

[Development and consequences of physician shortages in Bavaria]

How can primary care be secured in the long term? – a qualitative study from the perspective of general practitioners in Germany

Effective policy mechanisms for an equitable geographical distribution of general practitioners: a qualitative comparative analysis of the accessibility of primary care in Europe

Which positive factors determine the GP satisfaction in clinical practice? A systematic literature review

A Response to the Commentary Entitled: "addressing the Shortage of Health Professionals in Rural China: Issues and Progress".

Attractiveness of medical disciplines amongst Swiss first-year medical students allocated to different medical education tracks: cross-sectional study

Revitalizing General Practice: The Critical Role of Medical Schools in Addressing the Primary Care Physician Shortage

WORK–LIFE BALANCE OF GENERAL PRACTITIONERS IN GERMANY CONSIDERING RECENT REGULATIONS

Regional socioeconomic characteristics and density of general practitioners in Germany: A nationwide cross-sectional and longitudinal spatial analysis

Emergency physicians accumulate more stress factors than other physicians-results from the French SESMAT study

The layered crisis of the primary care medical workforce in the European region: what evidence do we need to identify causes and solutions?

Prevalence and forms of gender discrimination and sexual harassment among medical students and physicians in French-speaking Switzerland: a survey

How do the working lives of general practitioners in rural areas compare with elsewhere in Scotland? Cross-sectional analysis of the Scottish School of Primary Care National GP Survey

[Care of patients in nursing homes, what stumbling blocks and stepping for general practitioners? A qualitative study]