Abstract:Available proxy-based temperature reconstructions covering the past millennium display contrasted evolutions between the continents. The difference is particularly large between the two hemispheres. When driven by realistic natural and anthropogenic forcings, climate models tend to simulate a more spatially homogenous temperature response. This is associated with a relatively good agreement between model results and reconstructions in the Northern Hemisphere but a low consistency in the Southern Hemisphere. Here, simulations with data assimilations are performed to analyse the causes of this apparent disagreement. It shows that, when the uncertainties are taken into account, states of the climate system compatible with the forcing estimates, the reconstructions and the model physics can be obtained over the past millennium, except for the twentieth century in Antarctica where the simulated warming is always much larger than in the reconstructions. Such states consistent with all sources of information can be achieved even if the uncertainties of the reconstructions are underestimated. Although, well within the range of the proxy-based reconstructions, the temperatures obtained after data assimilation display more similar developments between the hemispheres than in those reconstructions. Ensuring the compatibility does not require to systematically reduce the model response to the forcing or to strongly enhance the model internal variability. From those results, there is thus no reason to suspect that the model is strongly biased in one aspect or another. The constraint imposed by the data assimilation is too low to unambiguously identify the origin of each feature displayed in the reconstructions but, as expected, changes in atmospheric circulation likely played a role in many of them. Furthermore, ocean heat uptake and release as well as oceanic heat transport are key elements to understand the delayed response of the Southern Hemisphere compared to the northern one during some transitions from warmer to colder states or from colder to warmer ones. The last millennium is thus an interesting test period to better understand and quantify the associated mechanisms.

Reconstruction of Patagonia's glacial history informs key global climate drivers

Near-synchronous Northern Hemisphere and Patagonian Ice Sheet variation over the last glacial cycle

Onset and Evolution of Southern Annular Mode-Like Changes at Centennial Timescale

Effects of Slab-Window, Alkaline Volcanism, and Glaciation on Thermochronometer Cooling Histories, Patagonian Andes

Summer Insolation Controlled Movements of Intertropical Convergence Zone During Last Glacial Cycle in Northern South America

Anti-phase glacier fluctuations on the millennial-scale on the southern Tibetan Plateau and New Zealand during the last glacial period

Precipitation drives western Patagonian glacier variability and may curb future ice mass loss

Quantifying Tectonic and Glacial Controls on Topography in the Patagonian Andes (46.5°S) from Integrated Thermochronometry and Thermo‐Kinematic Modeling

Multiple late Holocene glacier advances on the sub-Antarctic Kerguelen (49°S) islands: Evidence from a 1200 yr sediment core from a glacial threshold basin

Southern Annular Mode-like changes in southwestern Patagonia at centennial timescales over the last three millennia

Quaternary Glaciation and Hydrologic Variation in the South American Tropics As Reconstructed from the Lake Titicaca Drilling Project

Mapping of morainic complexes and reconstruction of glacier dynamics north-east of Cook Ice Cap, Kerguelen Archipelago (49°S)

Geodynamic and Climatic Forcing on Late‐Cenozoic Exhumation of the Southern Patagonian Andes (Fitz Roy and Torres del Paine massifs)

Chronology of Late Pleistocene glacial advances in a Mount Mercedario catchment, Subtropical Andes of Argentina (32° S)

Geologically constrained 2-million-year-long simulations of Antarctic Ice Sheet retreat and expansion through the Pliocene

Reconstructed and simulated temperature asymmetry between continents in both hemispheres over the last centuries

Hydrographic shifts in coastal waters reflect climate-driven changes in hydrological regimes across Northwestern Patagonia

Patagonian dust, Agulhas Current, and Antarctic ice-rafted debris contributions to the South Atlantic Ocean over the past 150,000 years

Tropical Andean climate variations since the last deglaciation

Tectonic Control on Rock Uplift, Exhumation, and Topography above an Oceanic Ridge Collision: Southern Patagonian Andes (47°S), Chile