Lap-Kei Lee,Xiaodong Wei,Kwok Tai Chui,Simon K. S. Cheung,Fu Lee Wang,Yin-Chun Fung,Angel Lu,Yan Keung Hui,Tianyong Hao,Leong Hou U,Nga-In Wu
Abstract:The recent integration of educational technologies and emerging learning approaches into education systems has been driven largely by the pandemic. This paper conducts a systematic review and delves into the new wave of research on serious games designed for innovative learning using augmented reality (AR), virtual reality (VR), and mixed reality (MR). The review was referenced to the review protocol, PRISMA 2020. Using the Scopus Database with a time filter from 2007 to 2023 (27 July), we searched 329 articles and shortlisted 273 relevant studies. Notably, European countries contributed the most (62.9%) to this research area. Among the most frequent keywords, VR (90.9%) was commonly used in AR/VR/MR, while e-learning (95.3%) was among the popular innovative learning approaches. Further research studies are needed to employ AR and MR technologies, as well as other innovative learning approaches, to enable performance evaluation and comparison of various educational technologies and learning approaches. We conducted an in-depth analysis of the relevant studies and their basic characteristics. Additionally, we introduced 15 essential and recently published AR/VR/MR standards to ensure better reliability, quality, and safety of architectures, systems, products, services, and processes. To facilitate performance evaluation and analysis, we surveyed 15 recently published benchmark education datasets. This review suggested four future research directions, including multisensory experiences, generative artificial intelligence, personalization and customization, and real-time interaction.
engineering, electrical & electronic,computer science, information systems,physics, applied
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### Problems the Paper Aims to Address
This paper aims to explore and analyze the current state of research on designing serious games in innovative learning using Augmented Reality (AR), Virtual Reality (VR), and Mixed Reality (MR) through a Systematic Review. Specifically, the paper attempts to address the following key issues:
1. **Research Status and Trends**:
- In recent years, the integration of educational technology and emerging learning methods has been significantly driven by the pandemic. Through a systematic review, the paper summarizes research from 2007 to 2023 on using AR, VR, and MR to design serious games to promote innovative learning.
- By analyzing the basic characteristics of these studies, such as the number of publications, distribution of literature types, distribution by country and region, and distribution by academic field, the paper reveals the trends and development directions of the research.
2. **Technology Application and Effect Evaluation**:
- The paper explores the specific applications of AR, VR, and MR in education, including how these technologies provide safe and controlled virtual environments for learners to practice skills and acquire knowledge.
- By comparing the effects of different technologies (AR, VR, MR), the paper evaluates their application effects in different learning modes (such as online learning, agile learning, hybrid learning).
3. **Standards and Norms**:
- To ensure the reliability, quality, and safety of related architectures, systems, products, services, and processes, the paper introduces 15 important AR/VR/MR standards.
- These standards help improve the repeatability, interoperability, and compatibility of research, thereby supporting high-quality learning environments.
4. **Future Research Directions**:
- The paper proposes four future research directions, including multi-sensory experiences, generative artificial intelligence, personalization and customization, and real-time interaction.
- These directions aim to further explore and optimize the application of AR, VR, and MR in innovative learning to enhance learning outcomes and user experience.
### Summary
In summary, this paper comprehensively analyzes the current state of research on designing serious games in innovative learning using AR, VR, and MR through a systematic review. It highlights the strengths and weaknesses of current research and proposes future research directions. This not only helps the academic community better understand the latest developments in this field but also provides important references for the further development of educational technology.