Accounting and control: a case study of resistance to accounting change

Robert W. Scapens,John Roberts
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1006/mare.1993.1001
IF: 4.344
1993-03-01
Management Accounting Research
Abstract:This paper describes a case study which traces the introduction of a new accounting control system into the unit companies of a division of a large multidivisional company and explores the antecedents and consequences of the resistance encountered by the project development team. The objectives of the study are to explore the complex web of social processes which comprise accounting change, to illustrate their historical and contingent character, and to illustrate how the process of change can inadvertently create the conditions which defeat the content of the change. It is important not to dismiss resistance to accounting change as illogical and emotional. Such resistance is probably informed by a whole variety of very real concerns and fears. It is only by exploring the organisational and historical contingencies which influence the process of accounting change that resistance can be understood. In this case we see how, in an organisation characterised by an ambiguous form of decentralisation, the failure to secure the legitimacy of a new system, coupled with an inability to find a workable relationship between the languages of production and accounting, lead to resistance to accounting change.
management,business, finance
What problem does this paper attempt to address?