Is the working capital channel of the monetary policy quantitatively relevant? A structural estimation approach

Hamilton Galindo Gil
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/s1365100524000233
2024-06-02
Macroeconomic Dynamics
Abstract:Is the working capital channel big, and does it vary across industries? To answer this question, I estimate a dynamic stochastic macro-finance model using firm-level data. In aggregate, I find a partial channel —about three-fourths of firms' labor bill are borrowed. However, the strength of this channel varies across industries, reaching as low as one-half for retail firms and as high as one for agriculture and construction. This provides evidence that monetary policy could have varying effects across industries through the working capital channel.
economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper attempts to explore the practical significance of the "working capital channel" in monetary policy and analyze the heterogeneous effects of this channel across different industries. #### Research Background and Motivation - **Research Question**: Is the working capital channel strong enough? Does it vary across different industries? - **Research Method**: The authors address these questions by constructing a dynamic stochastic macro-financial model and using firm-level data for structural estimation. #### Main Findings - **Overall Findings**: Overall, the working capital channel partially exists—approximately three-quarters of firms' labor costs are paid through borrowing. - **Industry Differences**: The strength of the working capital channel varies across industries, being the lowest in retail (about half) and nearly fully dependent on borrowing in agriculture and construction (almost 100%). - **Policy Impact**: These results indicate that the impact of monetary policy through the working capital channel significantly differs across industries. #### Economic Mechanism - **Role of Firm Cash**: Firms typically use cash to meet short-term needs and supplement short-term loans. The precautionary motive drives firms to accumulate cash during unfavorable economic conditions to cope with adverse situations such as rising short-term interest rates. - **Working Capital Channel Mechanism**: An increase in interest rates leads to a marginal increase in the cost of production inputs, causing firms to reduce their demand for working capital and lower production. If firms have sufficient cash to meet their working capital needs, they do not need to borrow, thereby weakening the impact of interest rates on firm decisions. #### Conclusion - This paper fills the gap in the existing literature regarding the quantification of the working capital channel's relevance and industry heterogeneity, emphasizing the importance of understanding the magnitude of this channel, which is crucial for understanding the effects of monetary policy.